Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Swowl]

Vote Count 2.1

scolapasta (2): Awaclus, WCD,
mathdude(1): MiX
MiX (1): EFHW

Not Voting (5): Joth, gkrieg, LaLight, scolapasta, mathdude

With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Exile.
Day 2 ends Wednesday, March 1st at 8:35pm FT.

[jotheonah]

Maybe it is gkrieg or mathdude and it's just a big ol' WIFOM gambit.

[Awaclus]

If scum is WIFOMing the night kill, scum is overthinking it because town never pays attention to the reads of the killed player. When I'm scum, I always just kill the players who scumread me and then I get away with it because all the people who scumread me are gone and nobody else thinks their opinions were worth listening to.

[gkrieg13]

Maybe it is gkrieg or mathdude and it's just a big ol' WIFOM gambit.

I never go for gambits on my own. I have supported other people’s gambits in the past though.

[mathdude]

Maybe it is gkrieg or mathdude and it's just a big ol' WIFOM gambit.

Always a possibility. But I didn't pull a gambit. And I'm not sure if gk would alone either... I wouldn't put it past him, but at the moment I believe him.

[EFHW]

@MiX How did you end up not voting towards getting an exile? You were there.

[MiX]

@MiX How did you end up not voting towards getting an exile? You were there.

I forgot it wasn't plurality.

[scolapasta]

Fyi, work Korea part is over, so now have less time for this until i get back Tuesday.

I am trying to keep up reading posts, but won't get a chance to really respond to anything until then.

[WestCoastDidds]

I’m checking in, but I’m a little bit surprised that there is so little activity.

[WestCoastDidds]

Vote Count 2.1

scolapasta (2): Awaclus, WCD,
mathdude(1): MiX
MiX (1): EFHW

Not Voting (6): Joth, gkrieg, LaLight, scolapasta, mathdude, WestCoastDidds

With 9 Alive it takes 5 to Exile.
Day 2 ends Wednesday, March 1st at 8:35pm FT.

Swan, you have me listed twice

[jotheonah]

I’m checking in, but I’m a little bit surprised that there is so little activity.

Weekends gonna weekend.

Also, we don’t have a ton to analyze. I suppose a Joseph reread would not be out of order.

[WestCoastDidds]

I’m checking in, but I’m a little bit surprised that there is so little activity.

Weekends gonna weekend.

True fact. I’m at this fancy resort this weekend, we saw Justin Bieber this morning before he went to play golf and then Kourtney Kardashian and Travis Barker at dinner, which is pretty disappointing as far as celebratory sightings go. Next weekend the Obama are coming to visit. I’d be way more swoony about seeing them.

[LaLight]

Oh. I'll be here in the evening

[mathdude]

Fyi, work Korea part is over, so now have less time for this until i get back Tuesday.

I am trying to keep up reading posts, but won't get a chance to really respond to anything until then.

Hope you're managing to keep up with the reading still!

I do not have time to reread anything this weekend... between marking/planning for school and family, life is busy.

Even if I were to just want to sheep someone's vote, I'm not sure who I would feel  safe doing that to. I hope we see a little more from everyone by Monday or so.

[LaLight]

Joseph2302 has died! He was a Vanilla Townie!

After enjoying a pizza dinner with the Family, they made the mistake of getting into a car they left parked unwatched on the street. The key goes into the ignition and BOOM! Joseph story cuts to black.

this is a weird kill and my first thought was that it is pretty random.

[LaLight]

I’m kind of shocked Joseph was town. I had the scummiest vibes from him. In other news, I’m really bad at reading vibes

as far as I remember this is a normal vibe from Joseph

[LaLight]

L-2 is quickexile territory.

why does it matter? We're no close to exlo

[LaLight]

I do agree that points to someone who feels pretty safely not under suspicion, or someone who's just gutsy AF.

or someone wants to find JK asap and then recruit.

[LaLight]

I think I would have recruited if I were scum....

I do agree that points to someone who feels pretty safely not under suspicion, or someone who's just gutsy AF.

MiX?

My initial rwaction is actually Awaclus. vote: Awaclus

[LaLight]

So let's finally do what needs to be done. Joseph reread.

I'm the SK

And Vote: gkrieg for RL Mafia 1 (it's been 5.5 years and I'm still making this joke vote every game)

Request: Voote count

Just re-reading the setup

Reading the setup is scummy
Vote: joth

What do people think about a mass claim at this point?

And Vote: gkrieg for RL Mafia 1 (it's been 5.5 years and I'm still making this joke vote every game)

oh god how many years

It was August 2017

Also DAMA.

What is DAMA?

I’m here! I had closed my dedicated forum tab in my browser… I have to get back in the habit of checking this again!

Sounds like what lurking scum would say

Everything above is pretty much fluff. But here it gets interesting, given what Awaclus said:

I’m here! I had closed my dedicated forum tab in my browser… I have to get back in the habit of checking this again!

Sounds like what lurking scum would say

Interesting. Why is that something lurking scum would say but

Looks like I don't get e-mail notifications from f.ds at all anymore, it used to be a little random before but I haven't gotten a single notification this whole thread. I guess I have to keep up with it manually.

is not? They're both very similar excuses for low activity, but Joseph called one out and ignored the other. Could it be because one came from a partner? J'accuse

Vote: Joseph2302

Vote: Awaclus then
My theory is that they're both scum, so doesn't matter so much which one we exile first (if we exile them both eventually, obviously godfather first is good)

Here we go with fluff again

I'm thinking scum!Joseph wouldn't come out with such a weak theory so early.

That's exactly what scum!Joseph would want you to think.

So scum!joseph wants to look towny and decides to do it by acting like newbie scum? Or are you just jabbing at him in an RVS way?

There's a simple answer: it's town!joseph acting like newb/idiot like usual

Then the vote:

Vote: mathdude

#wagons

That's L-3 I think?

So we have 2 wagons with L-3 (is correct terminology now meant to be E-3?)

Well, in terms of there being a team or partners, its pointless since someone doesn't know who the team is so they are not working in concert.  So, the strongman is just looking out for themselves, really, which means to me that that they are only one for all intents and purposes until/unless they recruit.  We win if we find the SM, so the traitor is just irrelevant.  And since the SM can't rely on a partner to defend them if things get sticky, they have to do it themselves.  Which was the point I was trying to make.  Mathdude is doing the most work in trying to shake a wagon, perhaps because he has to. If he is the SM a wagon is freaking scary.

The traitor isn't irrelevant, we stop winning if we find the SM if the SM recruits the traitor. So, if we exile the traitor today, that's great news for us and bad news for scum, which is why it's in the strongman's best interests to stop that from happening if possible.

Agree, this is what I was (badly) trying to say earlier in the thread. Better to kill a scum than a town, even if it's "only" the traitor.

Gkrieg seems like an easy vote, as he hasn't posted much at all

OTOH, seems like an easy misexile target for scum to wagon on, which I think could be the case here

Ergo, I think there's scum on the gkrieg wagon, as whilst exiling lurkers seems to be common, it's an easy out for scum SM to avoid being exiled and losing immediately

But here he doesn't sr Awaclus anymore (which also doesn't really clear Awa from suspicion):

Vote Count 1.4

gkrieg (5): WestCoastDidds, LaLight, mathdude, scolapasta, MiX (L-1)
Mathdude (3): Awaclus, Joseph, Joth
scolapasta (1): EFHW

Not Voting (1): gkrieg

So by my previous logic that SM is on this lazy gkrieg wagon, I think SM is in {WCD, LL, math, scola}

Vote Count 1.4

gkrieg (5): WestCoastDidds, LaLight, mathdude, scolapasta, MiX (L-1)
Mathdude (3): Awaclus, Joseph, Joth
scolapasta (1): EFHW

Not Voting (1): gkrieg

So by my previous logic that SM is on this lazy gkrieg wagon, I think SM is in {WCD, LL, math, scola}

And so I'm fine with my vote on math, don't see a compelling reason to change right now

I thought you were doing the fake hammer threat thing on purpose.

Yay, the return of the nonsense fakehammer

And the last post

I don't expect to be around much, but think my vote is in a good place right now

What's the rule if we don't get a hammer? Presumably no exile (which is bad for town)?

I'm not sure what to draw from it, it's basically nothing. It points to mathdude, actually, probably, surely vote: mathdude

[LaLight]

basically Joseph voted for math and then stayed in there for the whole day. It would probably be a good idea to exile math.

Imagine if this is how this game would work, we just exile the most suspicious person and they are scum and we win. Woud be instant classic

[MiX]

I'm glad you got to the same conclusion I did. Makes me feel validated.

[EFHW]

I'm not buying this scum!mathdude theory. I liked it ok at first, but the fact is it feels cooked up by scum. Scumpoints to Lalight for uncritically accepting it.

[Awaclus]

Vote: EFHW

[LaLight]

I'm not buying this scum!mathdude theory. I liked it ok at first, but the fact is it feels cooked up by scum. Scumpoints to Lalight for uncritically accepting it.

I did not accept it in any way, I came to this conclusion by myself