Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[2.71828.....]

Seriously, what a cop-out

^^scum^^

If E actually thought this, they would of torn eddie apart. This is not a Town!E response to this situation.

I thought it was pretty self-explanatory myself. Eddie is playing the classic role of "high road town" as in his decision to not participate somehow helps town.

It comes from a scummy mindset not a townie one.

Also, thanks for the high opinion of my play. Now I feel as if I have to live up to it....

[2.71828.....]

wow there is like nothing that has been said today, that is all I have.

It has been a slow post-duel day, which feels like scum sitting back and watching a town member get lynched. Joth looked like a potential lynch early and only 1 person came to his defense in any real way (not me, I just stated I preferred lynching Glooble) and now Glooble is feeling like the lynch and no one is really coming to their defense.

So either partner distancing or disengaged scum knowing the outcome.

Hopefully the first, but it feels like the latter

[2.71828.....]

Vote Count 2.5

Glooble (5): Awaclus, jotheonah, DatSwan, Joseph2302, e
jothenoah (3): Glooble, EFHW, Debatepro

Not Voting (4): Uncleeurope, mcmcsalot, Robz888, A Drowned Kernel

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day 2 ends on September 18, 05:00 forum time.

Very interested in taking a good look at the not voting people here tomorrow

[2.71828.....]

All that to say, if one of the two is scum, it is likely Glooble.

[Joseph2302]

wow there is like nothing that has been said today, that is all I have.

Yes it's been a really slow day
I still think Glooble over joth, although this lack of input from people makes me think the duel may just be town/town

[EFHW]

All that to say, if one of the two is scum, it is likely Glooble.

I would draw the opposite conclusion.  The uncomplicated lynching of Glooble here suggests he is town. If you think scum is disengaged,  like you said you do think, how does that lead you to the conclusion Glooble is scum?

[EFHW]

Vote Count 2.5

Glooble (5): Awaclus, jotheonah, DatSwan, Joseph2302, e
jothenoah (3): Glooble, EFHW, Debatepro

Not Voting (4): Uncleeurope, mcmcsalot, Robz888, A Drowned Kernel

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day 2 ends on September 18, 05:00 forum time.

Very interested in taking a good look at the not voting people here tomorrow

This is misleading.  Robz voted and ADK just stated intent to hammer.

[Awaclus]

All that to say, if one of the two is scum, it is likely Glooble.

I would draw the opposite conclusion.  The uncomplicated lynching of Glooble here suggests he is town. If you think scum is disengaged,  like you said you do think, how does that lead you to the conclusion Glooble is scum?

Scum could be Glooble, you, Debatepro.

[EFHW]

All that to say, if one of the two is scum, it is likely Glooble.

I would draw the opposite conclusion.  The uncomplicated lynching of Glooble here suggests he is town. If you think scum is disengaged,  like you said you do think, how does that lead you to the conclusion Glooble is scum?

Scum could be Glooble, you, Debatepro.

Could be,  but e said his reasoning led him to conclude Glooble was scum but that's not the logical conclusion from his reasoning.

[EFHW]

Yeah, I’ll vote later.

Willing to hammer either of them at the moment, as mentioned earlier.

We don't need a hammer, it's plurality lynch. You're essentially abstaining again. I don't know if that is scummy. But for town to somehow reach the correct answer, all the town players need to do their best in making a choice.

[Debatepro]

All that to say, if one of the two is scum, it is likely Glooble.

I would draw the opposite conclusion.  The uncomplicated lynching of Glooble here suggests he is town. If you think scum is disengaged,  like you said you do think, how does that lead you to the conclusion Glooble is scum?

Scum could be Glooble, you, Debatepro.

Besides this game when was the last time you were scum? You are absolutely 33.33 percent (repeating of course) incorrect here. Adding my reads it’s 66.66. For people who have played with me in a few games, I’m probably at least the 2nd safest town read.

Town!awaclus should avoid this line and look elsewhere. If Glooble flips scum, I would still look at aweclus, he can’t possibly think Glooble’s scum partners would so visibly pile on the only alternative. It is more likely they are abstaining. Can’t discount the possibility bussing (it gets them to the end game), but I’ve played more games in a format where that is common.

[Glooble]

So right now I think it's been obvious for a few days that I am the lynch, and aside from EFHW no one is stepping up to defend me. It might be interesting, for science, If we switched some votes around to make joth the preferred lynch, then see who stepped in to try and move the pendulum back to me.

[A Drowned Kernel]

vote: glooble

[A Drowned Kernel]

My head says glooble, my gut says joth. I'll do a reread tonight if no one's hammered

Did a sort of skimmy re-read, mostly just reading joth's and glooble's posts

Intent to hammer glooble

What soothed your gut from the re read?

On a reread glooble turning on joth read as very artificial and kind of desperate. It was a narrow thing but glooble's the better lynch here

[Uncleeurope]

#1 - I abstained from voting.

#2 - I am kind of in Datswan’s camp in that I don’t really have a strong preference one way or the other and am worried that this flip might influence my read on the other wrongly.

#3 - So I voted yes for the power and no for the duel by not voting.

#4 - It makes sense, I promise.

This decision is completely different from voting yes for the duel and no for the power.

Yeah, I’ll vote later.

Willing to hammer either of them at the moment, as mentioned earlier.

#1 - Either you thought one was 1 skum, 2 were skum, or none were skum. You not voting lowers the thresh hold of needed yes votes to *potentially* only 5 with 3 skum in the game. So, if you thought there was 1 skum... ok I guess as like an almost trap plus the PR benefits... but you can't follow that up with "I will vote for anyone". If you thought both were skum, then it would check out I suppose... except your lack of effort on the day (and of course claiming the no vote) really is weird there. If you thought both were town it is just dumb.

#2 - No you are not. People are not allowed in this camp that throw out willy nilly "I will vote for anyone" crap. Trust me, I sell the tents. I DO have a preference either way. I made that like abundantly clear in my 2 wall posts. I simply think I am picking between a "skum and a hard place". But when chosen to pick, I am made it pretty cut that I am on Glooble.

#3 - This is not how that works. By not voting you lowered the thresh hold of needed yes votes to make the duel happen. Also, there cannot be a PR without a duel. So, even in a world where you can word that differently... it just doesn't make sense. You need to vote in a fashion that favors the duel in order to favor the PR, and vice versa.

#4 - No. None of it does.

1. The other option is I didn’t think either of them was more likely one or the other.

2. Okay, I will leave your camp, I’m sorry. I will go to my own, it is just lonely over here...

3. That was a joke.

4. That was the punch line.

I know me not voting looks bad, that’s fine with me, I didn’t want to vote one way or the other in case it turned out I was wrecking other town members from their plan. I preferred making an always-kinda-bad-play over a sometimes-worse play.

We agree on e, though. I kind of wanted to see who would jump on that post first chance they got.

[Debatepro]

Does the day end when plurality is reached or at the deadline¹? Also, is the plurality v. majority distinction worthless because 1. there are only two in the duel and 2. "Either one may still be lynched earlier via a majority vote."²

... Duels
...
...  [1] For the rest of the day, only votes for the two dueling players are valid. All other votes (including a no-lynch vote) will have no effect. At the end of the day¹, the player with more votes is lynched (if it is a tie, a virtual coin is flipped). Either one may still be lynched earlier via majority vote ².
...

[EFHW]

Does the day end when plurality is reached or at the deadline¹? Also, is the plurality v. majority distinction worthless because 1. there are only two in the duel and 2. "Either one may still be lynched earlier via a majority vote."²

... Duels
...
...  [1] For the rest of the day, only votes for the two dueling players are valid. All other votes (including a no-lynch vote) will have no effect. At the end of the day¹, the player with more votes is lynched (if it is a tie, a virtual coin is flipped). Either one may still be lynched earlier via majority vote ².
...

The day ends at the deadline or at majority vote. Otherwise, it would have ended a long time ago. It's not meaningless because there is no consequence of no lynch if we can't find a majority.

[jotheonah]

vote: glooble

this was the hammer, no?

[Glooble]

vote: glooble

this was the hammer, no?

I don't think it was.

[Glooble]

Wait, yes it was.

Well, good luck guys. If joth turns out to be town, I'm sorry I tunnelled so hard. If joth turns out to be scum I'm sorry I didn't tunnel harder.

[Debatepro]

Should be.

Vote Count 2.5

Glooble (5): Awaclus, jotheonah, DatSwan, Joseph2302, e
jothenoah (3): Glooble, EFHW, Debatepro

Not Voting (4): Uncleeurope, mcmcsalot, Robz888, A Drowned Kernel

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day 2 ends on September 18, 05:00 forum time.

Vote: Glooble

vote: glooble

[Debatepro]

Wait, yes it was.

Well, good luck guys. If joth turns out to be town, I'm sorry I tunnelled so hard. If joth turns out to be scum I'm sorry I didn't tunnel harder.

Have any scum reads?

[Glooble]

Wait, yes it was.

Well, good luck guys. If joth turns out to be town, I'm sorry I tunnelled so hard. If joth turns out to be scum I'm sorry I didn't tunnel harder.

Have any scum reads?

ADK for sure. I still think joth/ Robz scum team is a strong possibility. Awaclus certainly, but I'm often bad at reading Awaclus.

Feeling towny on you, EFHW, and Swan. Slightly less towny but still a little towny on e. Null on Uncle and Joseph. Who am I missing?

[jotheonah]

Crap. Glooble doesn't troll, so he's basically town. Sorry bro.

[jotheonah]

Wait, yes it was.

Well, good luck guys. If joth turns out to be town, I'm sorry I tunnelled so hard. If joth turns out to be scum I'm sorry I didn't tunnel harder.

Have any scum reads?

ADK for sure. I still think joth/ Robz scum team is a strong possibility. Awaclus certainly, but I'm often bad at reading Awaclus.

Feeling towny on you, EFHW, and Swan. Slightly less towny but still a little towny on e. Null on Uncle and Joseph. Who am I missing?

debate