Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Glooble]

Eddie is either town or scum who has played in enough ashersky-run role madness games to know not to try and claim a “normal” role. My role is also a whole pile of stuff, so he got that part right.

[MiX]

Eddie is either town or scum who has played in enough ashersky-run role madness games to know not to try and claim a “normal” role. My role is also a whole pile of stuff, so he got that part right.

Or scum that has a partner that has played in enough ash RMMs. I wouldn't know, but I bet EFHW fills the bill, right?

[MiX]

Space is scum every way I look at the VCA.

Vote: Space

This is due to their Galz vote and subsequent bussing, which makes them appear in every scummy list, they're even the most likely partner with shraeye when he looks scummier, it's crazy!

This is all assuming ADK and Eddie aren't scum, however.

[A Drowned Kernel]

Eddie is either town or scum who has played in enough ashersky-run role madness games to know not to try and claim a “normal” role. My role is also a whole pile of stuff, so he got that part right.

This could all also all be true and he could still be scum

[A Drowned Kernel]

Eddie is either town or scum who has played in enough ashersky-run role madness games to know not to try and claim a “normal” role. My role is also a whole pile of stuff, so he got that part right.

This could all also all be true and he could still be scum

The stuff he claimed, that is

[2.71828.....]

Yeah, I think I am still leaving towards lynching Eddie given all the claims, vote counts, and play

Vote: Uncleeurope

[MiX]

Okay, so do we shoot him or lynch him? I'm fine either way, but I guess lynching is better to wait for more information?

Vote: Eddie

[ashersky]

Vote Count 2.14:

faust (3): joth, pubby, Glooble
ADK (1): Uncle
Uncle (5): ADK, Awaclus, WCD, 2.7, MiX
MiX (1): Space
Space (2): shraeye, PPS
shraeye (2): faust, Galzria

Not Voting (2): Datswan

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.  Day 2 ends at 10:00 p.m. on August 12.

[pubby]

Shooting is better in case he was lying about how his effect triggers.

I don't know if I agree with killing him tonight. A mislynch would kill 2 townies.

[pubby]

*today, not tonight

[faust]

Okay, so do we shoot him or lynch him? I'm fine either way, but I guess lynching is better to wait for more information?

Vote: Eddie

Shooting is better.

[faust]

Actually... MiX, can you inherit 1-shot powers that have been used?

[2.71828.....]

Actually... MiX, can you inherit 1-shot powers that have been used?

Lynching ADK and giving MiX the shot? I thought about that.

[2.71828.....]

But I think I prefer lynching Eddie over that idea

[shraeye]

I guess they were off wagon, so there is that.

Are we just running everyone who was off wagon up to L-1?

That seems to be the master plan.

I oppose the vig-Eddie plan too.  I feel like everybody's reads are still off enough that vig+lynch is likely to result in two town losses and give up our advantage.  It seems there are some sweet "I know things, or have the power to learn things" abilities; why not wait until we KNOW KNOW a scum and shoot that?

[MiX]

Actually... MiX, can you inherit 1-shot powers that have been used?

I don't know. I've asked a similar question to ash and haven't gotten a response.

Okay, so do we shoot him or lynch him? I'm fine either way, but I guess lynching is better to wait for more information?

Vote: Eddie

Shooting is better.

Why is shooting better? If we want ADK to be out of a shot, can't we force them to shoot D3 instead?

PPE: Yeah that seems correct.

[2.71828.....]

I guess they were off wagon, so there is that.

Are we just running everyone who was off wagon up to L-1?

That seems to be the master plan.

I oppose the vig-Eddie plan too.  I feel like everybody's reads are still off enough that vig+lynch is likely to result in two town losses and give up our advantage.  It seems there are some sweet "I know things, or have the power to learn things" abilities; why not wait until we KNOW KNOW a scum and shoot that?

I think vig ends the day, so it wouldn't be big+lynch today

[shraeye]

Space is scum every way I look at the VCA.

Vote: Space

This is due to their Galz vote and subsequent bussing, which makes them appear in every scummy list, they're even the most likely partner with shraeye when he looks scummier, it's crazy!

This is all assuming ADK and Eddie aren't scum, however.

While I resent the implication that I could be Space's partner, I'm chuffed to bits that you've seen the light and figured out Space is scum.

[MiX]

I guess they were off wagon, so there is that.

Are we just running everyone who was off wagon up to L-1?

That seems to be the master plan.

I oppose the vig-Eddie plan too.  I feel like everybody's reads are still off enough that vig+lynch is likely to result in two town losses and give up our advantage.  It seems there are some sweet "I know things, or have the power to learn things" abilities; why not wait until we KNOW KNOW a scum and shoot that?

I think vig ends the day, so it wouldn't be big+lynch today

Does it? If so then yes, shoot, otherwise keeping it seems better.

Wait what's the point of dayvig if all it does is give you infinite votes?

[jotheonah]

I guess they were off wagon, so there is that.

Are we just running everyone who was off wagon up to L-1?

That seems to be the master plan.

I oppose the vig-Eddie plan too.  I feel like everybody's reads are still off enough that vig+lynch is likely to result in two town losses and give up our advantage.  It seems there are some sweet "I know things, or have the power to learn things" abilities; why not wait until we KNOW KNOW a scum and shoot that?

We have no guarantee ADK is around tomorrow. Scum will kill whomever they think is most dangerous to them, even a third party.

[MiX]

I guess they were off wagon, so there is that.

Are we just running everyone who was off wagon up to L-1?

That seems to be the master plan.

I oppose the vig-Eddie plan too.  I feel like everybody's reads are still off enough that vig+lynch is likely to result in two town losses and give up our advantage.  It seems there are some sweet "I know things, or have the power to learn things" abilities; why not wait until we KNOW KNOW a scum and shoot that?

We have no guarantee ADK is around tomorrow. Scum will kill whomever they think is most dangerous to them, even a third party.

I am so accepting a third-party dayvig dying, especially when I get the shot.

[2.71828.....]

Looked up to confirm what I was thinking

Lynching me results in three bad things and two good things. (I clarified this and day-vig counts as lynch here)

Vig ends day based on this.

[MiX]

Looked up to confirm what I was thinking

Lynching me results in three bad things and two good things. (I clarified this and day-vig counts as lynch here)

Vig ends day based on this.

That's different, Eddie probably has "if you die during the day" or just "not NKd" (or whatever is equivelent), he doesn't have access to ADK's role to know otherwise.

[2.71828.....]

Looked up to confirm what I was thinking

Lynching me results in three bad things and two good things. (I clarified this and day-vig counts as lynch here)

Vig ends day based on this.

That's different, Eddie probably has "if you die during the day" or just "not NKd" (or whatever is equivelent), he doesn't have access to ADK's role to know otherwise.

Oh, ok. I guess I should ask for clarification

[2.71828.....]

Another thought. There was a very specific 2 hour twilight phase at the end of D1.

ADK- can you shoot during twilight?