For the record, I don't think Axxle investigated you. I'm pretty sure he revealed (the next day) that he had investigated Eevee for that crucial night.
Here is the link to a
MIII day 1 spreadsheet I made, charting all (IMO) significant posts made by everyone. Post number is included in parentheses, though I may have forgotten to include it a few times. But it's sorted by page number per row, so posts can still be easily found. I compiled it during Night 1 before deciding who to jail.
While it was nice for tracking individual actions, it didn't help a lot with seeing player interactions until the late game when there weren't many players left.
Something I learned from making the list -- it is very easy for townies to get lost and to make mistakes. When Galz first posted his case against jo, I believed it. But as the day continued, other arguments creeped in and, next thing I knew, I incorrectly remembered that I thought Galz's case against jo was weak. If Mafia had dug up that contradiction, that would have made me extremely suspicious. I believe I fessed up to my unwitting change of heart on day 2, as it was better than waiting for Mafia to catch it.
I also noticed that Robz seemed to contradict himself as well. If he hadn't been killed, I would have been after him. The thing was that early on in the day he seemed to be against no lynch, but by the end he was advocating it. I think I actually did this too though!
Did anyone find the jailkeeper tell I left on day 1? It was very subtle and I wasn't even sure of the legality of it, in that it treads kind of close to the "no cryptography" rule. But I figured that rule was mostly in place to keep Mafia from communicating during the day, and I didn't have to reveal my secret unless absolutely required.
Major props to Robz and Galz for having such scarily accurate reads on day 1. It's too bad that those reads got you killed. On the plus side, it proves that catching Mafia isn't purely chance, nor are town powers required.
In parallel, I think I only managed to stay alive through the early nights because I had such
bad reads on people. I was most suspicious of Dsell by far, and I continued to doubt O even when others had cleared him. I made lots of mistakes early on. We could have had a more productive day 2, and we should have realized something was wrong with the Morgrim wagon (although "they're all bussing him" was plausible, I think). I definitely got lucky on jailing yuma when it mattered most. I think my Eevee jail after that was a good WIFOM play.
Definitely misread Volt's doctor "tell". Funny that Dsell saw it too and thought it was a Mafia tactic, when apparently Volt did it by accident.
After reading the QT, I'm surprised I was so suspicious throughout. But hey, 50/50 is actually right where you want to be, right? Enough to survive day and night.
Author
Topic: Mafia III: In a shelter among beggars (GAME OVER, TOWN WINS) (Read 175864 times)