Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[WestCoastDidds]

I'm here now.

Good morning! I hope there’s coffee.

[Jimmmmm]

There certainly is!

[Awaclus]

I was busy over weekend but was also ok with trying to keep a low profile. And I did try to hint very vaguely when I suggested my goal was to exile scum or at worst a non PR. Clearly too vague for anyone to catch

I'll leave it up to you to decide if this is something you should answer, but could there be concrete evidence of you actually having a PR later? I mean something like observable effects on the number of deaths per night, targeting actions that a tracker or watcher could see, an investigative role whose results could later be confirmed e.g. from flips or from other people's claims, etc. Doesn't have to be absolute proof, just anything that could potentially ruin a planned fakeclaim later (and again I'm not asking what it is, just whether or not something like that is there).

[jotheonah]

I forgot I have a concert to attend tonight. Green Day / Smashing Pumpkins wooo

I hope you have the time of your life.

[Robz888]

I guess we shouldn’t exile a claimed PR.

Vote: shraeye

[scolapasta]

I was busy over weekend but was also ok with trying to keep a low profile. And I did try to hint very vaguely when I suggested my goal was to exile scum or at worst a non PR. Clearly too vague for anyone to catch

I'll leave it up to you to decide if this is something you should answer, but could there be concrete evidence of you actually having a PR later? I mean something like observable effects on the number of deaths per night, targeting actions that a tracker or watcher could see, an investigative role whose results could later be confirmed e.g. from flips or from other people's claims, etc. Doesn't have to be absolute proof, just anything that could potentially ruin a planned fakeclaim later (and again I'm not asking what it is, just whether or not something like that is there).

I can't tell if answering much more makes too much sense. Either you beleive me that I'm a PR and don't vote me or you don't, no?

But I'm willing to be convinced that it helps town for me to answer more. Swowl, thoughts? (and not because I'm 100% convinced your town, but I think either town you or scum you would give an honest and reasoned answer) Others too, of course.

(and if I do survive day (and night) we could continue to discuss "tomorrow".

[jotheonah]

I’m here.

I’m not gonna move to scola, though I can’t say I believe him.

Can I make a plea for Robz or fang over shraeye? I think the odds are better.

[Awaclus]

I guess we shouldn’t exile a claimed PR.

Scum can counter this strategy by claiming a PR.

[Swowl]

I was busy over weekend but was also ok with trying to keep a low profile. And I did try to hint very vaguely when I suggested my goal was to exile scum or at worst a non PR. Clearly too vague for anyone to catch

I'll leave it up to you to decide if this is something you should answer, but could there be concrete evidence of you actually having a PR later? I mean something like observable effects on the number of deaths per night, targeting actions that a tracker or watcher could see, an investigative role whose results could later be confirmed e.g. from flips or from other people's claims, etc. Doesn't have to be absolute proof, just anything that could potentially ruin a planned fakeclaim later (and again I'm not asking what it is, just whether or not something like that is there).

I can't tell if answering much more makes too much sense. Either you beleive me that I'm a PR and don't vote me or you don't, no?

But I'm willing to be convinced that it helps town for me to answer more. Swowl, thoughts? (and not because I'm 100% convinced your town, but I think either town you or scum you would give an honest and reasoned answer) Others too, of course.

(and if I do survive day (and night) we could continue to discuss "tomorrow".

I can't right now. Sorry. It is important that you decide whether you give an answer or not in your response and it comes from you, not me or anyone else.

[Cuzz]

I realize I'm way behind and deadline is soon so if someone (town only pls) wants to be so kind as to give a hint of where to focus my attention I'd much appreciate.

I would take insight on any/all of
MCMC
Robz
Shraeye

All three have struck me as possibly scummy at some point or another. Mcmc seems to kinda be driving things, and scum sometimes wants to try for that, though it's risky because if he's town then he's one of the most active and likely most helpful, so I lean away from him. Robz and schraeye have both said some oddly cryptic things and had some weird interactions that seem off to me.

[jotheonah]

Hold up.

There’s only one town PR we know exists and it’s one that scum doesn’t want to hit with a NK, right? The gladiator bomb? So why would scola say he expects to be night killed for claiming a power role?

[scolapasta]

Sure. I'm happy not answering now.

Also happy to move to Robz (sorry, since you just moved away from me - but that's actually something would want to do quickly for cred, no?)

Vote: Robz

[Awaclus]

I can't tell if answering much more makes too much sense. Either you beleive me that I'm a PR and don't vote me or you don't, no?

It's more complicated than that, because it's not a binary thing, I can entertain both possibilities.

[mcmcsalot]

I’m here.

I’m not gonna move to scola, though I can’t say I believe him.

Can I make a plea for Robz or fang over shraeye? I think the odds are better.

Convince me why robz over shraeye specifically why not shreaye

[scolapasta]

I can't tell if answering much more makes too much sense. Either you beleive me that I'm a PR and don't vote me or you don't, no?

It's more complicated than that, because it's not a binary thing, I can entertain both possibilities.

Sure. It's also possible you could be scum trying to see if I'm ther Gladiator bomb or not, to target me at night? Though I do read you mostly townie so far.

[infangthief]

Sure. I'm happy not answering now.

Also happy to move to Robz (sorry, since you just moved away from me - but that's actually something would want to do quickly for cred, no?)

Vote: Robz

What was this "Sure" in response to, the immediately preceding post (just 25 seconds earlier) or an earlier one?

[scolapasta]

To swowl's not wanting to advise.

[Awaclus]

VC should be:

shraeye (3): Swowl, Jimmmmm, Robz888
scolapasta (3): infangthief, Didds, faust
Robz888 (3): Awaclus, joth, scolapasta
infangthief (1): mcmcsalot
mcmcsalot (1): shraeye
Awaclus (1): Cuzz
Not Voting (0):

[Jimmmmm]

As I mentioned earlier, I think shraeye is more in the category of "acti-lurker". He's had plenty of opportunity to provide meaningful content but just kind of hasn't.

Vote: shraeye

Just kind of throwing the term "acti-lurker" out there without any indication of what that means in this specific context. Boo. Also of course the convenience of Swowl suspecting Jimmmm and shraeye and Jimmmmm just directing that towards shraeye.

It means, out of his 18ish posts up to that point, the only things I could find that I classified as even remotely helpful are a question about who is "content-full", a joke that scola was his 4th scum read, an unexplained vote on mcmc, a question as to why fang's "light claim" was scummy, and a reasonable point about mcmc calling out fang's "light claim" and then suggesting it shouldn't be discussed.

I was aware that voting for shraeye after Swowl's posts would likely be called out, but I wasn't going to let that change my intention to move my vote, and likely to shraeye.

[mcmcsalot]

Hold up.

There’s only one town PR we know exists and it’s one that scum doesn’t want to hit with a NK, right? The gladiator bomb? So why would scola say he expects to be night killed for claiming a power role?

Yup and given the fact that this is known town!scola shouldn’t say that. On the other hand scum!scola should know not to say that as well but you know I judge town harsher than scum when it comes to claims and such.

As with fang scola should full claim or stop talking about it

[MiX]

Vote Count 1.6

shraeye (3): Swowl, Jimmmmm, Robz888
scolapasta (3): infangthief, Didds, faust
Robz888 (3): Awaclus, joth, scolapasta
infangthief (1): mcmcsalot
mcmcsalot (1): shraeye
Awaclus (1): Cuzz
Not Voting (0):

With 12 alive, it takes 7 votes to exile. Day 1 ends July 29, 2024, 08:00:00 pm. That is less than 1 hour from now!

[jotheonah]

I’m here.

I’m not gonna move to scola, though I can’t say I believe him.

Can I make a plea for Robz or fang over shraeye? I think the odds are better.

Convince me why robz over shraeye specifically why not shreaye

My case on Robz is so subjective. The way he’s playing generally, so agreeable, much sheeping, much buddying, is a scum tell for Robz specifically. He is brazen.

The shraeye case is such a nothingburger. If you looked up “day one misexile” in the dictionary it would be the shraeye case, such as it is.

[WestCoastDidds]

It’s super frustrating that Shraeye has a vote out there doing nothing

Mcmc, what are you thinking?

[jotheonah]

I guess I’d move to shraeye to protect a claimed PR but I won’t feel good about it.

[WestCoastDidds]

I’m here.

I’m not gonna move to scola, though I can’t say I believe him.

Can I make a plea for Robz or fang over shraeye? I think the odds are better.

Convince me why robz over shraeye specifically why not shreaye

My case on Robz is so subjective. The way he’s playing generally, so agreeable, much sheeping, much buddying, is a scum tell for Robz specifically. He is brazen.

The shraeye case is such a nothingburger. If you looked up “day one misexile” in the dictionary it would be the shraeye case, such as it is.

I think there may be some wisdom there