If anyone wants to check my work: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1icsuA1ms80DurUaE-yEDS2t_BtfzVHTT
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1tYzVbV5W4ZMeakuCnQmEzXOR3O99IyDY
I don't understand your table I'm afraid.
I agree with your conclusion, except that
For others to see this - if they believe my analysis in post #1029, anyway - you can see that #1029 together with last night's results implies the existence of 2 yellows and 2 whites last night (the scum).
My guess was
Haddock: RED
e: RED
silver: RED
EFHW: RED
Galz: YELLOW
gkrieg: RED
Awaclus: RED
Swan: RED
Dylan: RED
chairs: RED
WW: BLUE
Iguana: BLUE
Jake: BLUE
and the response was 7 correct and 3 correct but wrong place.
To get 7 correct with 2 yellows and 2 whites, I must have guessed RED correctly 7 times, since my YELLOW guess of Galz was not right (there are reasons I went for that, btw - but they're not important now).
So everyone still alive, except WW, iguana and Jake, is town. But then whatever arrangement of RED/YELLOW/YELLOW we give to those three, we end up with either 6 or 8 fully correct guesses in my N2 guess:
EFHW: YELLOW
ash: RED 1 fully correct
Haddock: RED 2 fully correct
Awaclus: RED
gkrieg: RED
chairs: RED 3 fully correct
e: RED 4 fully correct
DatSwan: YELLOW
silver: RED 5 fully correct
Galz: RED 6 fully correct
Dylan: BLUE
Iguana: RED (If iguana is red, then this is 7, but then WW is yellow, so 8 correct overall)
WW: YELLOW (If WW is red, then iguana and Jake are yellow, so 6 correct overall)
Jake: RED (If Jake is red, then this is 7, but then WW is yellow, so 8 correct overall)
So either my analysis in #1029 is wrong (I'll double check it at some point) or I've definitely been messed with at some point.