Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Swowl]

Dylan has died at night!
He was an Adorable Mutt!

[Swowl]

Vote Count 3.0:

Not Voting (9): WCD, EFHW, ADK, Galz, faust, chairs, Eevee, Space, Robz

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Day 3 starts now and ends on October 18th at 6:28PM Forum Time.


THREAD UNLOCKED!

[Eevee]

Bummer bummer bummer.

Prob time to be somewhat judicious with our votes - scum has daychat and only takes two townies for them to coordinate an exile. We need to exile mafia today or we are positively toast

[Eevee]

My first inclination is chairs chairs. Instinctively makes sense that scum would have piled on glooble, him being the second leading candidate.

We should have started consolidating votes earlier yesterday. Town points to Space for trying to muster votes late yesterday. We needed more activity also!

[WestCoastDidds]

Adorable mutts getting whacked left and right! Ugh!

Alright people....eevee is spot on. We’ve got to get this right.

Here is the final vote count...I think at least 2 scum are on Glooble. Maybe even all three. ADK and chairs are pretty high on my list.

Glooble (6): faust, Robz888, ADK, chairs, Eevee, Space
chairs (2): Glooble, WCD
Eevee (1): EFHW

Not Voting (2): Dylan, Galz

[EFHW]

I think Eevee has to be scum here.

1. opportunistic voting
2. amazingly towny posts (528 and 529) directly after I voted him (513), but not before or since.
3. Fake dismay about nk.
4. Suddenly giving advice to town, mostly the standard Day 3 things people say.
5. If I squint and look for the players who have not received attention, have not done much, yet have been around, Eevee pops out.
6. He was on the Joseph wagon.

[EFHW]

7. He was on the Glooble wagon despite townread at 528. Why not just vote chairs?

[A Drowned Kernel]

Adorable mutts getting whacked left and right! Ugh!

Alright people....eevee is spot on. We’ve got to get this right.

Here is the final vote count...I think at least 2 scum are on Glooble. Maybe even all three. ADK and chairs are pretty high on my list.

Glooble (6): faust, Robz888, ADK, chairs, Eevee, Space
chairs (2): Glooble, WCD
Eevee (1): EFHW

Not Voting (2): Dylan, Galz

What changed your read on me from yesterday?

[A Drowned Kernel]

I think Eevee has to be scum here.

1. opportunistic voting
2. amazingly towny posts (528 and 529) directly after I voted him (513), but not before or since.
3. Fake dismay about nk.
4. Suddenly giving advice to town, mostly the standard Day 3 things people say.
5. If I squint and look for the players who have not received attention, have not done much, yet have been around, Eevee pops out.
6. He was on the Joseph wagon.

This list reads like you decided to scumread eevee first and then came up with reasons after

[WestCoastDidds]

Adorable mutts getting whacked left and right! Ugh!

Alright people....eevee is spot on. We’ve got to get this right.

Here is the final vote count...I think at least 2 scum are on Glooble. Maybe even all three. ADK and chairs are pretty high on my list.

Glooble (6): faust, Robz888, ADK, chairs, Eevee, Space
chairs (2): Glooble, WCD
Eevee (1): EFHW

Not Voting (2): Dylan, Galz

What changed your read on me from yesterday?

Glooble being town

[SpaceAnemone]

Robz being alive D3 as an IC is interesting. We know he's mostly been voting for townies, because he was on both Glooble and Joseph D1, and Glooble was his only vote D2. The only other person he voted on D1 was Didds.

Perhaps scum are just keeping him around because his reads are off. Though it's also worth considering whether scum might also like to keep him around to fool us into thinking we have a doctor when it may not be true. So if they're finding his reads are bad, it might be easier for them to justify that kind of a gambit, since it gives them a free safe-claim that we have "evidence" exists in the game.

Of course, I may also be casting doubt on a townie role that actually exists, if scum aren't being that sneaky here.. I just figure it's worth throwing that out there as a scenario before anyone moves to claims. This thought is mostly brought to you by the fun Robz and I and our scum buddy had in the last game I was in, which was also a case of doing something that seemed like it wouldn't be good for scum, but getting a better payoff just because it wasn't what town expected.

[A Drowned Kernel]

My first inclination is chairs chairs. Instinctively makes sense that scum would have piled on glooble, him being the second leading candidate.

We should have started consolidating votes earlier yesterday. Town points to Space for trying to muster votes late yesterday. We needed more activity also!

I think space's activity is only townie if chairs is scum. Otherwise it's null

[A Drowned Kernel]

Adorable mutts getting whacked left and right! Ugh!

Alright people....eevee is spot on. We’ve got to get this right.

Here is the final vote count...I think at least 2 scum are on Glooble. Maybe even all three. ADK and chairs are pretty high on my list.

Glooble (6): faust, Robz888, ADK, chairs, Eevee, Space
chairs (2): Glooble, WCD
Eevee (1): EFHW

Not Voting (2): Dylan, Galz

What changed your read on me from yesterday?

Glooble being town

Were you scumreading glooble yesterday?

[Eevee]

I think Eevee has to be scum here.

1. opportunistic voting
2. amazingly towny posts (528 and 529) directly after I voted him (513), but not before or since.
3. Fake dismay about nk.
4. Suddenly giving advice to town, mostly the standard Day 3 things people say.
5. If I squint and look for the players who have not received attention, have not done much, yet have been around, Eevee pops out.
6. He was on the Joseph wagon.

1 2 not proud of it, i've been pretty lazy this game
3 not fake, we have not been doing great
4 why is this bad?
5 fair
6 fair, i maintain that for day1 we rarely do better
7 i didnt think i could get back on before the deadline and wanted to avoid the noexile

[Eevee]

I think Eevee has to be scum here.

1. opportunistic voting
2. amazingly towny posts (528 and 529) directly after I voted him (513), but not before or since.
3. Fake dismay about nk.
4. Suddenly giving advice to town, mostly the standard Day 3 things people say.
5. If I squint and look for the players who have not received attention, have not done much, yet have been around, Eevee pops out.
6. He was on the Joseph wagon.

This list reads like you decided to scumread eevee first and then came up with reasons after

agreed!

[Eevee]

My first inclination is chairs chairs. Instinctively makes sense that scum would have piled on glooble, him being the second leading candidate.

We should have started consolidating votes earlier yesterday. Town points to Space for trying to muster votes late yesterday. We needed more activity also!

I think space's activity is only townie if chairs is scum. Otherwise it's null

this is true. from my perspective 3/7 of you are scum now, so it's actually reasonable to be pretty confident in your scumreads right now, small consolation there.

[A Drowned Kernel]

My first inclination is chairs chairs. Instinctively makes sense that scum would have piled on glooble, him being the second leading candidate.

We should have started consolidating votes earlier yesterday. Town points to Space for trying to muster votes late yesterday. We needed more activity also!

I think space's activity is only townie if chairs is scum. Otherwise it's null

this is true. from my perspective 3/7 of you are scum now, so it's actually reasonable to be pretty confident in your scumreads right now, small consolation there.

The thing is that the general lack of activity yesterday makes me think that scum was ok with either exile, so chairs is probably also likely to be town

[Eevee]

Good thing is, we've reached the fun stage in any mafia game! No scum deaths, but there should definitely be things to be gleaned from rereads now. Pinky swear I'll be reading through the key people tomorrow or the day after. One pretty important thing in this situation for townies is we must be pretty stubborn in our reads, so many scum out there sheeping is no good here. Also as important as finding scum is identifying town, people you'd be comfortable voting with. My feeling right is that person is ADK and as I said, mostly feeling scum from chairs, but rereads will hopefully provide more clarity on both fronts.

What do we know of the scum roles in the game?

[Eevee]

My first inclination is chairs chairs. Instinctively makes sense that scum would have piled on glooble, him being the second leading candidate.

We should have started consolidating votes earlier yesterday. Town points to Space for trying to muster votes late yesterday. We needed more activity also!

I think space's activity is only townie if chairs is scum. Otherwise it's null

this is true. from my perspective 3/7 of you are scum now, so it's actually reasonable to be pretty confident in your scumreads right now, small consolation there.

The thing is that the general lack of activity yesterday makes me think that scum was ok with either exile, so chairs is probably also likely to be town

That is not unreasonable.

[WestCoastDidds]

Adorable mutts getting whacked left and right! Ugh!

Alright people....eevee is spot on. We’ve got to get this right.

Here is the final vote count...I think at least 2 scum are on Glooble. Maybe even all three. ADK and chairs are pretty high on my list.

Glooble (6): faust, Robz888, ADK, chairs, Eevee, Space
chairs (2): Glooble, WCD
Eevee (1): EFHW

Not Voting (2): Dylan, Galz

What changed your read on me from yesterday?

Glooble being town

Were you scumreading glooble yesterday?

No... but I also acknowledge that D2 was a rough work week for me so I wasn’t terribly tuned in. Eevee was my biggest scumread yesterday.

[EFHW]

I think Eevee has to be scum here.

1. opportunistic voting
2. amazingly towny posts (528 and 529) directly after I voted him (513), but not before or since.
3. Fake dismay about nk.
4. Suddenly giving advice to town, mostly the standard Day 3 things people say.
5. If I squint and look for the players who have not received attention, have not done much, yet have been around, Eevee pops out.
6. He was on the Joseph wagon.

This list reads like you decided to scumread eevee first and then came up with reasons after

agreed!

What makes it seem like that? I scumread him based on points 1, 2, 5 and 6. The other 3 points came to mind as I organized my thoughts.

[A Drowned Kernel]

Adorable mutts getting whacked left and right! Ugh!

Alright people....eevee is spot on. We’ve got to get this right.

Here is the final vote count...I think at least 2 scum are on Glooble. Maybe even all three. ADK and chairs are pretty high on my list.

Glooble (6): faust, Robz888, ADK, chairs, Eevee, Space
chairs (2): Glooble, WCD
Eevee (1): EFHW

Not Voting (2): Dylan, Galz

What changed your read on me from yesterday?

Glooble being town

Were you scumreading glooble yesterday?

No... but I also acknowledge that D2 was a rough work week for me so I wasn’t terribly tuned in. Eevee was my biggest scumread yesterday.

When did you come to the feeling that glooble flipping town would implicate me as scum?

[A Drowned Kernel]

I think Eevee has to be scum here.

1. opportunistic voting
2. amazingly towny posts (528 and 529) directly after I voted him (513), but not before or since.
3. Fake dismay about nk.
4. Suddenly giving advice to town, mostly the standard Day 3 things people say.
5. If I squint and look for the players who have not received attention, have not done much, yet have been around, Eevee pops out.
6. He was on the Joseph wagon.

This list reads like you decided to scumread eevee first and then came up with reasons after

agreed!

What makes it seem like that? I scumread him based on points 1, 2, 5 and 6. The other 3 points came to mind as I organized my thoughts.

It's a weird mix of non-specific references to his previous play and to the posts he made immediately prior; to me it doesn't read like you had just read some or all of Eevee's posts and found them scummy, but were looking for something to say about another player

1- how do you define opportunistic voting? Where has Eevee done that?
2- why does this point to Eevee being scum?
3- why do you think Eevee's dismay is fake?
4- why is Eevee saying these things scummy and not null?
7- do you think chairs is scum?

[Robz888]

Galz talks soon or we exile him.

[Robz888]

I think I’m still around because I present no threat to scum, arguably that makes Eevee look quite suspicious.