Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[infangthief]

Thanks Galzria for answering those questions. Good answers mostly.

I'll explain more why I found those things odd and asked you about them:

• you made a comparison between the number of 'off' things Jimmmmm had said and the number that Didds had said, but the nature of the 'offness' was very different, so comparing the number of them seems bizarre.
• you unvoted from Didds because it turned out her 7 dwarves daychat claim was actually true. But that wasn't anything to do with why you'd voted for her in the first place.

So my reading was (maybe still is, not sure?) is that you were looking for excuses to join and then leave the Didds wagon, rather than these being actually genuine reads.

[Galzria]

I never disbelieved her claim, especially regarding the existence of the QT. What got me to switch was that the things that I WAS scum reading her for weren’t exactly strong reasons (you could argue they were better reasons than anything Jimmmmm had done, but Jimmmmm had done very little. That argument simply promotes scum lurking), and the particular person (Swowl) who confirmed the QT with her (and thus has likely a better read than I do), actively didn’t want her exiled - and I town read Swowl enough to accept that.

[infangthief]

vote: mathdude

What faust said.

[Awaclus]

Vote: mathdude

[infangthief]

And what mathdude said in #673.

[scolapasta]

I am starting to read mathdude as scummy, but I was *REALLY* hoping to give him a D1 and D2 pass this game due to other games. But it is getting harder. Push comes to shove, I'll vote there rather than no exile.

[mathdude]

faust, I just disagree with your read on Math. Like, I seriously don't understand how he's gotten exiled in previous games. He reads crazy townie to me. I DO agree that I didn't like his conclusion in the whole Pubby/Bright post - but I don't think the thought process that got him there was scummy at all.

This right here is how I get exiled - by actually trying to find scum.  By being active, and posting, prying, and trying to find who could be working together... and then people needling little semantics out of words that I say.

The more you say, the more likely you are for people to claim you look scummy.

Vote: pubby

[WestCoastDidds]

I think this is right...

pubby (3): Brightgalrs, WestCoastDidds, mathdude
Awaclus (1): Swowl
mathdude (3): faust, infangthief,  Awaclus
scolapasta (1): pubby

Not voting: scolapasta, Galzria,

[Awaclus]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

[Galzria]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

Did you get blamed for hammering Jimmmmm? Was this a concern of yours?

[Swowl]

Vote: Pubby

[Galzria]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

How do you know pubby is town?

[infangthief]

But actually, Galzria, those things you said were 'off' about Didds, they didn't strike you that way at the time, you had to go back and look to find some didn't you?

[Awaclus]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

How do you know pubby is town?

I don't, it just seems likely given his claim.

[Galzria]

But actually, Galzria, those things you said were 'off' about Didds, they didn't strike you that way at the time, you had to go back and look to find some didn't you?

No. I posted that they felt off at the time.

[Awaclus]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

Did you get blamed for hammering Jimmmmm? Was this a concern of yours?

Yes I did.

[Galzria]

Didds has 3x the posts of Pubby & Jimmmmm combined. That’s somewhat expected, but still, it’s noteworthy that the most vocal players are often the most suspected players because they’re generating the most noise. Does Didds activity level say anything about her alignment?

Didds, looking back, how would you characterize this exchange?

Hey uh Didds, did you get your alignment with PINL?

Why is this a question for me??

Why is this not an answer for me???

Because it is an oddly specific question.

What are you worried about?

You!

In the following exchange, the same question asked from Math to faust, and the pursuing answer, seems to catch you off guard. I’m trying to put my finger on why these two exchanges feel off. Any thoughts?

And what is this good authority?  Did Joth actually confirm to you with PINL?

Yes. Well, more or less. It's has to do with my role, so excuse me for not going into more detail.

Did you get yours with PINL?

No I didn't.

Oh, this is spicy!! Are our role posts lies?!

[mathdude]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

No, we can't. It puts us in a really bad spot, especially if scum kill is not RBed. Assuming 3 scum, that leaves 5 against 3 tomorrow, and scum just need to get 1 to side with them for no exile or misexile.

[infangthief]

But actually, Galzria, those things you said were 'off' about Didds, they didn't strike you that way at the time, you had to go back and look to find some didn't you?

No. I posted that they felt off at the time.

I mean, at the time Didds said them.

[Galzria]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

Did you get blamed for hammering Jimmmmm? Was this a concern of yours?

Yes I did.

Who blamed you?

[Awaclus]

Who blamed you?

I think it was mathdude but I'm not 100% sure without going back to check.

[Awaclus]

No, we can't. It puts us in a really bad spot, especially if scum kill is not RBed. Assuming 3 scum, that leaves 5 against 3 tomorrow, and scum just need to get 1 to side with them for no exile or misexile.

No exile at 5v3 is fine. It would be really nice to exile scum here (which of course is why I want to lynch you instead of pubby), but it's not the end of the world if we don't.

[scolapasta]

Vote: mathdude

Sorry.

[mathdude]

Can we exile mathdude? I don't want to have to hammer pubby with 3 minutes left and get blamed for hammering town again.

How do you know pubby is town?

I don't, it just seems likely given his claim.

Which you expect us to take your word for.

Who blamed you?

I think it was mathdude but I'm not 100% sure without going back to check.

Blame, no. Point out that it contributed to a minor scum read of you, yes

[Galzria]

Vote: pubby

Math is town.