Wierdest...game....ever.
That's my take. Consider:
5 Black Markets purchased. Total cards purchased from Black Market: Caravan, Horse Traders, Crossroads, and... Pearl Diver??
Total cash purchased, other than potions: two Silvers, one Gold--on T14?!
Multiple Feasts purchased at $4, with intent to grab Wharves, but none used for Silvers.
Despite a major engine available, no player shows intent to build to Provinces or Colonies.
No offense, but were both players drunk here?