OK so in the world where you are town, pretend for a moment that MM is town. So you are both town. So no teams allowed that include yourself of MM. Where is skum at?
This means there are two scum in:
Swowl
ADK
WCD
Yuma
LaLight
Calamitas
I take ADK off the table right away. Unchallenged UB claim is IC. Even if converted to a restless spirit the UB is not notified of that, so they still think they are the UB until proven otherwise.
Which leaves us with two scum in:
Swowl
Yuma
Calamitas
WCD
LaLight
- Calamitas has had their name thrown around as scum a lot, but nothing has really stuck. Scum partner protecting? Or just when people look at their whole game they read town? I fall in the second category. There were a few knee-jerk things that made me think scum, but their whole game has been town. In a large amount of posts, something will hit you the wrong way. Bound to happen. But looking past that, I think there game points to very strong town, especially the integral part in lynching Joseph.
- WCD has not had her best game, but I don't think that implies scum. Her most recent post that attracted criticism I think kind of sums up her game: she is either "lazy" (for lack of a better word) town, or lurking scum. She has had a few posts with an AtE element (see D1 reaction), and really the decision is if it was faked or real. Could go either way, coin flip. 1 is scum, 2 is town.
Rolled 1d2 : 2, total 2
Yuma - bursts of energy in posting, then silence. Different question than WCD here - are those bursts town trying to catch up, or scum trying to appear "helpful." Again, flip a coin
Rolled 1d2 : 2, total 2
LaLight is the only one that I went through earlier and landed on as scum. You can see the case above. If I take out mail-mi, I think PoE even more than before lands me on scum!LaLight
Swowl - when I did my reread earlier I landed town here. I will keep it there. Reference reply #710
So if mail-mi isn't scum, I think it is likely LaLight, {Yuma, WCD} as scum.
The choice between Yuma and WCD should be put off until more flips + claims happen.