Robz re-read and notes
Only 19 game posts.. this won't take long, will it?
Doesn't give townpoints to Joseph for the massclaim suggestion, but also specifically says he hasn't thought about the utility of a claim in this game. Then posts about being on holiday and is gone till after a prod.
Votes mcmc on his return. He joined the wagon in L-3 position, but it was already looking inevitable. He did come in with the observation that mcmc should perhaps have voted if he was so sure one of schadd and WW would be scum, because 50% is pretty decent.
A couple more posts deal with WW's questions about his use of language around segueing away from talking about schadd-WW to talking about TWM-Galz, and whether his working implied that he also thought that one of schadd and WW may be scum.
There are a few comments back and forth with theorel about vigs, then at post #310 Robz says that scum!theorel would have known mcmc would flip town.. which is the thing Galz points out as evidence that Robz could be scum, because he's possibly-deliberately left the SK out of the thinking he presented.
At #338 Robz one-ups Galz's mini-scum-case by pointing out that Galz shouldn't have discounted SK!theorel from his thinking. I think it's invalid reasoning on Robz's part, though, because Galz was only responding to Robz's earlier statement. Possibly I'm just trying to read too much into a joke post by Robz anyway.
Robz then disappears for ages again.. and I think that's something of benefit to scum in this game, particularly as he doesn't come in with any decent excuse/apology for being prodable for a second time this game (outside of the time he was away). He comes back declaring with a townread on TWM, which seems an odd choice, because I think other people seem more townie.
I'm not impressed by his theorel vote at #400, particularly because Robz justifies it by saying "he apparently can't help himself", which sets Robz's action up as more of a policy vote because theorel is going against Robz's suggestion. Not only did theorel justify why he feels the way he does (and Robz engaged with that not at all), but for someone with a growing wagon at a point where we're nearing a deadline, I'd really like to see votes made with a definite suspicion of scumminess, or at least a pro-town intent, and this doesn't really look like either of those things.