Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

why did anyone think it was ash/igu other than me

I did

[faust]

Being a Hider when you can't target like 50% of players without dying is kinda mean. Just saying

[ashersky]

Being a Hider when you can't target like 50% of players without dying is kinda mean. Just saying

Did you softclaim Hider anywhere?  Literally no one considered that possibility.

[LaLight]

Being a Hider when you can't target like 50% of players without dying is kinda mean. Just saying

It was not compulsive

[LaLight]

Being a Hider when you can't target like 50% of players without dying is kinda mean. Just saying

It was not compulsive

And you had the IC!

[SpaceAnemone]

my fav part was when SA decided to babysit ash on the last night, then igu decided to doctor ash then SA changed their mind, Would've been unexpected for Dylan

I really agonised over that! If there'd been only one mafia-person left, I think following Ash rather than babysitting him would have been more townie, because while killing ash with a babysit would have been a glorious way to go out, I figured there was no need to play risky like that (and every chance he wouldn't kill me since I'd announced (a bit subtly, but still!) that I had the babysitter shot, and was clearly scumreading him by the end of that day.

The fact that Igu protected ash makes me feel better about not using the babysit shot after all, but I really don't understand how everyone else thought ash was so townie -- he was sooooo obviously being scummy in his flawed arguments and overconfident language :-(

If the babysitter shot had been left where it was, and if igu hadn't interfered, I'd hope Dylan would have been caught, because by that point it would be clear that his Star Glasses info was incorrect.

I think the thing that had me confused at the end of D3 was that I didn't think three scum plus one SK in a game that size felt likely at all, and that hunch seemed to be backed up by enough vets that they couldn't all be scum :-(

[gkrieg13]

To be fair, we only had one mislynch before LYLO. So we didn't do too badly as town.

[faust]

Being a Hider when you can't target like 50% of players without dying is kinda mean. Just saying

Did you softclaim Hider anywhere?  Literally no one considered that possibility.

No; I wanted to be targeted by scum.

It sucks that there are no role flips. That is a major boost for scum.

[silverspawn]

To be fair, we only had one mislynch before LYLO. So we didn't do too badly as town.

such a huge factor in these games is who dies at night.