Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[WestCoastDidds]

If WCD is scum, she's playing a really impressive game.

And then we all laughed and laughed and laughed...because heaven knows no one has ever thought that about my play!

I don't think I really need to prove my veracity, but the best thing I have going for me is that Space, Swan, and Joth all have the same information about me. I can't see a scenario where I could have figured that out early and then been able to maintain it with everything else that is changing in the game in light of new information, etc. Instead, we just keep getting better and better town information.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

With UoS I feel as if there is just not enough information to really make a good decision about lynching them, hence wanting the claim. They are a prime suspect today based on PoE, and while I don't have much of a reason to lynch them, I don't have a reason NOT to lynch them

This is a terrible reason for wanting a claim, but that's okay because I realized I have a way to confirm my claim tomorrow, so I'm not claiming today period. It's relevant only if you'd be willing to lynch through my claim anyway.

Also I don't see an intent to hammer.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

It feels like 3 people are voting me just because they want me to claim not because they want to lynch me. This is... not smart.

[jotheonah]

If UoS wasn't at L-1, I'd probably switch my vote to her at this point, simply due to, as E said, process of elimination. As is I'm happy keeping my vote on who I think is the second most likely scum.

Looking forward to hearing a claim.

This is .... almost an intent to hammer.

[Glooble]

It feels like 3 people are voting me just because they want me to claim not because they want to lynch me. This is... not smart.

I think all of the people voting for you are doing so because they think you're the most likely of the remaining players to be scum. I agree with them, so if you continue to insist on not claiming, I'm probably gonna hammer.


I intend to hammer.


This is my intent. I am declaring it.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

I'm curious what other people think though, especially those meta-driven folks who know e a little better. ash, for instance, or UoS or Space. Is e the type to use a 1-shot cop in such a way? I would expect seasoned players to save a power like that for the late game. But of course, that requires surviving to the late game.

It doesn't seem that weird to me. 1-shot cop is absolutely better later on, but e isn't a crazy N1 NK, there isn't faust in the game where the scumteam killing him N1 is actually a meme, and there are plenty of players in that initial list who obviously wouldn't be the NK. Looking at it now I'd put her in my top 3 players, so using it early makes sense. Obviously that's not an unbiased assessment on my part, but I don't think it would be hard for town e to come to the same conclusion.

[jotheonah]

I'm curious what other people think though, especially those meta-driven folks who know e a little better. ash, for instance, or UoS or Space. Is e the type to use a 1-shot cop in such a way? I would expect seasoned players to save a power like that for the late game. But of course, that requires surviving to the late game.

It doesn't seem that weird to me. 1-shot cop is absolutely better later on, but e isn't a crazy N1 NK, there isn't faust in the game where the scumteam killing him N1 is actually a meme, and there are plenty of players in that initial list who obviously wouldn't be the NK. Looking at it now I'd put her in my top 3 players, so using it early makes sense. Obviously that's not an unbiased assessment on my part, but I don't think it would be hard for town e to come to the same conclusion.

Thanks, this is a helpful datapoint.

[jotheonah]

I'm curious what other people think though, especially those meta-driven folks who know e a little better. ash, for instance, or UoS or Space. Is e the type to use a 1-shot cop in such a way? I would expect seasoned players to save a power like that for the late game. But of course, that requires surviving to the late game.

It doesn't seem that weird to me. 1-shot cop is absolutely better later on, but e isn't a crazy N1 NK, there isn't faust in the game where the scumteam killing him N1 is actually a meme, and there are plenty of players in that initial list who obviously wouldn't be the NK. Looking at it now I'd put her in my top 3 players, so using it early makes sense. Obviously that's not an unbiased assessment on my part, but I don't think it would be hard for town e to come to the same conclusion.

Though worth noting this list of reasons is completely different than the reason e gave...

[UmbrageOfSnow]

I'm a doctor you jerks. I was going to target Space tonight and confirm myself.

Robz targeted e on N1, I targeted Ash on N2 and N3. I also have a power to give someone a boosted power in some way that neither Robz nor I have used.

My flavor name is just Medic.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

I'm curious what other people think though, especially those meta-driven folks who know e a little better. ash, for instance, or UoS or Space. Is e the type to use a 1-shot cop in such a way? I would expect seasoned players to save a power like that for the late game. But of course, that requires surviving to the late game.

It doesn't seem that weird to me. 1-shot cop is absolutely better later on, but e isn't a crazy N1 NK, there isn't faust in the game where the scumteam killing him N1 is actually a meme, and there are plenty of players in that initial list who obviously wouldn't be the NK. Looking at it now I'd put her in my top 3 players, so using it early makes sense. Obviously that's not an unbiased assessment on my part, but I don't think it would be hard for town e to come to the same conclusion.

Though worth noting this list of reasons is completely different than the reason e gave...

How arrogant would it be to say "I'm one of the best players in this game, so I was worried about being the NK?"

[jotheonah]

Town having full doc AND full JK (effectively 2 docs) seems pretty powerful.

[jotheonah]

unvote anyway, in the name of ensuring time for discussion and no quickhammers.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Where has everyone been all day? I guess UoS is just taking time coming up with a claim, slows down play a bit

I dislike this though, how often to I post in the morning?

[SpaceAnemone]

One guess is that because I shared QT info in another QT, none of which was in the game thread, it does make some sense to have it be a QT penalty.

Right.. so with whom did you have a QT after Swan, who was N2 and failed D3, and the N3 when you claim you didn't have a QT because you were being penalised for quoting something from the Swan QT?

[SpaceAnemone]

Where has everyone been all day? I guess UoS is just taking time coming up with a claim, slows down play a bit

I dislike this though, how often to I post in the morning?

Maybe e is still getting used to being in a European timezone where everything happens in the evening or overnight? Like, for us 11am is already 4 or 5 pm (for me and e respectively), so it's not exactly early.

[Glooble]

I'm a doctor you jerks. I was going to target Space tonight and confirm myself.

Robz targeted e on N1, I targeted Ash on N2 and N3. I also have a power to give someone a boosted power in some way that neither Robz nor I have used.

My flavor name is just Medic.

I don't remember a Medic named Medic in the books. Does anyone else?

Just to confirm, Robz did not target me with the power booster night 1? Cause that seems like a really weird role to have two of.

[jotheonah]

One guess is that because I shared QT info in another QT, none of which was in the game thread, it does make some sense to have it be a QT penalty.

Right.. so with whom did you have a QT after Swan, who was N2 and failed D3, and the N3 when you claim you didn't have a QT because you were being penalised for quoting something from the Swan QT?

Maybe just give us a list:
N1
D2
N2
D3
etc. It does seem like the number of QTs doesn't add up if you get them every day and every night.

[SpaceAnemone]

unvote anyway, in the name of ensuring time for discussion and no quickhammers.

That seems townie.

I want to think about the claim, and about WCD's QT weirdness maybe-scumslip thing, but right now I'm going to be offline for a few hours hosting games night.

Please don't lynch anyone before I'm back :-)

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Town having full doc AND full JK (effectively 2 docs) seems pretty powerful.

I'm not exactly a full doc, but the details are none of anyones business, you lynch me or scum NKs me and you can figure it out from my flip probably. I absolutely will not claim the details of that part of the role.

[jotheonah]

I'm a doctor you jerks. I was going to target Space tonight and confirm myself.

Robz targeted e on N1, I targeted Ash on N2 and N3. I also have a power to give someone a boosted power in some way that neither Robz nor I have used.

My flavor name is just Medic.

I don't remember a Medic named Medic in the books. Does anyone else?

Just to confirm, Robz did not target me with the power booster night 1? Cause that seems like a really weird role to have two of.

There was a Medic in the book who was just called Medic.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Just to confirm, Robz did not target me with the power booster night 1? Cause that seems like a really weird role to have two of.

Robz did not target you.

[SpaceAnemone]

I don't remember a Medic named Medic in the books. Does anyone else?

Yeah, the ships have medics, don't they?

PPE some. Definitely leaving this time...

[Glooble]

Just to confirm, Robz did not target me with the power booster night 1? Cause that seems like a really weird role to have two of.

Robz did not target you.

So what's the likelihood faust puts two different power-boosting roles in the game?

[Awaclus]

Vote: Glooble

[Glooble]

Vote: Glooble

Shocker.