Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[gkrieg13]

I think this is how Faust is when he is voted for as scum. His post about RR is true, and I'm still surprised the earlier push of RR didn't go through, but I almost want to lynch Faust more today.  That being said, he is doing more for us than RR ever will.

[Roadrunner7671]

Is this a bastard game disguised as a normal game?

RR, what was this about?

The mod was playing!

srs bsns only from me sry

[2.71828.....]

rereading now.  I will post as I see things that stick out to me

[Roadrunner7671]

The worst part about being suspected so mucj D1 is that the town will never trust you and at LyLo this stuff'll come back to haunt me.

[Roadrunner7671]

If all my townish reads vote for me (Teproc, TWM, Jake and iguana) I will vote for myself, because I believe at that point the majority of the town will want me lynched, and I won't go against the town.

[2.71828.....]

Vote: Robz

In a game with this many scum, the best uninformed vote is against someone whose scum game is significantly better than their town game.

Robz has a 5/12 chance of being scum. Those are pretty good odds and I would pretty much always choose to lynch him with those odds.

Also, Hi Robz. This is our first game together.  I'm town and right now my goal is to get ya.

I can't really argue with this, actually.

https://i.imgur.com/jvsIqgz.gif

I don't think scum!robz makes this joke

[2.71828.....]

Iguana had a very townie reaction to the wagon on him

also, I should unvote while I am doing this

[Robz888]

Is faust L-1? We need more vote counts.

[2.71828.....]

Yeah, starting to really like iguana for town

[2.71828.....]

J Reggie had a wagon created on him?  I can see why

[2.71828.....]

Ash had the fifth vote on the RR wagon t 205, and I really don't like his reasoning.  Growing suspicious of ashersky.

[2.71828.....]

The WIFOM is strong with faust.

[2.71828.....]

"I want the hammer" reads to me as "I want the potential town cred for hammering scum".

It's a big difference to the usual games where scum knows they are participating in a mislynch when they vote.

Actually quoting rather than linking because I really like this

[iguanaiguana]

Is faust L-1? We need more vote counts.

Should be L-3. He was L-2 and I switched to RR.

check mark emoji

[2.71828.....]

Faust has this series of 6 posts that are coming across as half joking, half serious, and half townie.  Which makes me 150% more confident than I was before that he is scum.  But if I start everyone at 50/50 then he is is still only at 75% scum.  Either way, growing more suspicious.

[iguanaiguana]

E is doing good analysis here. Hm

[2.71828.....]

So Robz.  (read through 322 so far).  He has popped in and out so far, and nothing to make me feel warm and fuzzy about him being town.  He was kind of sort of against JR votes based on meta, sheeped an opinion of mine without really investing himself anywhere (like as in, he didn't do votes (quick scan - his first vote is at 483 - haven't gotten there yet)), then continued with some friendly eevee sheeping.  Keeping an eye out for him.

summary through 322: Robz, Ash, faust, and JR all are coming off a little suspicious to me.  Jake and RR are just kind of there with some weird posts that seem like they could be scummy but could also just be posts that make them mislynches. Iguana, eevee, and teproc are townie.  Who am I forgetting?  TWM, Joseph, and gkrieg.  No real opinions yet.  TWM is trying hard this game to not come off scummy like he has in the past.  I don't think that is actually scummy, I think that is just him working hard to be more useful town.  gkrieg and Joseph I don't know.

And of course, I am town

[Robz888]

So Robz.  (read through 322 so far).  He has popped in and out so far, and nothing to make me feel warm and fuzzy about him being town.  He was kind of sort of against JR votes based on meta, sheeped an opinion of mine without really investing himself anywhere (like as in, he didn't do votes (quick scan - his first vote is at 483 - haven't gotten there yet)), then continued with some friendly eevee sheeping.  Keeping an eye out for him.

summary through 322: Robz, Ash, faust, and JR all are coming off a little suspicious to me.  Jake and RR are just kind of there with some weird posts that seem like they could be scummy but could also just be posts that make them mislynches. Iguana, eevee, and teproc are townie.  Who am I forgetting?  TWM, Joseph, and gkrieg.  No real opinions yet.  TWM is trying hard this game to not come off scummy like he has in the past.  I don't think that is actually scummy, I think that is just him working hard to be more useful town.  gkrieg and Joseph I don't know.

And of course, I am town

This is a fair appraisal of my play.

[2.71828.....]

I like the TWM analysis of Jake.  The observations that Jake talks about Jake and how that is scummy is something that I find intriguing, and I am inclined to like that analysis.  Slightly scummier on Jake, townier on TWM.

(reads have slowed down - we started watching a movie)

[Teproc]

Don't have time right now, but will be around before deadline.

[ashersky]

I read the posts up until this post.  That's all.

I still like the faust lynch.  Any squirming at all is scummy from faust.  Town!faust never squirms.  This game he's squirmed a little.

I think gkrieg has said the same thing in different words.

[2.71828.....]

ok, finally finished reading through.

Want to lynch:
JR

Would lynch:
Ashersky, Robz, faust

Don't want to lynch:
gkrieg, Joseph, Iguana, Jake, RR, TWM, Teproc, Eevee

Vote: J Reggie

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

What's up with the JR lynch getting no traction whatsoever? I don't mean no people joining, I mean no people even commenting on it. Feels like he has the lowest number of mentions by others, despite being middling in the post count. Seems odd.

Whats your case on him?

[2.71828.....]

We have four things from J Reggie.  First, the plan:

Tell us your plan!

Why thank you.

I think we should start off D1 with a mass claim. We have a good chance to catch at least one scum here without losing any key PRs. Here's the catch though: it only works if everyone does it. And I mean everyone.

I'll start. I'm a VT.

Then the Joseph vote

vote: j Reggie for role fishing, trying to out all our PRs.

The setup says we don't have any PRs? 8VT vs 3 mafia vs 2 werewolves

This isn't likely to be warning a partner, since mafia have day chat and werewolves only have one partner. But

I claim TV.

Obv!fakeclaim. Vote: ii

This is unannounced L-2.
vote: Joseph

Then the faust vote

Oh the sheepage. But it's actually a reasonable wagon this time. vote: Faust

and the gkrieg case

Also I just realized that everyone should be scum hunting in this game, which is kinda interesting.

This is the type of post scum makes to make you think they have a town mindset. Like a pseudo-faked-townslip.

He then votes for gkrieg in his next post.  And that's really it.  Nothing here feels like town!Reggie to me.  It feels like J Reggie, when he is active, is doing everything he can to appear townie without actually being townie. 

[schadd]

well