A) Shraeye was a Survivor.
B) We have no proof that ADK is as well, however I believe him.
C) e was also essentially town.
D) There are multiple “non-town” factions that are not “anti-town”.
E) pubby’s flavor text is likely yellow, and that’s completely ok.
F) Shraeye wasn’t lying.
F.1) There’s no benefit to him continuing the charade after he was lynched.
F.2) His anger and indignation wasn’t faked. He was genuinely upset that we “lynched the cop”
F.3) That’s the worst possible fake claim for him to make, as it buys him at most a day if he’s wrong.
F.4) His play throughout D2 is consistent with him having a scum result that he didn’t want to share. He would’ve made himself a target of scum N2.
G) Faust was Joth’s #1 scum read, and I’m supportive of this read. That’s two IC’s that believe Faust is scum.
H) MiX is likely scum. He claimed something yesterday and then contradicted that claim today.
H.1) I don’t know why the result I got on him was “same wincon”, but there are multiple possibilities.
I) I suspect there may be yet another “not green text” “town” faction. That’s part of this setup. Many smaller “town” factions that result in false investigative results.
I.1) This does not apply to Space & Shraeye’s result, as Shraeye was a Survivor, and he was very clear on exactly Space being EFHW’s partner. Not green text, or yellow text, or purple text - but red text.
I.2) Space has claimed very clearly green text, even after being given the option to do otherwise.
I agree with almost all of this:
- All the faction stuff I essentially agree with
E) IDK 100% where I stand on pubby, but agree with the yellow text thought.
F) Shraeye had no reason to lie, the upside does not match the downside (as I already mentioned).
H) MiX contradiction.. I think I know what you are referencing, and I agree there is a possibility that MiX is skum.
F) Space is probably skum, I agree.
*then there is a gap*
Faust) Day 1 makes me feel skummy on him. The fact that he "released a child last night" actually makes me feel slightly less so the more I think about it. If he were skum, it would of caused much more confusion to say he also doctored Galz (once we all woke up to an alive Galz), and then send us spinning on why 2 more kids are gone if that is true. Skum lean here.
E) Like 90% most likely town. But it is possible yellow text has a non-town win con.
*then there is a gap*
ADK) I disagree. There was bound to be something. Regardless, I believe ADK to be Traitor/Mafia/SK at this point. If they are Town, they wouldn't of claimed Survivor. If they are SK, a Survivor claim at the time would be moderately safe as they would know they are 1 faction, then there is a town faction, then there is a skum faction, then E flipped a different faction, and there is the skitter faction... to assume all of that, plus SK (but no survivor), would of been a good claim at the time. If they are traitor, having a day vig seems like a good balancing mechanic for skum. And then there is the possibility that they are just mafia, but not the player with the day vig... this is to say they claim survivor (more ballzy than the SK version, but still possible based on factions and potential skum info), then they post the kill command in the thread (which does nothing), then the REAL day vig posts the command in the skum thread. I agree with whoever said that we should focus on finding the mafia faction today, so ADK is def not my choice... but I also am no where near believing they have a town win con.
lol PPE 10
Author
Topic: RMM48: Falling Skies Mafia (Game Over) (Read 250127 times)