Debatepro's probably scum. Let's analyze one of their posts, mainly the one with actual reads and not just questions: (I cut some of the flavour in it to get to the read list)
- I want to read more from e, efhw, and eddie because I feel like I know them better than other players. No ideas on PPS and pubby, because they are not saying much, and I don't know them very well. Asher hasn't said much, I did agree with his take on DS's plan v planning, and they were helpful. I think at least one scum tends to be inactive in d1. But I have not played many games and thus a small sample size.
- mcmc seems townie but being helpful is part of his meta. I may always equate being nice and helpful as a town trait. I’ll have to factor that into my calculation if I can.
- This DS issue with plan vs. planning seemed contrived and shit, wouldn't be surprised if there was scum on and intentionally avoiding that discussion. Not a plus or minus for DS, mostly others. This doesn't exonerate DS, just thought it was crap.
- MiX always seems scummy, even when he is town, I think that is well known. He does seem to be playing a little bit more deliberately, but I've heard he is doing this more and more. Wouldn't surprise me if scum team avoided voting for town!mix, hoping he will be lynched without their help.
- My 'spidey senses' have occasionally been heightened by ADK, gkreig, glooble, & Joth. When i reread, I can convince myself that that they could be town.
- SS - Not good at reading him, last time I played he was scum and had a town read on me. Probably won scum the game because I was too stubborn to see it for what it was. I'll probably read them more skeptically in this game.
Now let's process it:
e - He feels like he can read him better. No reads
Eddie - He feels like he can read him better. No reads
EFHW -He feels like he can read her better. No reads
pps - Doesn't know him, not saying much. Null, I presume
pubby - Doesn't know him, not saying much. Null, I presume
ash - Hasn't said much, agrees with him regarding Swan's plan vs planning thing (IIRC ash said it came more from town?). No reads (although he said he was helpful and then mentions that's a town trait)
Then a comment that "one scum tends to be inactive D1", I suppose throwing shade on everyone he had mentioned so far. Then he continues:
mcmc - Townie but he always sees helpful as town.
Swan - Plan vs planning thing doesn't change his read on Swan, so I presume it's null?
MiX - He's scummy when town, something about how I play, ends with "scum team doesn't want to vote for him, hoping he's lynched without their help". No real read here, unless that was supposed to say null.
ADK, gkrieg, Glooble and joth - Scummy, I presume. All lumped together and he even says he's not that sure.
silverspawn - Hard to read, then some talk about his previous game. No reads
Overall there's 1-2 town reads, 4 "scum" reads and the rest are a bunch of nully nulls. Meh, this probably fits town!Debatepro, but it wouldn't fit me if I didn't scumread him to hell and back.
Regardless, Debatepro, if you had to vote for someone right now, who would it be?