Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[ashersky]

Vote Count 2.9:

faust (2): joth, MiX
ADK (2): WCD, Datswan
Uncle (4): faust, ADK, 2.7, Awaclus
MiX (1): Space
Space (2): shraeye, PPS
PPS (1): Uncle

Not Voting (3): Galzria, Glooble, pubby

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.  Day 2 ends at 10:00 p.m. on August 12.

[pingpongsam]

I may have to sub out. I was so busy today this game never crossed my mind. I’m sticking to it through this weekend as I should be pretty free then. I’ll be driving tomorrow for a few hours. I feel like an ass as this has normally not been an issue but it was problematic in my last game too.

[pingpongsam]

Pretty impressed with Joth’s work. Was feeling more and more town on MiX today as he came clean about his role but Joth’s analysis sealed the deal, there. I’m still good with my Space vote but would definitely consider Faust as well. Don’t have anything concrete for anyone else, though.

Joth, what would you say about No Lynch today? I have never, ever seen it as a viable option and was taught that even suggesting it was scummy but you made compelling arguments for it yesterday.

[Uncleeurope]

Vote: Faust

[Uncleeurope]

Vote: Faust

[Swowl]

EFHW would be okay with me, better than Joth, I think.

In a dream world we would take a closer look at ADK (who people refuse to talk about) or WCD (who people are extremely mixed on). And Space, but I always suspect Space for whatever reason.

And Awaclus, because Awaclus. Has he announced having less time? He seems quieter than usual, which is significant.

Eddie is town.

Wait what?

Eddie says “EFHW would be ok with me, better than Joth”.
Then Eddie ends the day voting for not EFHW, but instead for Joth.

Like i am actually finding Eddie more towny today than i was previously, but for completely separate reasons.

The post you quoted is more like “i could vote for EFHW... i would do that over Joth... but here are some other options to throw in the pit (space, adk)”.... and then again, ended up on Joth.


Where do you derive “Eddie is town” from this quote?

PPE 1

[WestCoastDidds]

So much work, Joth, thank you.

I’m putting some of your conclusions here so they are easier for me to get back to:

1) still pretty into the faust 3D chess theory. Yes he started the EFHW wagon, but he tried way harder to stop it.
2) Space, Glooble, MiX, myself, and e all tried to stop it at various points but then in the end when the chips were down and we needed a lynch they/we got on board. I actually, ultimately, don't think you find scum here. It was too easy just to not show up, and then maybe the lynch doesn't happen. I guess we can throw Swan in that camp too.
3) Eddie, pubby, ADK, faust, these are the people who tried hardest to stop the wagon and ended off wagon.

shraeye also goes on the scumspect list.

[jotheonah]

EFHW would be okay with me, better than Joth, I think.

In a dream world we would take a closer look at ADK (who people refuse to talk about) or WCD (who people are extremely mixed on). And Space, but I always suspect Space for whatever reason.

And Awaclus, because Awaclus. Has he announced having less time? He seems quieter than usual, which is significant.

Eddie is town.

Wait what?

Eddie says “EFHW would be ok with me, better than Joth”.
Then Eddie ends the day voting for not EFHW, but instead for Joth.

Like i am actually finding Eddie more towny today than i was previously, but for completely separate reasons.

The post you quoted is more like “i could vote for EFHW... i would do that over Joth... but here are some other options to throw in the pit (space, adk)”.... and then again, ended up on Joth.


Where do you derive “Eddie is town” from this quote?

PPE 1

I jumped the gun on that one. Reading on further, Eddie is very possibly not town.

[jotheonah]

Stream of consciousness analysis has downsides!

[Uncleeurope]

Nah, I’m town.

[shraeye]

Joth, why do you have Shraeye as town?

I've been reading shraeye as super townie all game. Do you think he's not?

He didn't hop on the EFHW wagon (I did't either though) and some of his reads have been off in retrospective. Personally I have him in the "leaning town" group rather than "town".

What reads are you talking about in the "retrospectively off" category?

[shraeye]

Stream of consciousness analysis has downsides!

For instance, you correctly found Space suspicious but didn't vote there

[pubby]

Reread some more. EFHW joined the e wagon right before going VLA. Don't see her doing that if e was scum, but 100% don't see her doing that if e was the Queen. e seems super townie to me.

What reads are you talking about in the "retrospectively off" category?

Your reaction to Glooble and WCD early on was funny.

[shraeye]

Bump, pubby

[A Drowned Kernel]

Can I interest anyone else in the pingpongsam wagon? I think his pushing the MiX lynch in spite of the claim -- and his disingenuous characterization of the rest of the town as ICing MiX rather than merely delaying his lynch  -- add up to scum trying to push us into lynching either a PR or, more likely, a troublesome 3rd party.

vote: pingpongsam

and I guess prooobbbabbbblllyyy I need to admit that a third party observer who didn't know how townie I am would have to put me in that bucket also

This is the only post of joth's I didn't like, everything else seemed very towny

[pubby]

Bump, pubby

I already responded I think?

[pubby]

vote: faust

[faust]

Really? Suppose scum!me's plan was to start a wagon on a partner and then derail it once the deadline comes around... why on earth would I choose the partner that has announced VLA leading up to the deadline? That makes no sense whatsoever.

[pubby]

Do you want me to post my case? I was going to wait a few days but I can do it now.

[faust]

338: MiX votes EFHW (first to do so)
346: MiX unvotes EFHW

This right here is indisputable evidence of joth's townieness, and anyone trying to say otherwise is scum.

otherwise

[faust]

Do you want me to post my case? I was going to wait a few days but I can do it now.

I don't really care, but I find it curious that you are asking the player you think is scum for play advice.

[Awaclus]

338: MiX votes EFHW (first to do so)
346: MiX unvotes EFHW

This right here is indisputable evidence of joth's townieness, and anyone trying to say otherwise is scum.

otherwise

Vote: faust

[Awaclus]

(but really vote: Eddie)

[faust]

Vote: faust, why is your power not just a way that scum spends the harnessed children?

Read the flavor. Do you think releasing a child and letting them return to their parents is what the evil scum does?

Also, start of D1 flavor was different.

[Uncleeurope]

Hey, Faust, any other opinions other than my evilness you care to present? It makes it hard to agree with everything you say if you just vote me all the time.