Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

Also, I don't think there's a world where a scumteam of ADK, joth, Didds makes sense regardless of human/host considerations.

[Awaclus]

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

[faust]

Human: faust, MiX, mail-mi, Swowl, scolapasta, LaLight, (hypercube)
Host: Didds, ADK, joth
Both but also neither: Awaclus

Is this about right?

I will say this: If ADK were the only town host, then mail-mi would have just endgamed us. Which is to say... if this is correct, then either joth or Didds have to be town.

[faust]

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

You made it up.

[faust]

Okay, I think scola did not actually claim Host/Human, and I'm also not sure about MiX, can we do that? It seems like it's helpful to figure stuff out.

[faust]

Where stuff is "should we resurrect Didds"?

[MiX]

I didn't claim human/host status yet.

Okay, I think scola did not actually claim Host/Human, and I'm also not sure about MiX, can we do that? It seems like it's helpful to figure stuff out.

I see no reason to.

[Awaclus]

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

You made it up.

Did I also make up the part where I got it wrong at first and realized my mistake upon opening my QT to ask a question about my role?

[faust]

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

You made it up.

Did I also make up the part where I got it wrong at first and realized my mistake upon opening my QT to ask a question about my role?

Yes. I thought that was implicit in my first answer.

[MiX]

Where stuff is "should we resurrect Didds"?

Yes.

[Awaclus]

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

You made it up.

Did I also make up the part where I got it wrong at first and realized my mistake upon opening my QT to ask a question about my role?

Yes. I thought that was implicit in my first answer.

Have I ever done something like that as scum?

[mail-mi]

MiX should have just received a message.

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

You made it up.

Did I also make up the part where I got it wrong at first and realized my mistake upon opening my QT to ask a question about my role?

Yes. I thought that was implicit in my first answer.

Have I ever done something like that as scum?

Perhaps not, but isn't the goal to be unpredictable as scum and do new things so that you aren't lynched?

[MiX]

I have the message.

[scolapasta]

I didn't claim human/host status yet.

Okay, I think scola did not actually claim Host/Human, and I'm also not sure about MiX, can we do that? It seems like it's helpful to figure stuff out.

I see no reason to.

Catching up. Also don't see reason to claim this yet.

[scolapasta]

Where stuff is "should we resurrect Didds"?

Yes.

Wait, why? (not saying I'm against it, just wanting to understand the why's of it)

[MiX]

Where stuff is "should we resurrect Didds"?

Yes.

Wait, why? (not saying I'm against it, just wanting to understand the why's of it)

To gain time. Also to confirm that I shot her, although that's a bit useless. Plus, given all the shenanigans we uncovered today, I have no reason to think Didds is scum.

[faust]

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

You made it up.

Did I also make up the part where I got it wrong at first and realized my mistake upon opening my QT to ask a question about my role?

Yes. I thought that was implicit in my first answer.

Have I ever done something like that as scum?

I think you can answer that question better than me, so I'm not sure why you are asking.

[Swowl]

@ faust - clarification for your list of abilities and actions from a few pages back:

I also claimed the Maintenance shut down ability. Once per game, during the day, I can target a dead host and make it so they can never use Maintenance again.

Also also, Host/Human status unclear on me? I rezed Joth. I thought that made it clear I was Human. Just to be clear - I am in fact Human.

[scolapasta]

MiX why were you so quick to dayvig WCD?

[Swowl]

I will not use my ability on Didds unless it is like decided here that I should. But I do not believe that she is Town.
Within the realm of plausible shit, if she is town, that means either:
1. I shot Joth, then brought him back. Which is not accurate.
2. Joth was killed by a 3rd party. Which could make Joth either skum or town still. But if skum, then either that third party was me or didds, or they are lying.
3. Somehow Joth is skum that died and there was not other kill that night or the following night. Not really super believable.
4. Some sort of Ninja kill on Joth. So Joth is probably town.

So yeah. I really do not see Joth being skum. And if they are, then Didds still is likely third party. Or if Joth is Town... then didds is likely skum. So I do not like the idea of bringing Didds back at this point.

I am stilling trying to parse any other options of the MM vs Joth thing.

I think the best lynch is to lynch skum, and I think that it is most likely to be awaclus. I understand the concept people are talking about regarding not choosing them based on Host/Human... but like, who is a suitable lynch outside of them?

[MiX]

MiX why were you so quick to dayvig WCD?

I need to do it some time before deadline, and it was...sorta compulsive that I had to do it today? So, yeah.

I haven't claimed everything, but you don't need more from me at all.

[scolapasta]

MiX why were you so quick to dayvig WCD?

I need to do it some time before deadline, and it was...sorta compulsive that I had to do it today? So, yeah.

I haven't claimed everything, but you don't need more from me at all.

I ALWAYS need more from you.

Why compulsive to do today?

You do see that it's kind of weird that you did it very early before we can a chance to fully process WCD's claim (which seems to have turned out to be true) and then also the confusion of how your ability on me should work. (i.e. using my receiving two NOs as a way of claiming Didds was lying; rather than a misunderstanding of how your PR works on the target)

Also, why are you not William?

[MiX]

I have a passive. That passive somehow lead me to have to kill today. It's not important.

It's weird, yes, but...I don't know what else to say. I played with the information I had, and I didn't want to get to a point where I had passed the time to dayvig.

[Awaclus]

Another thought. If the scum team is <Didds, ADK, someone else> that someone else is probably a human, right? I mean, it makes sense that there would be a mix of hosts and humans for scum. So in that case, Awaclus would be a bad choice for today's exile, as would I. We'd want to be choosing from a pool of humans.

Awaclus counts as a human for maintenance.

Do you think scum!me has an ability with a clarification about how it works with the town win con, or do you think I made that up?

You made it up.

Did I also make up the part where I got it wrong at first and realized my mistake upon opening my QT to ask a question about my role?

Yes. I thought that was implicit in my first answer.

Have I ever done something like that as scum?

I think you can answer that question better than me, so I'm not sure why you are asking.

The answer of course is that I haven't. If I was scum, I would have set up something better than that, such as a lack of nightkill that you can then blame on someone you claimed to roleblock.

[MiX]

Why do you need something better than this? Why would scum!you have to fabricate a way to exile someone?

How could faust know there were no doctors (alive, I presume hypercube was the doc)?