Plan A(waclus): claim drafting order now. Get 100% correct ordering, out our PRs without knowing where in the order any individual scum comes because they could have permuted their numbers. Go into D2 likely to be one strong PR down, another one blocked etc.
Plan B: Hold off on claiming. Lose 1-2 townies probably, hold a claim on D2 instead. Get useful PR results at night. Maybe only lose a VT. Town tells the truth about their draft order, scum permutes again. Do they risk trying to guess what slot the missing townie has? Probably depends on where in the order they claim and how much they want to gamble, but it's a risky thing. And we have a D1's-worth of scumreads to help us make a claiming order to put the scummier-looking people at the top, thereby decreasing their chances of guessing the slot of a dead townie. All in all, we're likely to get the same claiming order as D1, but with a lower likelihood of loss of key PRs over VTs.
Of course, we don't even have to claim on D2. All we have to agree is that Plan B is stronger than Plan A, and we're good to get on with normal D1 accusations and stuff instead of this notion that we should claim.