O, I don't disagree that there is likely a mafia or two on the early TINAS bandwagon if he is a townie. If fact I've said a couple times that I am suspicious of theory for exactly that. I would strengthen that suspicion if TINAS turns out to be a townie, and would consider it a legitimate starting point to apply pressure on day 2. Alternatively, we could go for theory right now, but if he's town, then what do we do about TINAS? We could also just wait for more people to create suspicion on themsleves, but why would anyone other than theory and TINAS make a spectacle of themselves at this point, when just lying low means we will almost surely eventually just lynch one either theory or TINAS?
Like most of us I'm getting a little frustrated with TINAS' comments, like "And I was so close. Go for it. I've said all I have to say, just keep it in mind once you know the truth." I mean, that's just not helpful and it seems to be the way most of his posts go. And now we are training him to just be silent to boot (though something tells me that wouldn't continue if he survives the day). I don't think I want to be dealing with his playstyle on day 2, day 3, and I can't see mafia killing him early on if he is town when he is obviously such a lightning rod for suspicion in the town. I think we should decide to kill him or let him live, but then with no carry-over suspicions of him moving forward or we won't be able to do anything but keep focusing on him and eventually kill him later. I don't think I can do that, so I'd like to just kill him now and move on.