At the risk of sounding information-not-analysis, just thinking through reasons to be suspicious of various people:
TINAS: Suspicious because: claiming to be ok with being lynched, roleclaiming vanilla townie, being confusing. Unsuspicious because: maybe he's just a troll. And eh, it's just words, there were no suspicious accusations or associations, getting reads on people is harder than it seems I think...
Theory: Suspicious because: spearheaded a campaign against TINAS, including seriously wanting it to end quickly and lynchingly. Unsuspicious because: it was a campaign against TINAS, and it seemed pretty honest I guess?
Ozle: Suspicious because: made Rob's accusations of TINAS and Theory's vote against TINAS into a real bandwagon by adding in a second vote, with pretty specious reasoning at the time. Unsuspicious because: Well, I reread a lot of his posts, and they seem very similar to what goes through my head, and he claimed to be a newbie and I haven't played much IRL and no forum mafia, so this behavior/talk seem pretty consistent with "newbie townie".
Davio: Suspicious because: not that many posts to go on? Unsuspicious because: Didn't he start redirecting attention from TINAS to Theory? Unless him and TINAS are in cahoots.
O: Suspicious because: He spent a while voting purely, transparently randomly... and I'm not sure whether he ever stopped, considering I'm his top suspect ever since his post came up ending with the digit '4' which landed on me. And then trying to justify that as sincere? Also, his ranking seems strange - basically everyone who's had strong convictions and accusations is high on the list, whereas people who haven't are low on it? Not suspicious because: ...not sure, actually. Because he didn't vote for TINAS?
Robz: Well, he's been very straightforward so far. He believes he had a read on TINAS and has been in favor of lynching him all along, never deviating. Perhaps a suspicious amount of confidence for a townie?
Honorable mentions to:
Popsofctown: he died first, but maybe he's coming back as a zombie to kill us all? You never know.
Me: ...right, not filling this one in, someone else can if they think I'm suspicious enough to warrant it.
...I tried to make suspicion rankings like Robz or O, but I'm being too uncertain at the moment.
TINAS, Theory, O are probably near the top.
Davio, Ozle, Robz afterwards.
Goober, Axxle, and ME unsuspicious.
Still don't feel comfortable voting for someone
Maybe I'll vote theory later tonight or something.