Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[pingpongsam]

I find the EFHW wagon troubling. It built quickly based on not much, although there is always not much D1. I’m certainly not reading her as scum enough to vote her. Robz is still a decent vote. faust’s analysis of LaLight seems like the best case of the day at this point. We’re traveling back home tomorrow so I should be around for deadline. Hydrad is still town.

[LaLight]

I find the EFHW wagon troubling. It built quickly based on not much, although there is always not much D1. I’m certainly not reading her as scum enough to vote her. Robz is still a decent vote. faust’s analysis of LaLight seems like the best case of the day at this point. We’re traveling back home tomorrow so I should be around for deadline. Hydrad is still town.

what analysis?

[LaLight]

I find the EFHW wagon troubling. It built quickly based on not much, although there is always not much D1. I’m certainly not reading her as scum enough to vote her. Robz is still a decent vote. faust’s analysis of LaLight seems like the best case of the day at this point. We’re traveling back home tomorrow so I should be around for deadline. Hydrad is still town.

what analysis?

ah, my analysis about faust. I read it vice versa

[LaLight]

I don't like EFHW wagon much as well

[faust]

Something’s really off with faust’s play in this game

How? Do you think he is scummy?

I think this is somewhat very different from usual faust's play and I think this is more scummy than not. I already mentioned his strange claim and change of mind about it in 3,5 minutes at the very beginning of the game and he just seems less thoughtful in this game. I don't believe that he is scumhunting

And have I ever been less thoughtful as scum?

[faust]

Also I will probably be entertaining my parents around the time of the deadline.

[LaLight]

Something’s really off with faust’s play in this game

How? Do you think he is scummy?

I think this is somewhat very different from usual faust's play and I think this is more scummy than not. I already mentioned his strange claim and change of mind about it in 3,5 minutes at the very beginning of the game and he just seems less thoughtful in this game. I don't believe that he is scumhunting

And have I ever been less thoughtful as scum?

That's WIFOM. And scum makes mistakes

[EFHW]

Vote: LaLight

I am convinced now. This is a good lynch.

Convinced by what?

Answer to this?

[faust]

Vote: LaLight

I am convinced now. This is a good lynch.

Convinced by what?

Answer to this?

By LaLight's scumminess.

[faust]

Something’s really off with faust’s play in this game

How? Do you think he is scummy?

I think this is somewhat very different from usual faust's play and I think this is more scummy than not. I already mentioned his strange claim and change of mind about it in 3,5 minutes at the very beginning of the game and he just seems less thoughtful in this game. I don't believe that he is scumhunting

And have I ever been less thoughtful as scum?

That's WIFOM. And scum makes mistakes

But you still fail to provide a reason for why my behaviour is more likely to come from scum!me than town!me.

[LaLight]

Something’s really off with faust’s play in this game

How? Do you think he is scummy?

I think this is somewhat very different from usual faust's play and I think this is more scummy than not. I already mentioned his strange claim and change of mind about it in 3,5 minutes at the very beginning of the game and he just seems less thoughtful in this game. I don't believe that he is scumhunting

And have I ever been less thoughtful as scum?

That's WIFOM. And scum makes mistakes

But you still fail to provide a reason for why my behaviour is more likely to come from scum!me than town!me.

Because I don't see you scumhunting, because scum feels more pressure and makes decisions that they think are good for town, but they are not (still talking about your claim). Scum has more information and they can't hide it perfectly every time. When someone doesn't look like usual self, it's probable they's scum. We don't know what scum knows about the game and/or setup. What if you win if kill Samurai Jack so mcmc's proposal that eventually outs Jack came in handy and you claimed just to out Galz? These are my assumptions, but it all bases on the fact you act weirdely therefore you are more likely to be scum. And why in the world would you turn on your inner Awaclus and just say LaLight is scum? Do you even try to convince people to lynch me?

[faust]

I have scumhunted. I have done twice as much for this game as anyone else. This may well still be below what you are used to. That is because if noone seems to care about the game, it is pretty hard to care myself.

[faust]

And I don't want to discuss my claim, but what you put out there as reasoning is obvious conspiracy theory level stuff.

[faust]

And the reason I am not making a case on you is because I don't have one. Your posts feel scummy. Either others see that too or they don't.

[mcmcsalot]

So I think lalight is wrong about Faust. But I don’t think that means lalight is scum. Lalight has had some very lackluster games recently (especially when compared to the standard I had previously held for him) and so sort of bad logic and not fleshed out cases is kind of what I have grown to expect from town lalight. It feels like since his really poor sk game in lost Mafia there have been multiple games where I was like “oh he has to be scum” and then it turns out to be a mislynch.

[mcmcsalot]

I think idp is town and don’t want to say why.

- IDP has 7 posts since game start, and like 1-2 of them are him stating VLA. Not calling IDP out for anything, but I fail to see how anything he said could give anyone ANY read (whether town or skum) so far in the game.
- Question at IDP... when you you feel comfortable giving the reason?

I will feel comfortable giving the reason when it becomes relevant. It is not a strong enough reason to outweigh any decent case and thus wouldn’t be worth mentioning until the point that it’s relevant.

[mcmcsalot]

I think idp is town and don’t want to say why.

- IDP has 7 posts since game start, and like 1-2 of them are him stating VLA. Not calling IDP out for anything, but I fail to see how anything he said could give anyone ANY read (whether town or skum) so far in the game.
- Question at IDP... when you you feel comfortable giving the reason?

I will feel comfortable giving the reason when it becomes relevant. It is not a strong enough reason to outweigh any decent case and thus wouldn’t be worth mentioning until the point that it’s relevant.

*fixed quote fail.

[EFHW]

And the reason I am not making a case on you is because I don't have one. Your posts feel scummy. Either others see that too or they don't.

Isn't this unlike town!you as well?

[faust]

And the reason I am not making a case on you is because I don't have one. Your posts feel scummy. Either others see that too or they don't.

Isn't this unlike town!you as well?

No.

[EFHW]

I don't like EFHW wagon much as well

I think Robz is the scummiest vote on my wagon. vote: Robz.

[EFHW]

And the reason I am not making a case on you is because I don't have one. Your posts feel scummy. Either others see that too or they don't.

Isn't this unlike town!you as well?

No.

It seems like you are looking for an easy mislynch.

[faust]

And the reason I am not making a case on you is because I don't have one. Your posts feel scummy. Either others see that too or they don't.

Isn't this unlike town!you as well?

No.

It seems like you are looking for an easy mislynch.

If I was looking for an easy mislynch, wouldn't I still be voting for you?

[EFHW]

And the reason I am not making a case on you is because I don't have one. Your posts feel scummy. Either others see that too or they don't.

Isn't this unlike town!you as well?

No.

It seems like you are looking for an easy mislynch.

If I was looking for an easy mislynch, wouldn't I still be voting for you?

I don't know. I almost never get lynched. Good to know you've decided I'm town, though.

[faust]

And the reason I am not making a case on you is because I don't have one. Your posts feel scummy. Either others see that too or they don't.

Isn't this unlike town!you as well?

No.

It seems like you are looking for an easy mislynch.

If I was looking for an easy mislynch, wouldn't I still be voting for you?

I don't know. I almost never get lynched. Good to know you've decided I'm town, though.

I have not, but if I am trying to convince you of something, I might as well do it under the assumption that you are, since otherwise the whole thing is pretty pointless. I will hardly be able to convince you that you are scum.

[faust]

Also last time I checked you were at L-2. What makes you so sure you won't be lynched here?