@gkriek, you are totally mischaracterizing my objection to the Galz lynch: I was definitely not arguing he was town, but that I preferred not to push someone who I thought had a strong chance of flipping SK, and wanted to push a wagon that had a higher chance of not losing the game.
But my logic held even better for galz not being the SK than not being town. It was obvious when he sat at L-1 for so long that he really couldn’t be the SK.
So right now do you believe EFHW is scum or do you believe it was a double bus?
What I thought at the time was that Hydrad was the SK who the mafia knew about. It felt like it made sense for Galz, because his play didn't seem particularly team-like, whereas if mafia knew who the SK was, then piling onto him like people piled onto Galz at the start of last day phase made a lot of sense, especially when they could use his scummy-looking hammer and subsequent absence as cover.
I'd would be surprised if scums double-bussed on their RB, and EFHW is not looking like the towniest one here. Your argument doesn't hold, though, because while an SK wants to lynch town, yesterday we particularly
didn't want to lynch the SK because it would probably have been handing the game to mafia. So an SK could sit there on L-1 due to mafia and not be hammered by cautious town -- I don't see any problem with that.