From the re reads I have done on my suspicious player list, this is where I am at:
Morgrim:
Day 1:
1) They claim Det Zimm. That is weird. Why would you outright claim a cop designated PR D1 for no reason? I couldn't, and now still cannot get over that. I did in the middle because I thought Galz made a good case about Morgrim pushing silver without a lot of real given reason.
2) I am giving skum points to anyone that just jumped on the Awaclus wagon, which Morgrim was right in the middle of. Awaclus claim seemed ridiculously towny and clearly hinted at having a time traveling component to it (which I would assume skum would want to eliminate asap).
Day 2:
1) They wake up - see below to why I don't think that makes sense.
2) They disappear for the Galz push on silver thing and for the end of day to verify anything.
Day 3:
1) They claim results on 2 dead players.
2) They give themselves 2 shots, which they have used up. Thus creating no reason for "Skum to kill them at night".
3) They throw in the silver reverse flip to add in a little craziness and, I am assuming, make it seem more believable.
Then there is just the logic of how the Det Zimm claim played out. In the below three steps they have created a role for themselves that checks out, that has no reason to be NK'd (because all shots are used), and also creates chaos of information (with the "results on SS").
Step 1 - Claimed Det Zimm.
Gave no insight as to what he could actually do, but as it has been universally kind of accepted, it was def expected to hint at having a cop-like ability set. Also, since Awaclus was the only other claim and they were the lynch... I find it strange that the deaths for the night were Iguana, who they could easily of pushed a skum meta for based on their opening of D1... so IDK why they would want him dead... and then Ashes, who essentially pushed a similar concept to Iguana so they could of also pushed a case on them. Why would Town!Morgrim wake up? Cop results in a game like this can be extremely damning to skum... they just what... rolled the dice he wasn't gonna pick on of them?
Step 2 - Disappear Day 2 after Galz makes their case about silver.
As we know now, silver was Town, as well as the final lynch of WCD. Why speak up if it is Skum!Morgrim? They can just let it play out. The only other wagon that got close was Hydrad, who I also think is skummy at this point and that obviously got de-railed onto WCD.
Step 3 - Claim results and render themselves a non-target.
They claimed Iguana Night 1 to verify the bullets. Then claimed the backwards result on silver Night 2. THIS IS A PERFECT PLAY. They have verified they are a cop, they have given results that do not tie them to anyone at all. Annnnndddd they even throw in a little chaos about the reverse flip on silver to make it seem more believable.
I am staying on GK for the test vote right now, but Morgrim is my top pick at this point.