Oh no! I'm on the top of the suspicion list now
Knew I shouldn't have made a final vote...
Well, TINAS survived being on top of the list for a while, maybe I can too.
Good morning, you fools.
As I said over and over and over and over and over again, Theory had done nothing to make himself particularly suspicious, other than accusing who actually was suspicious.
Theory voters, you've got some explaining to do. That's Axxle, Davio, O, TINAS, and Ftl. It's essentially a certainty that both mafia are among these 5 people.
As I said earlier Axxle stands out to me as someone leading the game, doing a lot of hedging, and generally acting suspiciously. And hey, I still find TINAS suspicious.
I'm not convinced that both Mafia are among those five. I'd be more like to suspect a 1-1 split between Theory and TINAS voters (unless TINAS is himself Mafia).
If both Theory and TINAS are innocent, then the mafia had nothing to gain by ganging up on one of them, and it's better to stay split. (Of course, if TINAS is Mafia, then presumably his partner didn't vote for him, given how close he came to being lynched.)
Axxle is possible. He kept talking as if he were going to vote for TINAS, but wanted someone else to actually finish the job, perhaps so as not to get stuck in the kill-an-innocent bunch like the five of us did? I need to go back and see whether TINAS/Axxle is possible as a mafia pairing - did Axxle jump on the bandwagon once it looked to be certain? Or was he there from the beginning of it?
I am, too, suspicious of Axxle's hedging but mostly actually of Ftl. Ftl is the guy who wanted me gone because of the person I am, rather than anything game related, and then at the last minute seemed fine to swing completely the other way and drop the hammer on Theory with no real reasoning. I'd like to hear from Ftl about why he did this?
Mostly because I cooled down a little, stopped being angry, and realized that voting for someone because I don't like them would pretty much be as bad as a lot of things I dislike. (Especially after someone - O, or Ozle, I think? - basically said the same thing about me, that they didn't like how I play but that wasn't gonna make them vote for me.) Theory was the opposite option, for wanting a quick lynch of TINAS (I actually thought that Robz was much more single-minded about attacking TINAS than Theory was, but Theory seemed not to give much of a justification, like with the pitchforks comment).
Also, TINAS afterwards, after he didn't get lynched when axxle didn't vote for him, said some more reasonable things than he had said previously, or that's the impression I got.
Also, i think the killing of Theory means we are all going to find it difficult to cast the first vote on someone now!
Eh, I don't think so. Other way around, even maybe; next time, we may be less hasty to pull the trigger on someone just because they seem to have wanted to lynch first, since we were mislead before.
TINAS, TINAS, TINAS. I still dont get your style in the first day, especially the offering to vote for yourself, but not doing it. That just strikes me as plain weird behaviour. You also seemed to jump on whoever was the popular candidate against you (although this makes sense if you were trying to save yourself, but doing it because its not you, rather than who you think is Mafia strikes me as a survival instinct rather than the 'for the town' attitude i think you would normall have)
Well, to be fair, if you know you're Town, then anyone-but-you is more likely to be Mafia than you.
People who seem innocent to me:
Me
Robz maybe?
Mafia: everyone else
Maybe TINAS and Axxle at the top of the list?
Davio seems to be habitually uncommitted? I need to go back and reread and see whether he was ever really on one of the bandwagons and agitating for someone in a noticeable way or just staying hidden