Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[AJD]

I like it when one card-shaped thing has effects that resemble those of a different type of card-shaped thing: Inheritance is basically a Project, Obelisk is kind of a Trait, Lost in the Woods is essentially an Artifact, and Plateau Shepherds resembles a Landmark. (Am I missing any?) It's interesting to see similar gameplay concepts get implemented with the tools of whatever a given expansion has as its gimmick.

[J Reggie]

There's also cards that could be a different type without many changes. HoP could easily be a night card, and Landing Party feels like a reserve card for instance. Of course there would be some differences in those cases.

[Awaclus]

There's also cards that could be a different type without many changes. HoP could easily be a night card, and Landing Party feels like a reserve card for instance. Of course there would be some differences in those cases.

And most Nights could be Treasures.

[Karpeth]

I like it when one card-shaped thing has effects that resemble those of a different type of card-shaped thing: Inheritance is basically a Project, Obelisk is kind of a Trait, Lost in the Woods is essentially an Artifact, and Plateau Shepherds resembles a Landmark. (Am I missing any?) It's interesting to see similar gameplay concepts get implemented with the tools of whatever a given expansion has as its gimmick.

I would support the changing of all of those, except plateau shepards.

I works just like a project.
O - just like a trait.
LiW — just like an artifact.

However, PS does not follow the 2-non-card limit and requires a kingdom card to summon it.

I’d argue that Seize the day is a project - since it’s once per game.

I see no other.

Both HoP and Scheme missed their chances to be night.

[AJD]

Seize the Day is something that happens immediately when you buy it, though, not a persistent ability like Projects are—it acts more like an event.

And Scheme would be much worse as a Night card, since Night cards are stop cards!

[Karpeth]

StD happens once per games and needs some kind of trackability.

Scheme is one that DXV said he might have wanted to do as night.

[LibraryAdventurer]

I made and printed a night version of Scheme to play with, and it was indeed too weak so I changed it.

[infangthief]

And most Nights could be Treasures.

All Knights could be Treasures, with Capitalism.

[Udzu]

And most Nights could be Treasures.

All Knights could be Treasures, with Capitalism.

Just Sylvia, surely?

[infangthief]

And most Nights could be Treasures.

All Knights could be Treasures, with Capitalism.

Just Sylvia, surely?

Oops, yes, I forgot how Capitalism worked.