I have also clarified this a few times. I am NOT gunning for galzria in the beginning. The eevee argument does not point at Galzria as a specific scum. It does however show I suspect Galzria more than PPS, which was something I wanted to hide at that time. And I only went on Galzria when somehow his response to the reveal of my eevee theory was beyond my expectation of a townie.
Now I find Galzria's lack of posting at times (like immediately prior to the fight) to be very suspicious and am not a huge fan of him switching between you, Eevee, and manda, but I honestly would say he has given me a better town vibe than you have. And both of you look scummier than manda and Eevee in this whole dispute.
This is interesting... because I seem to remember that you have said otherwise. What changed your thoughts?
Regarding the first quoted section: I may be wrong, but I was under the impression that you brought up manda and myself as a way to see Galzria's response and possibly use this against him. So this is
before your Eevee theory, which as stated, I dislike for other reasons. So, in a sense, you were gunning for him from the start, though this was unrelated to your case on Eevee's innocence.
As for why I changed my mind: Mainly the two reasons I have stated. They just seem like something the Mafia would plan for during the night:
"Hey, I think one of us should gun for someone right off of the bat."
"But who should you gun for? What should I do?
"I'd say you should stay back and lay low. How does me hunting for Galzria sound?"
"Good, but don't make it too obvious."
"Alright, I'll start off looking towards a few others and use his reaction against him."
Galzria, meanwhile, just seems to call out the breadcrumb. I don't find his play to be all that great, but I dislike your argument against him. It makes sense, yes, but it is very self-centered. Outside of some of his points against you, the only thing that makes him scummy is his more recent wagon-switching in order to get
someone lynched. And I can justify this as trying to avoid a no-lynch. Meanwhile, I admit that it is ridiculous that it took so long for him to see your side in your argument with him, but I can see why he was so outraged. This is not to say I agreed with his stance. I merely understood how he took said stance.
So, I'll do the typical exercise: from Mafia to town: Shark_Bait, timchen, Galzria, pingpongsam, manda, Eevee, Young Nick. Shark_Bait is a bit of a separate case from you two and his should be discarded because no one seems to care. It won't help towards a lynch. My thoughts against him are not due to lurkiness but his play prior to that. As stated earlier, pingpongsam has been the enabler for your argument. I understand his play style is to spark up responses like these, but I can see it as Mafia trying to invoke chaos. manda and Eevee are relatively equal in my book. For some reason I don't have much of a read on Eevee despite his contributions throughout d2. A re-reading of some of his posts would be nice. That he really tried to reign timchen in during his emotional phase where he gave his own (timchen's) vote to Galzria is noteworthy, even if I can not yet say if that is a Mafia or town maneuver.
Some re-reading (especially of manda and Eevee) and posting of my d2 iPad observations are next on my to-do list, and hopefully I can do both before the lynch deadline.