Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[silverspawn]

I would say scum = town

[silverspawn]

you scum

[Roadrunner7671]

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

[IDontPlayThisGame]

We should establish whether scum = non-town or scum = mafia.

I think scum = non-town will lead to more confusion than sticking to scum = mafia.

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

Or town doing something really strange. But I'm inclined to agree with you.

[silverspawn]

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

almost sounds like lynching me would be a good idea!

[silverspawn]

think about it, I'm lynched day 1 all the time anyway, so as a mime I have no reason to claim mime, clearly I must be mafia claiming to be a mime.

[schadd]

think about it, I'm lynched day 1 all the time anyway, so as a mime I have no reason to claim mime, clearly I must be mafia claiming to be a mime.

Unsubscribe > This content is no longer relevant to me

[SpaceAnemone]

We should establish whether scum = non-town or scum = mafia.

I was thinking of "scum" as being the mafia faction, at least when I said that I don't think Joseph is scum. He could be a mime, in that he's being about the same as usual, and I usually want to lynch him for not being particularly pro-town, so that would be good play for a mime.

[silverspawn]

think about it, I'm lynched day 1 all the time anyway, so as a mime I have no reason to claim mime, clearly I must be mafia claiming to be a mime.

Unsubscribe > This content is no longer relevant to me

 

[Swowl]

We should establish whether scum = non-town or scum = mafia.

I think scum = non-town will lead to more confusion than sticking to scum = mafia.

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

You don't think it likely for a VT to claim mime?

Or town doing something really strange. But I'm inclined to agree with you.

[Swowl]

Vote Count 1.1

silverspawn (1): Awaclus
theorel (1): Roadrunner7671
SpaceAnemone (2): IDontPlayThisGame, theorel
silverspawn (2): silverspawn, Joseph2302
Joseph2302 (1): SpaceAnemone
Lekkit (1): schadd

Not Voting (4): Robz888, The_Wine_Merchant, DatSwan, Lekkit

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day 1 ends Jan 25 at 4 am forum time.

SilverSpawn is listed twice (first and then fourth) for "votes on him"

[Swowl]

someone else claimed mime right? I can't find it - who was it?

[IDontPlayThisGame]

We should establish whether scum = non-town or scum = mafia.

I think scum = non-town will lead to more confusion than sticking to scum = mafia.

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

You don't think it likely for a VT to claim mime?

Or town doing something really strange. But I'm inclined to agree with you.

I'm assuming the bit in bold is what you meant to say outside of the quote because I didn't say that. Ignore whether it's likely. How is it pro-town for town!silver to claim mime and try to keep selling it like this? How does it help us find mafia?

[Robz888]

Hey all. Sorry, I've not been helping much. Having a hard time getting into this one. Will try harder this week.

[Swowl]

We should establish whether scum = non-town or scum = mafia.

I think scum = non-town will lead to more confusion than sticking to scum = mafia.

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

You don't think it likely for a VT to claim mime?

Or town doing something really strange. But I'm inclined to agree with you.

I'm assuming the bit in bold is what you meant to say outside of the quote because I didn't say that. Ignore whether it's likely. How is it pro-town for town!silver to claim mime and try to keep selling it like this? How does it help us find mafia?

... how does it not?

[Swowl]

We should establish whether scum = non-town or scum = mafia.

I think scum = non-town will lead to more confusion than sticking to scum = mafia.

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

You don't think it likely for a VT to claim mime?

Or town doing something really strange. But I'm inclined to agree with you.

I'm assuming the bit in bold is what you meant to say outside of the quote because I didn't say that. Ignore whether it's likely. How is it pro-town for town!silver to claim mime and try to keep selling it like this? How does it help us find mafia?

And yes sorry i suck at phone posting

[Swowl]

We should establish whether scum = non-town or scum = mafia.

I think scum = non-town will lead to more confusion than sticking to scum = mafia.

I don't like this SS play. He's either mafia or a mime, right?

You don't think it likely for a VT to claim mime?

Or town doing something really strange. But I'm inclined to agree with you.

I'm assuming the bit in bold is what you meant to say outside of the quote because I didn't say that. Ignore whether it's likely. How is it pro-town for town!silver to claim mime and try to keep selling it like this? How does it help us find mafia?

... how does it not?

And that is not like a Awaclus-esc “how is it not”... like really- you don’t see the positive side from a VT/Town Perspective of this play?

[silverspawn]

SilverSpawn

vote: DatSwan for bastardizing my name

[faust]

SilverSpawn is listed twice (first and then fourth) for "votes on him"

Fixed now.

[Joseph2302]

someone else claimed mime right? I can't find it - who was it?

Me

[theorel]

So, the question is: is claiming mime a survivalist tell?

-Town does not want to lynch mimes, so claiming mimes might look like trying not to get lynched.  This is something scum would do.
-But actual mimes will not claim mime, so claiming mime doesn't actually make you look like a mime, hence it doesn't actually decrease your chance of getting lynched...arguably it increases it (as any controversial action would).
-But then, if it does increase the chance of being lynched then it becomes a claim mime is likely to make...which brings us back to the beginning, hence the WIFOM.

Controversial actions also increase town interaction, pulling people to speak up, and providing opportunity to find scum through their "unnatural" responses, so claiming mime is potentially pro-town (as any sufficiently controversial action is).  So, since silverspawn is town, I will sheep and vote: silverspawn.

[Awaclus]

Vote: theorel

Too much overjustification.

[silverspawn]

theorel speaks the sense.

[Joseph2302]

So, the question is: is claiming mime a survivalist tell?

-Town does not want to lynch mimes, so claiming mimes might look like trying not to get lynched.  This is something scum would do.
-But actual mimes will not claim mime, so claiming mime doesn't actually make you look like a mime, hence it doesn't actually decrease your chance of getting lynched...arguably it increases it (as any controversial action would).
-But then, if it does increase the chance of being lynched then it becomes a claim mime is likely to make...which brings us back to the beginning, hence the WIFOM.

Controversial actions also increase town interaction, pulling people to speak up, and providing opportunity to find scum through their "unnatural" responses, so claiming mime is potentially pro-town (as any sufficiently controversial action is).  So, since silverspawn is town, I will sheep and vote: silverspawn.

You think ss is town and therefore you vote for them?!
That seems scummy.
Vote: theorel

[Robz888]

Also sort of suspicious of theorel for disguising "actually it's WIFOM" as detailed analysis.