Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Galzria]

That's all well and good Galz, except that for the fact that I'm town. You don't know that of course but it does invalidate your argument, for future reference.

I should clarify. You wouldn't know I'm town if you are town as well. Didn't mean for my post to suggest that Galz is definitely town.

Didn't even think of that. But it is a good point

vote: Andrew

You think I would point that out if I was scum?

WIFOM. Get in front of it. Yeah.

Also, "I wouldn't do that as scum" is the most overused and ridiculous argument ever - used pretty equally by town and scum alike.

Nice job trying to make it seem like my question is not worth answering. You'll probably have the same response for every question I pose in my defense. Quickest way to a mislynch right here folks!

Not true at all. And I answered your question. But that's not a defense. A defense has value and merit. "I wouldn't do that as scum" does not. There 's no content there. Yes, you would do that as scum. Or as town. Next?

And actually, not only did I answer it, I gave 2 reasons for WHY you would do it as scum:

1) WIFOM
2) To get out in front of it.

[Robz888]

Sorry. That huh wasn't clear. What "this" are you referring to in that post and further what bearing does it have on Andrew's alignment?

Oh, Andrew was saying he was having trouble forming reads, and I was agreeing with that... I am also having trouble forming reads.

When another player says something I was thinking, or expresses a similar sentiment, without me prompting them or indicating that I feel this way, I read them as town.

[Skumpy]

I feel like my thinking has been a much more tentative versions of Robz's (which makes me wonder about him a little now). I was starting to lean team Galzria, but the new Andrew wagon bothers me a bit.

Probably wrong but Vote: TWM for now
Partially because his 2 votes have been for very obvious unsuspicious reasons while letting everybody else get into heated debate.

And partially because, judging by his signature, he's overdue for a scum role 

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Sorry. That huh wasn't clear. What "this" are you referring to in that post and further what bearing does it have on Andrew's alignment?

Oh, Andrew was saying he was having trouble forming reads, and I was agreeing with that... I am also having trouble forming reads.

When another player says something I was thinking, or expresses a similar sentiment, without me prompting them or indicating that I feel this way, I read them as town.

I was having trouble forming reads too. Still am. Andrew's post was first that made me think one way or another. Think the whole town fits in that basket. And I have to say that sounds like a poor way to form reads. Have you had success with it? Legit question, not trying to delegitimize. I could very much be in the wrong.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

I feel like my thinking has been a much more tentative versions of Robz's (which makes me wonder about him a little now). I was starting to lean team Galzria, but the new Andrew wagon bothers me a bit.

Probably wrong but Vote: TWM for now
Partially because his 2 votes have been for very obvious unsuspicious reasons while letting everybody else get into heated debate.

And partially because, judging by his signature, he's overdue for a scum role 

My very obvious unsuspicious reasons are perfectly valid reasons for voting for someone. Your vote on me doesn't fit that criteria though.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Not sue what you mean about letting others get into debates. Why would I debate things I don't have an opinion or read on?

[AndrewisFTTW]

That's all well and good Galz, except that for the fact that I'm town. You don't know that of course but it does invalidate your argument, for future reference.

I should clarify. You wouldn't know I'm town if you are town as well. Didn't mean for my post to suggest that Galz is definitely town.

Didn't even think of that. But it is a good point

vote: Andrew

You think I would point that out if I was scum?

WIFOM. Get in front of it. Yeah.

Also, "I wouldn't do that as scum" is the most overused and ridiculous argument ever - used pretty equally by town and scum alike.

Nice job trying to make it seem like my question is not worth answering. You'll probably have the same response for every question I pose in my defense. Quickest way to a mislynch right here folks!

Not true at all. And I answered your question. But that's not a defense. A defense has value and merit. "I wouldn't do that as scum" does not. There 's no content there. Yes, you would do that as scum. Or as town. Next?

And actually, not only did I answer it, I gave 2 reasons for WHY you would do it as scum:

1) WIFOM
2) To get out in front of it.

Not sure how I could generate WIFOM from that but whatever. Not interested in arguing with you anymore. It's not fun for me.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Not sure how I could generate WIFOM from that but whatever. Not interested in arguing with you anymore. It's not fun for me.

Cause it is such a fun time for Galz?

He voted for you. You asked why. He provided an answer. You questioned that answer in a passive aggressive post. He responded. It isn't like he is unnecessarily provoking you or something.

I understand that arguing might not be fun, but you seem to be spinning it in a way that makes Galz look like the bad, scummy guy. In my eyes, he is scum hunting. Or at the least doing an adequate job of pretending to scum hunt.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

And if it won't be fun to argue with me, then don't. Only do what is fun to you. Just wanted to put it out there that I approve of what Galz was doing.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Well excuse me Overreacty McGhee. I didn't say Galz is provoking me. I didn't say he was acting in a scummy way. Hell I even think he's pretty towny right now! I didn't even say anything negative about arguing with Galz, I just said it wasn't fun for me anymore. Not sure what the big deal is or what I'm suddenly being yelled at.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Overreacty McGhee.

^

[Roadrunner7671]

I'm on vacation so I only really had time to skim the thread. I'll be back later!

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Double vote: Andrew

[The_Wine_Merchant]

The point is that you seem to be trying delegitimize his points on you by making him look like a punk that is picking on you. Nobody wants to side with a bully. But the point is perfectly valid.

[AndrewisFTTW]

The point is that you seem to be trying delegitimize his points on you by making him look like a punk that is picking on you. Nobody wants to side with a bully. But the point is perfectly valid.

Absolutely NOT what I'm doing. I disagree with him sure, but I'm not painting him as a bully or a punk. Just saying I don't feel like arguing with him anymore.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

The point is that you seem to be trying delegitimize his points on you by making him look like a punk that is picking on you. Nobody wants to side with a bully. But the point is perfectly valid.

Absolutely NOT what I'm doing. I disagree with him sure, but I'm not painting him as a bully or a punk. Just saying I don't feel like arguing with him anymore.

Then I am misinterpreting.

[chairs]

vote: Robz for hating wagons.

[Galzria]

That's all well and good Galz, except that for the fact that I'm town. You don't know that of course but it does invalidate your argument, for future reference.

I should clarify. You wouldn't know I'm town if you are town as well. Didn't mean for my post to suggest that Galz is definitely town.

Didn't even think of that. But it is a good point

vote: Andrew

You think I would point that out if I was scum?

WIFOM. Get in front of it. Yeah.

Also, "I wouldn't do that as scum" is the most overused and ridiculous argument ever - used pretty equally by town and scum alike.

Nice job trying to make it seem like my question is not worth answering. You'll probably have the same response for every question I pose in my defense. Quickest way to a mislynch right here folks!

Not true at all. And I answered your question. But that's not a defense. A defense has value and merit. "I wouldn't do that as scum" does not. There 's no content there. Yes, you would do that as scum. Or as town. Next?

And actually, not only did I answer it, I gave 2 reasons for WHY you would do it as scum:

1) WIFOM
2) To get out in front of it.

Not sure how I could generate WIFOM from that but whatever. Not interested in arguing with you anymore. It's not fun for me.

I don't really want to argue with you either, but...

You think I would point that out if I was scum?

Is the definition of a WIFOM argument.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Ok I'm getting ahead of myself. Clearly it was RVS. And if nobody else sees anything in it, that's fine. I'll drop it.

On vacation this week so will just be periodically catching up. Doing that now.

Scummy and towny.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Skumpy, Andrew, chairs are all townie, in descending order. That's a decent start for the game. And Teproc is an IC. We're starting to get some good PoE going here.

Awful.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

People should be able to get an alignment tell on skump from this I think. Get to work on that people.

I think skump is town. If he's scum, he would have run this "ask all the questions" plan by his scumbuddies, who very well may have thrown cold water on it.

Which player is IRL related to Galz? Also, why is there a wagon on Galz? I don't understand it.

Agree with the first part.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Hi! Good vote. Well the reasoning could be better, but anyway I like where it ended up.

Can you tell us anything about yourself, maybe most importantly what we should call you? Xx? Raptor? Slayer? xrs? Pick wisely.

More voted the way I did because his accusation seemed shady

I'll go by Xx, I like the sound of it.
Little about myself, this is my first time playing a forum game, so forgive me if I make any mistakes.
things I like:
-long walks in the beach
-watching the sunset
-sarcasm
things I don't like:
-irony
-lists
Any other questions feel free to ask.
[/quote]
What's wrong with lists?? Their awesome.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

I also think I should definitely get a D1 pass.

No.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Vote: Faust

[faust]

Where's RR at on votes? I don't mind joining a wagon on D1 strictly on activity basis.

Yeah me too. Lurking is a serious threat here. We have a lot of inactive players.