Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Roadrunner7671]

Ha I didn't realize I was already voting for theorel, but I'm happy to take the scum points for it 

[schadd]

egh robz can be town too

[Robz888]

Has any one done analysis on whether No Lynch is bad here?

[schadd]

analysis
[|||||-----] 50%
[||||||||||] 100%
done!
no lynch is bad

[SpaceAnemone]

SpaceAnemone: buddying me maybe?

Haha. Not my motive there. I liked your thinking in the posts, and I thought your tactic of voting for me at #83 was subtle scum-hunting. You said you were voting because you liked IDP's earlier argument, and that argument was purely based on an earlier game before I'd even posted in this one (it's at #53). So either you were making a really very lazy lie, or you were trying something on to see who'd bite. I assumed the latter, which was why I waited to see who'd hop on rather than protesting the unreasonableness of it.

Sadly, Joseph was the only one to hop on and join you, and he's a bit random and doesn't really think these things through anyway, so I don't think it's as big a scum-tell for him as it might be for others.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Has any one done analysis on whether No Lynch is bad here?

If we want to no-lynch, we have to vote for it. I don't think it's good here but I think it could be good if we've lynched a mime.

5. If the deadline is hit without a player reaching the majority of votes, the player with the most votes will be lynched. If two or more players are tied, whoever had more votes at the end of the previous Day is lynched. If still tied, the lynchee is determined randomly among the tied players.

Also, I won't be around at the deadline but I should be around a couple hours beforehand. Sorry for another completely dead D1 from me. I still don't think silver is town.

[silverspawn]

I figured it out! no-lynching is not good. Thanks, thanks, you're welcome.

[Swowl]

I do not like the idea of not lynching. Given both skum teams have DC we need to take advantage of gaining information everywhere possible. The way I look at is silverspawn is either Mafia or VT and I am on the fence for both. Leaving my vote there for now, but I will be around throughout the rest of the day.

Also, side note... not really to be used now today, but to be remembered later, since there is the whole DC thing on both skum teams... I like the chances of finding skum in the lurkers decently well.

[Joseph2302]

I figured it out! no-lynching is not good. Thanks, thanks, you're welcome.

Is it ever good?

[schadd]

I figured it out! no-lynching is not good. Thanks, thanks, you're welcome.

you're welcome

[Awaclus]

I figured it out! no-lynching is not good. Thanks, thanks, you're welcome.

Is it ever good?

Yes.

[Joseph2302]

I figured it out! no-lynching is not good. Thanks, thanks, you're welcome.

Is it ever good?

Yes.

Very rarely, and never on D1

[SpaceAnemone]

lekkit and space i like for not town

Wrong on at least one count. Does that make you more or less likely to be right on the other one?

do you suppose i have enough information to make an accurate call on lekkit?

Yes, because you are some sort of magical being who likes forming reads out of the information vacuum that is a typical D1. Though you're underperforming here!

[silverspawn]

In RMMs it can be good if town is strong enough, the problem is just that we usually don't know. But in this setup, absolutely not.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Ugh. I am a bad person. Sorry.

I was hoping I would have avoided the prod, but just missed it. I'll catch up now and vote.

[Robz888]

Vote: Silverspawn because we need a lynch I guess? I'll be here for the next three hours, on a train with little else to do.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Hi everyone, I'm a mime. I'm telling you so you'll lynch me out of WIFOM.

This is true. I know because I'm the other mime

Vote for vote: joseph I dislike his mime claim more than silver's because joseph already opened with the dumb SK claim. Feel like he realized this would be a weird way to get early attention and see it dissipate after silver did his. Whereas silver's just looks like early game antics.

Highly doubt either of them are actually mimes.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Well. Two days in and I am already behind. All the sorriez. I'll catch up over the weekend.

Obv!scum post here

Phoowey!

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Vote: Space
Wagons.
Also, L-4

Still ok here. I like voting for wagons. I dislike stating the reason is voting for wagons.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

So quick meta question based off this post, mostly relating to Joseph and silver at this point, what advantage does either mafia or mime have to look really suspicious? I know that lynching is how mimes win. OK. But there is a chance that this setup has a vig right? I guess mafia and mime might know that there isn't based on what their roles were. But there are a few options where mafia or mimes might not know and think there could be?

Looking at it doesn't look like it is as conclusive as I thought. Until we figure out what mafia and mimes might have known about the setup going into the start of game.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Vote: theorel

Too much overjustification.

Oh dear. I am agreeing with Awaclus.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Don't like the contents of this post or its conclusion to vote RR, who has been a pretty good voice of towniness thus far.

temporary vote: theorel But slightly dependent on the answer to the question below:

Theorel, are you familiar with RR and his meta? I feel like I don't know much about you.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

And a vote count so I can remember where everyone is at:

theorel (5): Roadrunner7671, Awaclus, Joseph2302, silver, TWM
SpaceAnemone (1): IDontPlayThisGame
Joseph2302 (1): SpaceAnemone
Lekkit (1): schadd
sivlerspawn (3): Lekkit, DatSwan, Robz
RR 1 - theorel

Looks like my theorel vote was L-2, by the way.

[Robz888]

Vote: theorel

Something was off about him.

[SpaceAnemone]

Bed time now. Will try to be awake just before the deadline. I'm not super-keen on the theorel wagon just because the stuff they've been posting seems okay to me, but I haven't played with them before (have I?), so I have no typical behaviour with which to compare it. As a verbose and detail-oriented person, I feel like over-explanation isn't necessarily something that's scummy.

I'd be willing to fo to Robz, I think -- his wagon-hopping doesn't feel like it's got much genuine opinion behind it. Lots of people don't seem to be saying a lot, though. Let's go with vote: Lekkit while I sleep.