Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

Mod: Are neighbors told everyone who is in the neighborhood, or do they discover it from who shows up?

The intention is that they know everyone (and I don't think in Discord it would be possible to handle it otherwise).

[Swowl]

Sunday Chore Day today ya'll sorry! Have not read, will not be able to until I wake up. But I will be back tomorrows

[jotheonah]

I’m a little lost I have to confess. I completely disagree with LaLight but I find him townie. I find EFHW scummy but I don’t think that exile is happening and it’s probably not tactically correct. Are there even any other wagons that aren’t on me? Do I need to like reread and come up with my own case or something?

[jotheonah]

In retrospect going from no mafia to three games in a row was maybe a mistake.

[Awaclus]

Do I need to like reread and come up with my own case or something?

You are allowed to vote for people without having a case.

[Awaclus]

It's a bit more effective if they don't know you don't have a case, but it does still count towards exiling them, so it's better than nothing in any case.

[jotheonah]

Do I need to like reread and come up with my own case or something?

You are allowed to vote for people without having a case.

Well yea but the trick is knowing whom to vote for you see.

[LaLight]

I’m a little lost I have to confess. I completely disagree with LaLight but I find him townie. I find EFHW scummy but I don’t think that exile is happening and it’s probably not tactically correct. Are there even any other wagons that aren’t on me? Do I need to like reread and come up with my own case or something?

honestly, I'm a little lost too. i feel like level of activity in this game is pretty low from pretty much everyone and the day ends tomorrow, so we're probably going to get a last minute exile or no exile

[LaLight]

hard to make cases, when no one posts

[LaLight]

i post, but don't make cases on me

[LaLight]

prod: Robz888

[EFHW]

Ok, vote: mcmc. Galzria suspected him and calling Cuzz's question towny was a thing I also noticed. Mcmc, maybe you can say where that thought came from?

[mcmcsalot]

Ok, vote: mcmc. Galzria suspected him and calling Cuzz's question towny was a thing I also noticed. Mcmc, maybe you can say where that thought came from?

I think I said at the time. It promoted discussion, I didn’t think of the traitor implication and otherwise thought it was something that only scum would have to potentially lie about because town didn’t have any decision’s to make regarding the modifications. So it felt like a pro-town thing to do.

[faust]

prod: Robz888

Robz888 has been prodded.

[EFHW]

Ok, vote: mcmc. Galzria suspected him and calling Cuzz's question towny was a thing I also noticed. Mcmc, maybe you can say where that thought came from?

I think I said at the time. It promoted discussion, I didn’t think of the traitor implication and otherwise thought it was something that only scum would have to potentially lie about because town didn’t have any decision’s to make regarding the modifications. So it felt like a pro-town thing to do.

Right, right, I remember that. I was wondering why you labelled it at all.

[jotheonah]

I don't think Cuzz'question is any scummy, we needed to start a conversation and this topic starter is as good as any

We did need a topic starter, but this is the kind that leads town to say too much and hand the game to scum.

EFHW, can you help me understand? How could town reveal too much? It’s not like we got any choices

I'm just speaking from experience.

Ok rereading day 1 this seems to lend some credence to EFHW being a PR. If I'm reading between the lines right.

[jotheonah]

Let's try vote: Cuzz

We had a Cuzz wagon day 1 and it wasn't a terrible idea. It kind of got derailed mainly because EFHW voted for it in a scummy way and then the wagon turned to her. But EFHW IS town, we should really look at Cuzz again.

In addition to starting the speculation about mods, Cuzz feels a little off to me from his town meta, and he seemed awfully defensive day 1 on a quite small wagon.

[Robz888]

prod: Robz888

Robz888 has been prodded.

While I understand the rules technically say prods after 24 hours, I feel a little annoyed about a prod of me being requested when 1) it was a weekend, and 2) I did have a post making a point of substance just two days ago.

I have drunkenly skimmed the messages for the last few pages so forgive me if I missed something essential but I have to say this: EFHW is overwhelmingly likely to be telling the truth, no? No counter claiim, it could get dicey for her eventually, Galz dying instead seems like clear mafia decision to kill a strong town player and leave alive a PR in order to mislead us… I would say I’m 80/20 on this being legit. If we had newbies in this game I would understand them being skeptical, but people who’ve played 20+ games on this forum should know this sort of claim is true in vast majority of cases right?

I'm going to resist the urge to vote LL out of annoyance, though.

[EFHW]

@Lalight and Didds - Why did you each react so strongly to my Cuzz vote?

[Robz888]

Mcmc is muted compared to his usual town performance, that's something. However, it feels wrong to be all like "wow you aren't MR PRO-TOWN this game, you have to get exiled."

Swowl is not telegraphing town to the same degree as usual.

WestCoastDidds' strategy of having a high posting strategy of significant non-game related materials is... typical for them, right? I would not hate a wagon there.

LaLight seems like he's worried about getting exiled at the last minute, which could be for a variety of reasons.

My familiarity with what shraeye has contributed this game is... not significant.

I am mostly just as lost as everyone else, except I think EFHW is like obv town.

[Robz888]

Oh, the Cuzz stuff. Sure. Vote: Cuzz

[LaLight]

prod: Robz888

Robz888 has been prodded.

While I understand the rules technically say prods after 24 hours, I feel a little annoyed about a prod of me being requested when 1) it was a weekend, and 2) I did have a post making a point of substance just two days ago.

I have drunkenly skimmed the messages for the last few pages so forgive me if I missed something essential but I have to say this: EFHW is overwhelmingly likely to be telling the truth, no? No counter claiim, it could get dicey for her eventually, Galz dying instead seems like clear mafia decision to kill a strong town player and leave alive a PR in order to mislead us… I would say I’m 80/20 on this being legit. If we had newbies in this game I would understand them being skeptical, but people who’ve played 20+ games on this forum should know this sort of claim is true in vast majority of cases right?

I'm going to resist the urge to vote LL out of annoyance, though.

sorry, didn't want to annoy you!

[LaLight]

what is this sudden cuzz wagon? i'll vote there for self preservation, but I'd prefer joth, WCD or Swowl any day

[LaLight]

ah, deadline is not tomorrow

[Cuzz]

Let’s try elsewhere folks