I agree with you. I don't strongly suspect Axxle, just wanted to point out that he's not rock-solid town yet. I am also suspicious of Morgrim and wish we could hear from him. I'm really hoping that one of our roles besides Axxle had some success and just hasn't seen this yet.
And I would argue that Eevee was in fact Robz' main target for at least part of the time. Towards the end of the day, he was rallying to get Eevee lynched but not me. Another difference: Eevee jumped on the Robz bandwagon whereas I started it (at a time when there was absolutely zero suspicion of Robz). I'm not saying that Robz must be right because he was a townie and he's dead, he's completely wrong about suspecting me. But I think that in light of Eevee's opportunistic-looking voting and his "I'm a noob" attitude, he could have been on to something. Add to that Eevee comes out swinging against me day 2, and it makes me somewhat suspicious.
Also even though I really got a townie read day 1 on Voltgloss, I'm now less sure. Turns out his strong cases were against two non-mafias (he wouldn't have known jo was SK day 1). They were quite strong at the time, but I have to second guess now.
Robz held both you and Eevee as suspicious and went after the latter because he already had a vote on him, whereas nobody else was suspicious of you at all. You said Eevee came out swinging against you on day 2. I went to find that quote, and here it is:
@Dsell
It really looks like you are trying to make everyone forget what happened between you and Robz yesterday. How does everyone else feel about Dsell's analysis that just starts "well, because I am town, ..."?? Seems to me like you are trying to make everyone assume that before anyone remembers to suspect you.
Too tired to start writing a longer post now.
First, that isn't exactly a major attack. And Eevee has a point -- even now you are glossing over the fact that Robz was quite suspicious of you, instead focusing on what Robz had said against Eevee. This isn't a new thing either. Very early on day 2, you posted this:
[parts of this post snipped for brevity]
OK, so I guess a big question is why Robz?
That is my question too. It seems like a very odd choice because I was very suspicious of him (sorry Robz 
), and I probably would have still been suspicious of him day 2. It could be to throw suspicion on Eevee, or it could even be that the mafia were worried about his strong suspicion of Eevee (i.e. Eevee is mafia).
And this:
I almost want to think they killed him because they thought he was a power role. He really doesn't seem like a great strategic choice. However, I think we should go on the assumption that there was strategic motivation because we don't get any information by assuming they were looking for a power role. It's possible the mafia is trying to confuse us.
I think that this kill should either make us much more or much less suspicious of Eevee. Yes, he had other suspects, but Eevee was who he was really gunning for. So either the mafia wanted to nip that suspicion in the bud (which seems like the obvious, not very sneaky play) or they want to validate his suspicions (which seems sneakier but perhaps more likely...I doubt we're working with "obvious" mafia). The first case would make Eevee mafia and the second case would make Eevee town. The mafia could have had other reasons though or they may have been really bluffing and want us to choose one of the above options.
I think all of the above should probably apply to myself to a lesser degree, as well as Voltgloss to an even lesser degree.
I think it's worth noting that you posted these
before Eevee's post. So if Eevee came out of the gates swinging for you, you did the same thing
first. Granted, you also mentioned the possiblity that they were throwing suspicion on Eevee, but your statements (especially recent) seem far more focused on Eevee being suspicious.
I think it can be a bit misleading to focus solely on the votes. I compiled the list because it's helpful, but it's important that we also look at the actual posts that were made as well. On that front, I saw far more posts from you that felt off to me than I did from anyone else (other than Morgrim, who remains the most sketchy to me). I'll have to go back and find those posts...
Author
Topic: Mafia III: In a shelter among beggars (GAME OVER, TOWN WINS) (Read 156414 times)