Re-read ADK. Something I noticed was a tendency to give reads without much explanation.
A few questions for you...
...analysis on district-partners...
so uh this theory is not lookin' too bad right now.
vote: shraeye
i wanna know why you could promise that #1 in the draft order (apparently WCD) wouldn't be the nightkill target.
I feel this.
vote: shraeye
I wasn't around much at the end of D1 due to RL busyness but I will try to do some catch up in the coming days. But I'm feeling good about where things stand right now
I was never super convinced by the district partners theory. What exactly was the "this" that you felt?
Alright, after a reread:
Unlikely to be mail-mi and raptor's partner: cayvie, glooble, mix, EFHW, e, lalight, didds, faust, shraeye, jim, ash
Could still be other scum: glooble, EFHW, faust, jim
On a reread I realized that shraeye's whole "we should claim our rank" and "#1 isn't going to be killed by scum" was likely (he didn't say as much but it's what I gathered) based on believing that scum was able to collude during the ranking phase, so that's basically a townslip from him
Looking back at mail-mi's list, I think it's unlikely he put multiple partners on the scummier end of his list
So where I'm left right now is vote: scolapasta
What made EFHW unlikely to be Mafia? What made you vote for scola? Was it just mail-mi's list placements?
Didds isn't someone I want to lynch today, probably not ever, partially based on district stuff
"Probably not ever" is a pretty big call. To what extent do you stand by that? What did she do in your QT that was Towny and couldn't just be attributed to her being her friendly self?
I've mentioned this before and I don't know how important it is, but my role seems completely unmodified for me being town
I find this to be a fairly compelling post for your Town Godfather narrative. Do you think, if you were a scum Godfather in this game, you would claim Godfather, or would you prefer to come up with some other claim? Were you disappointed when you found out you had been investigated, wishing you had some other role to claim?
The SK's dead, so I'm guessing faust hid behind glooble
Who's left here? How about a vote: EFHW
When I read this post just now, I thought it might be a scumslip. When I saw MiX's flip I figured he was on a second scum team, since it didn't indicate Serial Killer. But if the Mafia say had 4 members, they would know that a second scum team would mean too many scum players.
However, I then noticed that it also contained a vote for a Mafia member. It's hard to say exactly how much weight should be put on an out-of-the-gates Day 4 vote on Mafia, particularly when ash immediately then put the issue more or less to bed. But it's worth noting.
Probably ash, looking back at lalight on D1 it seems unlikely that he was mail-mi or raptor's partner. I think we're looking for the fourth mafia partner and not for another team, based on the fact that they've flipped as "mafia" and mix has a unique flavor for his faction; if it was two teams and not mafia+SK I would think that the red flips would have their own name
Was the Mafia/unique name comparison your immediate thought when seeing MiX's flip, or did you spend time thinking about it during that Night?