I've spent most of the last little while making a reads list:
Robz888 -- Yeah, I don't like his posts much. He supports Galz's awful logic, and then shrugs off being called on it, and doesn't do much else of content.
DatSwan -- Don't like how much he seems to be antagonizing faust, but he seems townie in hoe carelessly he's posting. I say carelessly because using language like "not to be a horrible person but.." is generally a sign of needing to spend a little longer working on tone and empathy and questioning your own motives and stuff.
faust -- Makes a lot of sense to me, which is not always the case with scum!faust, so he can be town for now.
SirClemens -- kinda null so far. Note even as talkative as me :-P
mcmcsalot -- Someone just psoted a case for town!mcmc, and I can't unsee it at the moment, so I acknowledge bias but think he can be town for now too.
Teproc -- He's making several comments about Iguana in Lost, but I feel like this situation is a bit different, and would involve rather more invention on Iguana's part, so I'm a bit suspicious of Teproc's motive here. Though it turns out he was the one posting about town mcmc, which would be kind of bolder whiteknighting if he's that scummy. Nullish, I guess?
pingpongsam -- Like I just said, he'll scumslip for us if we let him be for a while. Especially in a setup like this :-)
Galzria -- Baaad probability stuff. I agree interactions are good, but so are accurate priors. Makes him less good at probabilities, rather than more scummy. I don't think I find his text all that bad.
iguanaiguana -- probably town, but to be revisited later. People have already pointed out that he's painted a target on himself, so I hope his super-duper role can handle that.
Cuzz -- He's a bit antagonistic in his interactions, but he's asking a lot of decent questions. Townie side of null.
The_Wine_Merchant -- Surprisingly little here so far. Not sure I like the sheep vote. Null for now.
SpaceAnemone -- Spaaaaaaace. I always do this, and I'm almost always town. Coincidence??
LaLight -- I'm having a hard time getting a read on him. A couple of things posting about his past town performances ring danger bells, but it's not like he'd have a super-low chance of doing that as town either. Nullish-scum maybe?
I'm happy leaving my vote on Robz for now, but I don't have a high degree of confidence in anything right now becuase this is D1, and anemones are not known for their strong reads...