I believe I stated my opinions on the last page. I'm honestly left unsure about you, Galz. I wouldn't be surprised if you and Pops are bussing each other, either. You're both very experienced players, you both have very different views and one getting the other lynched would look very town. But I also expect you'd both know such a conclusion would be suggested, and so the WIFOM starts.
Pops recent posts also happen to have done something towards convincing me of my suspicions. Town lying is perfectly legitimate, and can work. Like many reasons for policy lynching, 'lynch all liars' is a good way for a community to stop creative play and hinder the towns chances in difficult games. And his recent post, uhh... I'm really struggling to see that as a reason that can be taken seriously, even if it was posted earlier. Short posts don't tell us much, they don't let you do analysis, they intentionally limit the amount you're saying in the game and thus limit the amount of information flowing in the game. Now tell me, who would want to do that, mafia or town? Hmm. And your justification is that it lets a small number of players stay caught up. Which doesn't really work once we hit a point where posts are made at a rate of like a hundred per day. It just means they have one less person's posts to read.
Author
Topic: Mafia IV: Within These Estate Walls (GAME OVER - MAFIA WINS!) (Read 335014 times)