So, this is where I'm at:
D1:
Day 1 final vote count
Lalight (SANE COP)(1): Awaclus (INSANE COP)
gkrieg13 (TRAITOR)(1): Hydrad (VT)
pingpongsam (VT)(7): faust (VT), McMcsalot (VT), Joseph2302 (VT), Robz888 (VT), Lalight (SANE COP), gkrieg13 (TRAITOR), 2.71828... (MAFIA)
not voting (4): Dsell (VT), DatSwan (SANE COP), pingpongsam (VT), Galzria (VT)
With 13 alive, it took 7 to lynch.
----------
Note, so either both scum were on PPS (possible - it was a "free" wagon, in that it wasn't really scummy to be on it), or Dsell is scum.
----------
D2:
Day 2 Final Vote Count
Galzria (1): gkrieg13
Robz888 (3): Joseph2302, Hydrad, Lalight
gkrieg13 (6): McMcsalot, Robz888, 2.71828..., Dsell, DatSwan, Awaclus
not voting (1): Galzria
With 11 alive, it took 6 to lynch.
----------
Now, with this VC, either both scum were on Gkrieg (possible - they didn't know that he was the Traitor), or Joseph is scum. Also, the chances here that Robz, as a town wagon, had all three town on it seems slim - which makes Robz/Joseph a little more scummy.
---------
D3:
Vote count 3.3
2.71828... (5): Dsell, Lalight, Robz888, Galzria, DatSwan
not voting (4): 2.71828..., McMcsalot, Joseph2302, Hydrad
With 9 alive, it took 5 to lynch.
--------------------
With the D3 VC, e obviously wasn't going to vote for himself - so the question is whether his partner bussed or not. If not, then his partner is Joseph. If his partner did bus, then it's either Dsell - going in at vote #1 looking for some real early town credit, or Robz at #3, getting on when it seemed clear that's where the lynch was gonna be.
----------
So. Points in conclusion:
- On either D1 or D2 (and possibly both), both Mafia were on wagon together.
--- These combinations are: {D1|2.7/Robz}, {D1|2.7/Joseph}, {D2|2.7/Robz}, {D2|2.7/Dsell}
- As it is easier to vote together earlier rather than later (You make up a smaller % of the wagon with co-voting earlier on), this makes Robz/Joseph slightly more likely than Dsell.
- On D3 scum either bused, or they did not. If they did, it is more likely to bus when it seems inevitable than to start the wagon - making Robz more likely than Dsell. The fact that Joseph didn't vote e is also scummy - although he did state intent to. Intent to vote scum without actually doing so is a pretty scummy place to be.
----------
Given all that... plus the post from Gkrieg D1 about Joseph:
"I also want to lynch Joseph real bad, so probably town there too."
And I think I prefer to lynch Joseph today.