Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mail-mi]

And the thought of confirming you actually have a baseball cap by giving it to somebody honestly hasn't crossed your mind?

I don't feel the need to confirm I have it. I'd rather it not fall into the wrong hands.

[faust]

Also, everyone has posted and no one else has joined me on skip. This might be lylo (or Mylo) so that makes me feel just a little bit more confident in my vote there.

Well if this were the kind of LyLo where scum can quickhammer with one vote then we'd already have lost, so that shouldn't be something that informs your decisions.

[Eevee]

can everyone share their reads? feels very relevant to scumhunting.

[skip wooznum]

@faust, best guess, who are the bad guys?

[skip wooznum]

Ppe

[skip wooznum]

can everyone share their reads? feels very relevant to scumhunting.

I plan on doing so later today.

[A Drowned Kernel]

One of mail-mi or skip is scum (and where we should probably lynch today if we're not lynching joseph) and the other's probably town. After that I think I'd vote faust over scola

[skip wooznum]

Eevee, if we lynch mail-mi today, do not investigate Joseph. It's pointless, we're not lynching him. Investigate one of the others. I would suggest scola, but adk and faust are also fine. Scola claimed to have a piece that he gave to joth night 1. Faust claimed to have one that got stolen night 2. Confirmation that they have never had any other pieces, and that they no longer have those pieces that they once had, would be good. Also, confirmation that they actually had those pieces at all is important too. Although not for faust, as mix already confirmed that. 

Anyway, don't investigate Joseph. It doesn't matter if he's lying. It only matters if other people are lying.

[skip wooznum]

One of mail-mi or skip is scum (and where we should probably lynch today if we're not lynching joseph) and the other's probably town. After that I think I'd vote faust over scola

(How is lynching Joseph your first option?)

[skip wooznum]

Honestly the main reason I don't want to lynch mail-mi is because then I'm gonna get shot tonight, and all y'all are gonna end up lynching faust, which will be a mistake.

[skip wooznum]

• Generally in games like these, do scum get to talk N0 or not just night N1? i.e. do we think they've had any chance to coordinate anything yet?

Why wouldn't they get to talk N0?

Scola, did you ever answer this? Why would this game be different than any other game?

[mail-mi]

• Generally in games like these, do scum get to talk N0 or not just night N1? i.e. do we think they've had any chance to coordinate anything yet?

Why wouldn't they get to talk N0?

Scola, did you ever answer this? Why would this game be different than any other game?

This is scola's second? game, and he was town in the first one, so it could just be newbie innocence.

[scolapasta]

• Generally in games like these, do scum get to talk N0 or not just night N1? i.e. do we think they've had any chance to coordinate anything yet?

Why wouldn't they get to talk N0?

Scola, did you ever answer this? Why would this game be different than any other game?

This is scola's second? game, and he was town in the first one, so it could just be newbie innocence.

That is correct. (well, 2nd or 3rd game , I can't remember if this was before M126. Regardless, I was town in that one too.

Why do we think scum killed sudgy last night?

[skip wooznum]

• Generally in games like these, do scum get to talk N0 or not just night N1? i.e. do we think they've had any chance to coordinate anything yet?

Why wouldn't they get to talk N0?

Scola, did you ever answer this? Why would this game be different than any other game?

This is scola's second? game, and he was town in the first one, so it could just be newbie innocence.

That is correct. (well, 2nd or 3rd game , I can't remember if this was before M126. Regardless, I was town in that one too.

This doesn't really answer the question. Why did you think this game might be different from the other games you played?

Why do we think scum killed sudgy last night?

Whom would you have killed?

[scolapasta]

• Generally in games like these, do scum get to talk N0 or not just night N1? i.e. do we think they've had any chance to coordinate anything yet?

Why wouldn't they get to talk N0?

Scola, did you ever answer this? Why would this game be different than any other game?

This is scola's second? game, and he was town in the first one, so it could just be newbie innocence.

That is correct. (well, 2nd or 3rd game , I can't remember if this was before M126. Regardless, I was town in that one too.

This doesn't really answer the question. Why did you think this game might be different from the other games you played?

The point is that I wasn't aware that they could talk in N0 in those other games either. i.e I never thought it might be different, I just didn't think to wonder about that in those other games. Well that's not exactly true: for Hunger games there was N0 talk. But it wasn't just for scum but also all the different districts. So that game definitely seemed different.

Why do we think scum killed sudgy last night?

Whom would you have killed?

I'll answer after I get others to answer my question first.

[skip wooznum]

• Generally in games like these, do scum get to talk N0 or not just night N1? i.e. do we think they've had any chance to coordinate anything yet?

Why wouldn't they get to talk N0?

Scola, did you ever answer this? Why would this game be different than any other game?

This is scola's second? game, and he was town in the first one, so it could just be newbie innocence.

That is correct. (well, 2nd or 3rd game , I can't remember if this was before M126. Regardless, I was town in that one too.

This doesn't really answer the question. Why did you think this game might be different from the other games you played?

The point is that I wasn't aware that they could talk in N0 in those other games either. i.e I never thought it might be different, I just didn't think to wonder about that in those other games. Well that's not exactly true: for Hunger games there was N0 talk. But it wasn't just for scum but also all the different districts. So that game definitely seemed different.

So if you didn't think to wonder about N0 in the other games, why did you think to wonder about it in this one?

[skip wooznum]

Why do we think scum killed sudgy last night?

Probably because he was obv!town, and there was nobody else who was obv!town and also a good idea to kill.

[scolapasta]

• Generally in games like these, do scum get to talk N0 or not just night N1? i.e. do we think they've had any chance to coordinate anything yet?

Why wouldn't they get to talk N0?

Scola, did you ever answer this? Why would this game be different than any other game?

This is scola's second? game, and he was town in the first one, so it could just be newbie innocence.

That is correct. (well, 2nd or 3rd game , I can't remember if this was before M126. Regardless, I was town in that one too.

This doesn't really answer the question. Why did you think this game might be different from the other games you played?

The point is that I wasn't aware that they could talk in N0 in those other games either. i.e I never thought it might be different, I just didn't think to wonder about that in those other games. Well that's not exactly true: for Hunger games there was N0 talk. But it wasn't just for scum but also all the different districts. So that game definitely seemed different.

So if you didn't think to wonder about N0 in the other games, why did you think to wonder about it in this one?

I mean, I already explained that for Hunger Games - that was first and everyone had some kind of N0 QT. I can add it was explicitly in the set up - since it was specifying when during N0 scum could and could not talk.

For M126 (I checked and confirmed it started before this). It just wasn't so important. These RMMs have more going on, what with (in this case) items. So there's more to coordinate than just who to vote for, and that's what made me wonder.

Skip, why are you town and yams is scum?

[scolapasta]

Why do we think scum killed sudgy last night?

Probably because he was obv!town, and there was nobody else who was obv!town and also a good idea to kill.

Who else is ob!town but not a good idea to kill?

[skip wooznum]

Why do we think scum killed sudgy last night?

Probably because he was obv!town, and there was nobody else who was obv!town and also a good idea to kill.

Who else is ob!town but not a good idea to kill?

Well, whom would you have killed?
Honestly your question sort of presupposes a specific answer to my question. Scum didn't decide in a vacuum to kill sudgy, they compared him with other potential nk candidates, and decided he was the best. So until you tell me who you think was a good nk target, I don't really know the intent of your question, or how to answer it satisfactorily. Are you asking why scum didn't kill me? Eevee? you?

[skip wooznum]

Skip, why are you town and yams is scum?

This question has multiple answers, and I will get into it, but it may take more energy than I currently have. I'd also like to put down other thoughts and reads on adk/you/faust(/eevee), but that will take even more effort. Hopefully tomorrow.

Who do you think is scum?

[skip wooznum]

Skip, why are you town and yams is scum?

I will say one thing, though. If I'm scum, then scum started with both the codebook and notebook, which would make vey little sense to begin with. Then, on top of that, instead of keeping this to themselves, and waiting to see what the codebook/notebook did, scum publicly outed that info to the whole thread in an extremely strange and impromptu moment during twilight of D1. So there's no way I'm scum.

[faust]

@faust, best guess, who are the bad guys?

As of now, having reread only D1, I'm thinking Eevee>scola>ADK.

I've also realized something I really should have thought of before though - skip is definitely town. I mean the whole affair with him giving the codebook to joth doesn't make sense if they are both scum.

So Vote: mail-mi is the best thing for today I think.

[faust]

Skip, why are you town and yams is scum?

I will say one thing, though. If I'm scum, then scum started with both the codebook and notebook, which would make vey little sense to begin with. Then, on top of that, instead of keeping this to themselves, and waiting to see what the codebook/notebook did, scum publicly outed that info to the whole thread in an extremely strange and impromptu moment during twilight of D1. So there's no way I'm scum.

Oh, haha.

[skip wooznum]

@faust, best guess, who are the bad guys?

As of now, having reread only D1, I'm thinking Eevee>scola>ADK.

I've also realized something I really should have thought of before though - skip is definitely town. I mean the whole affair with him giving the codebook to joth doesn't make sense if they are both scum.

So Vote: mail-mi is the best thing for today I think.

Eevee is a very central character in a lot of the actions and claims that have happened over the course of the game. It's been hard for me to come up with a scenario where he's scum, and complicated for me to consider the implications of all the claims and stuff. Could you walk me through your process?

Like for example, did he really start out with the rope? What's the point of my power if he did?