Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[jotheonah]

I think there is a Town role that matters, and I think that Skum has more info than we do.

what makes you think these two things are true?

[jotheonah]

this is awkward, coming moments after I said I don't like voting for people who are voting for me, but

vote: fang

For a couple of reasons. While everyone has been sort of starting there own wagons, fang hopped right on the first one that looked like it had legs (it didn't, in fact, turn out to have legs).

But the real kicker is that he then tried to subtly goad Didds into joining and making it a real wagon.

It's a little on the nose for scum play, but then I didn't notice it until re-read. Best case I've got as of now.

[Robz888]

this is awkward, coming moments after I said I don't like voting for people who are voting for me, but

vote: fang

For a couple of reasons. While everyone has been sort of starting there own wagons, fang hopped right on the first one that looked like it had legs (it didn't, in fact, turn out to have legs).

But the real kicker is that he then tried to subtly goad Didds into joining and making it a real wagon.

It's a little on the nose for scum play, but then I didn't notice it until re-read. Best case I've got as of now.

Where was the didds goading?

[jotheonah]

A few weeks ago I read some of one of the first Mafia games on here, M2, or MII or however they were numbered. Day 1 had all this "you have to be nice to people, don't actually place a vote anywhere that's a bit extreme, just voice some suspicions".

I'm all for being nice, and wish I was better at it, but I'm glad we're fine with slinging votes around too.

Didds, do you want to come and vote for joth? Or do you feel like helping joth find a reason he can vote for mcmcsalot?
Awaclus, did you really consider saying "pretending to wonder"? I find that hard to believe.

oh, hi Robz. And yes you and joth were both in Mafia 2.

[Robz888]

Okay, I'll bite.

Vote: fang

[scolapasta]

Man, checking in now and 5 new pages! Lots to catch up.

I did lie yesterday when I said I'd try to reread last night - well, it was truthful at the time, but then a last minute let's drive to the beach for the weekend derailed that plan.

So I get the votes for me, with limited posts and no real content. It's something scumpasta would do. But it also something scolatown would do too, so 🤷

I could be around for deadline, but also prefer if we solidify earlier, as by 8pm, I'm possibly at dinner, would otherwise be busy. I guess that's also a good thing about plurality.

From my quick reading, I'm leaning mcmc and fang, and am happy to put a vote in once there's another vote count. (since I don't have time to tally up where we are since last vote count).

[scolapasta]

Re: the person who said I was their 4th read and what you can learn form that.

Just that I don't seem particularly scummy or towny to then. Whcih seems reasonable to me based on the one post I had up to that point.

[shraeye]

Vote: mcmc

Because of the thing

[Swowl]

Robz Shraeye Pasta MCMC where yall at top read wise?

I feel like we have played out this topic quite a bit and this sort of information is objectively more helpful to scum.

Why specifically these players?

What sort of information?

General mass reads lists. We used to do reads lists all the time and I feel like we realized scum uses that to know which misexhiles they can get over the hump.

Not asking for a top reads list. Was just poking people for where they were at. And yes I did post it at the people not voting bc those are the ones that I am curious about.

[Swowl]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

[faust]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

Oh wow, congratulations!

I hope you can manage to beat the flies and reclaim your home in time.

[jotheonah]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

Woo! I too am about to embark on that journey... although I found out about 5 months ago. Expecting the baby in mid-October.

[faust]

Unofficial vote count time!

faust (1): Awaclus
joth (1): infangthief
mcmcsalot (3): Jimmmmm, faust, shraeye
Awaclus (1): Cuzz
scolapasta (1): Didds
shraeye (1): Swowl
infangthief (2): joth, Robz888
Not Voting (2): scolapasta, mcmcsalot

No guarantees.

[mcmcsalot]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

Woo! I too am about to embark on that journey... although I found out about 5 months ago. Expecting the baby in mid-October.

Congrats to you both! It is an amazing adventure, however get your mafia'ing in in the next few months lol. Mine are 2 and 4 and the mental energy for this has just recently returned.

[Robz888]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

Wow, congratulations! Swowl Jr. on the way

[mcmcsalot]

Vote: mcmc

Because of the thing

what thing?

[Robz888]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

Woo! I too am about to embark on that journey... although I found out about 5 months ago. Expecting the baby in mid-October.

Congrats to you too!

[faust]

Vote: mcmc

Because of the thing

what thing?

the thing with the stuff

[Robz888]

Vote: mcmc

Because of the thing

what thing?

the thing with the stuff

oh that thing

[WestCoastDidds]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

CONGRATULATIONS!! Give DisSwan the hugest hug from us!!  What great news!!

[scolapasta]

Okok Completely non game related…

I’m gonna be a dad!!!!

Just found out this morning!!!!

Amazing - congratualations.

Vote: Swowl

Just kidding:

Real vote:

Vote: fang

(Don't want to go to 4 on mcmc, just yet, so let's have the 2nd wagon)

[infangthief]

Congratulation Swowl! Congratulations joth!

[Awaclus]

Congrats!

[infangthief]

But the real kicker is that he then tried to subtly goad Didds into joining and making it a real wagon.

It's a little on the nose for scum play, but then I didn't notice it until re-read. Best case I've got as of now.

Recommending wagons to other players is objectively useful, because you often get interesting responses. In this case the response from Didds's makes me think she is town.

I would not say it is too on-the-nose for scum play (for me), particularly as I did it in my last scum game. In order to try to seem towny.

[infangthief]

What is your fourth from top scum read

Ok, I actually pulled up the player-list and decided to tackle this question seriously (seriously).

It's scolapasta.

Hmm.

What can anyone possibly find interesting about this?

I was trying to decide whether it was scummy to name your allegedly fourth-from-top scum read, without explanation.

What did you decide?

Nothing, thus the “hmm”

What were you expecting to get?? "scolapasta is my fourth-from-top scum read because my top three scum reads are X,Y and Z"?