I think there’s a fine case against you. Better than any put forward on anybody else. Your defense of “But I wouldn’t do any of that as scum” is meaningless - it’s literally “because of X I’m town”, which is EXACTLY how you would try to act as scum.
No, this is just so wrong. You argue that I am scum precisely because of something you think I wouldn't do as town. At the same time you claim that as scum I would act the same as town.
I feel like I’ve explained this case, but boiled down:
I think you did something (start the EFHW wagon) not thinking it would go anywhere. Your case was flawed, and you asked people to join for a dumb reason (thank you PM’s). When it started to gain traction, You began to feel trapped. It doesn’t matter that the reasons were bad, they were your reasons. You had to stand by them. But you started to push Joth instead, trying to pull attention away from EFHW. When that ultimately fell through, you finally bailed on EFHW and argued everybody else do the same.
That’s a very reasonable argument. Your defense of “no, that’s not what so would do if I were scum” doesn’t really matter, because your inate argument is that “I only acted that way because I’m town” - but if we were to allow that a grain of truth then we must also allow that as scum you would be attempting to emulate that play.
Now, scum isn’t Joth. And it’s not e. And it’s not me. And it’s not MiX.
That leaves voters #6, #7 & #8: Awaclus, Glooble & Space
That leaves voter #2 & #3: WCD & Swan
The first two joined on wagon there joined when you were pushing it. If they’re partners with EFHW, that’s really rough for scum.
So that makes Glooble, Awaclus & Space as realistic possible bussers. Off wagon, hey, we agree on being ok with pubby being Town (for now). We’re going not Eddie too. That leaves 4: You, Shraeye, PPS & ADK. ADK we’ve marked as not-EFHW-partner.
So, removing yourself, you have:
Off wagon [PPS, Shraeye]
On wagon [Awaclus, Space, Glooble]
Two of those players should be scum. Do you believe scum double-bussed? Why? What supports it? If not, then which of PPS or Shraeye is scum and why?