Vote: theorel
Not sure I like this ending though
Naah, we totally had it in the bag anyway. I actually cleared schadd and PPS. WW claimed a role and wasn't about to be counterclaimed, and if he
had been counterclaimed, we could just have lynched both him and the counterclaimant and secured the win. I think EFHW is absolutely right to make the day run its course, though.
I'd overstated my townread on theorel towards the end of D2, because it seemed the safest way to push schadd as townie without giving away that I had extra information. That was because schadd was
not reading as townie to me in the slightest... In the absence of my "not aes sedai" result on him, I'd totally have given into pressure and joined his lynch :-P Having seemingly wacky townreads just seemed the surest way of diverting from schadd and onto someone I
was actively scumreading. Re-reading theorel after getting Swan's flip made me wonder about his D2 opening in retrospect, but certainly earlier on I'd read him as nullish-to-maybe-town, so I think he played well.
I was only being coy about giving away my "not Aes Sedai" result on PPS because I wanted the remaining scum to worry that I had something incriminating on them, in the hope they'd come out as vig, because even forcing a 1v1 was great for town, and a quicker win for us than risking running up to lylo. I've actually really enjoyed the way the gameplay made me have to do reads while simultaneously trying to plot role stuff behind the scenes :-)
Anyway,
vote: theorel