Reread the game.
So ash said something that appears like a contradiction and DatSwan pulled out some quotes pointing this out. Then he got heat for it. I think everyone who pointed out that this doesn't make DS scummy deserves some town points. That's at least EFHW and ash.
I think pubby's appearance so far is not good. Here is the full ISO for you:
vote: pingpongsam
I cannot get into this game guys. Try as I might.
That's OK. It means I won't feel guilty about...
vote: jotheonah
Not expecting to change my vote from this.
@pubby, explain your vote and I'll probably sheep you.
I think joth is trying harder than anyone else to appear innocent. I don't believe him when he says he's not "into" this game - I mean, he had opinions about voting blocs and strategy and even tallied up the votes for everyone.
But if he is town, I won't feel terrible if he's lynched. Because again, I'd rather lynch the guy who's not feeling the game than a player more involved.
3 posts, and all are scummy.
I'm also wary of debatepro. In my first game with them – well, I was scum and knew they were town, so it's possible I deluded myself, but I nonetheless – I got super strong town vibes from them pretty much the entire game. This time I don't. Is it just because they're not as new anymore? Very possible.
This is also interesting:
Can a friendly town person please give me a high-level explanation of what the traitor is and how it works? I've never played with one and read the mafia wiki on it, but I'm still unsure how it works in or could work in this game.
I did stuff like that as scum when I was new. Actually did it in my first scum game. But the fact that they say they've read on it in the wiki is the kind of detail that makes it more likely to be true.
@Mcmc: you've never answered me about how seriously you took your attempt to create the bloc. Please respond.
This post is over-the-top scummy. MiX is saying "explain your completely unexplained vote and I'll join your wagon, [apparently regardless of how bad the explanation is]". Why even ask for the explanation? So you have a flimsy pretense for your scummy vote?
vote: MiX
Consider yourself being in scum!Mix shoes. Does this really seem like a plausible thought process?
I did say it was over the top.
But you voted anyway. Why?
Here's where I'm at right now.
Town: ADK, Gloooble, Eddie, joth
Scum: pubby
vote: pubby