Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[pingpongsam]

Okay, I read the setup.

7 possible arrangements in which only 2 can even contain a rolecop and then rolecop returns a vanilla on scum. So why was trying to get a rolecop to claim a good idea?

I tried to think of that from the idea that I am scum and I want town to out the rolecop and it still didn't add up to a good idea. I mean if the rolecop can't actually cop me then why do I care much about him as scum?

Okay, so getting a rolecop claim is better for town than scum I suppose. The 2 shot Doctor can prevent a NK on the rolecop so claiming is safe and the watcher can spot scum NKing the rolecop. So the claim itself is relatively safe and then if there is a rolecop then the possible arrangements are reduced to only 2 which is more information than town currently has but scum already knew.

Did I do good, do I get a cookie?

[AndrewisFTTW]

Okay, I read the setup.

7 possible arrangements in which only 2 can even contain a rolecop and then rolecop returns a vanilla on scum. So why was trying to get a rolecop to claim a good idea?

I tried to think of that from the idea that I am scum and I want town to out the rolecop and it still didn't add up to a good idea. I mean if the rolecop can't actually cop me then why do I care much about him as scum?

Okay, so getting a rolecop claim is better for town than scum I suppose. The 2 shot Doctor can prevent a NK on the rolecop so claiming is safe and the watcher can spot scum NKing the rolecop. So the claim itself is relatively safe and then if there is a rolecop then the possible arrangements are reduced to only 2 which is more information than town currently has but scum already knew.

Did I do good, do I get a cookie?

You're about 6 pages late. Here's a 6 page old cookie.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Okay, I read the setup.

7 possible arrangements in which only 2 can even contain a rolecop and then rolecop returns a vanilla on scum. So why was trying to get a rolecop to claim a good idea?

I tried to think of that from the idea that I am scum and I want town to out the rolecop and it still didn't add up to a good idea. I mean if the rolecop can't actually cop me then why do I care much about him as scum?

Can you count?? There's 3. #2, #3, #5

[pingpongsam]

Okay, I read the setup.

7 possible arrangements in which only 2 can even contain a rolecop and then rolecop returns a vanilla on scum. So why was trying to get a rolecop to claim a good idea?

I tried to think of that from the idea that I am scum and I want town to out the rolecop and it still didn't add up to a good idea. I mean if the rolecop can't actually cop me then why do I care much about him as scum?

Okay, so getting a rolecop claim is better for town than scum I suppose. The 2 shot Doctor can prevent a NK on the rolecop so claiming is safe and the watcher can spot scum NKing the rolecop. So the claim itself is relatively safe and then if there is a rolecop then the possible arrangements are reduced to only 2 which is more information than town currently has but scum already knew.

Did I do good, do I get a cookie?

You're about 6 pages late. Here's a 6 page old cookie.

So, since no rolecop claimed when apparently it was being made crystal clear to everyone but me that doing so was a great plan can we assume there isn't one and reduce the possible arrangements to five?

Also, are we supposed to award town points to the idea and backers? I recall it being gkrieg and Robz. Please tell me so I can mafia good.

[pingpongsam]

Okay, I read the setup.

7 possible arrangements in which only 2 can even contain a rolecop and then rolecop returns a vanilla on scum. So why was trying to get a rolecop to claim a good idea?

I tried to think of that from the idea that I am scum and I want town to out the rolecop and it still didn't add up to a good idea. I mean if the rolecop can't actually cop me then why do I care much about him as scum?

Can you count?? There's 3. #2, #3, #5

Now, are you starting to understand why me reading setups is a useless waste of everyone's time?

[AndrewisFTTW]

Okay, I read the setup.

7 possible arrangements in which only 2 can even contain a rolecop and then rolecop returns a vanilla on scum. So why was trying to get a rolecop to claim a good idea?

I tried to think of that from the idea that I am scum and I want town to out the rolecop and it still didn't add up to a good idea. I mean if the rolecop can't actually cop me then why do I care much about him as scum?

Can you count?? There's 3. #2, #3, #5

Now, are you starting to understand why me reading setups is a useless waste of everyone's time?

Actually you're both wrong, there are four setups with a rolecop. But again, we already beat the dead horse. Now the poor horse is being.... well, nevermind.

[AndrewisFTTW]

In all seriousness, I think you voting yourself is a pretty null PPS-ish thing to do, so I'm not going to get my logic in a twist over it.

Maybe, because you are relatively new. Or maybe you're scum trying to nix my town vibe because the truth is that scum!PPS would never claim to be scum on D1.

I don't see town narrative for intentionally attenuating anther's attempts at generating a town signal. It's really all town can do at this stage of the game.

This would have been a much townier thing if your sig wasn't what it is. 

I think given his involvement with creating the setup, gkrieg would have probably started with the rc talk early as either alignment, especially since someone else in the game already knew some of his thoughts and would recognize it if he were to try to hide some info/insight he had. However, the way he has done it suggests town to me.

Vote: Joseph

PPE 1

Why?

Why are you not letting him react to it himself before you try to get a reason out of me?

Is this your master scumhunting plan? Vote people with no substance and arbitrarily decide whether or not it's scummy?

[SpaceAnemone]

Okay, I read the setup.

7 possible arrangements in which only 2 can even contain a rolecop and then rolecop returns a vanilla on scum. So why was trying to get a rolecop to claim a good idea?

I tried to think of that from the idea that I am scum and I want town to out the rolecop and it still didn't add up to a good idea. I mean if the rolecop can't actually cop me then why do I care much about him as scum?

Can you count?? There's 3. #2, #3, #5

Now, are you starting to understand why me reading setups is a useless waste of everyone's time?

Well, the fact that you slipped on maths rather than on something scum-indicative is at least encouraging! I would argue that under certain conditions, forcing you to participate in setup discussion is very high utility for town...

[pingpongsam]

You have a point. But refusing to do so benefits my scum game which is really the only game that matters.

[Robz888]

Vote: PPS

[Dylan32]

In all seriousness, I think you voting yourself is a pretty null PPS-ish thing to do, so I'm not going to get my logic in a twist over it.

Maybe, because you are relatively new. Or maybe you're scum trying to nix my town vibe because the truth is that scum!PPS would never claim to be scum on D1.

I don't see town narrative for intentionally attenuating anther's attempts at generating a town signal. It's really all town can do at this stage of the game.

This would have been a much townier thing if your sig wasn't what it is. 

I think given his involvement with creating the setup, gkrieg would have probably started with the rc talk early as either alignment, especially since someone else in the game already knew some of his thoughts and would recognize it if he were to try to hide some info/insight he had. However, the way he has done it suggests town to me.

Vote: Joseph

PPE 1

Why?

Why are you not letting him react to it himself before you try to get a reason out of me?

Is this your master scumhunting plan? Vote people with no substance and arbitrarily decide whether or not it's scummy?

Nope. It was to vote with little (or none in this case) disclosed substance to gauge reactions that can be recalled later when there is more evidence to combine it with, whichever way the evidence points.

And Joseph, I would have liked a bit more than just copying Jake there. Want to try again for me, please?

Jake, this is why you don't answer for other people immediately, because then you give them an easy way out of pressure, which makes sense if you are trying to diffuse potential pressure on a partner or you have a night result which ICs them, which you don't.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Vote: PPS

You know that's L-1 right?

[pingpongsam]

Vote: PPS

You know that's L-1 right?

Too bad I can't hammer that guy, I mean, he claimed scum for crying out loud.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Vote: PPS

You know that's L-1 right?

Too bad I can't hammer that guy, I mean, he claimed scum for crying out loud.

Too bad I don't really want to hammer.

[LaLight]

I actually would hammer but not so early in the day

[AndrewisFTTW]

Vote: PPS

You know that's L-1 right?

Too bad I can't hammer that guy, I mean, he claimed scum for crying out loud.

Too bad I don't really want to hammer.

What's wrong with hammering?

[pingpongsam]

Vote: PPS

You know that's L-1 right?

Too bad I can't hammer that guy, I mean, he claimed scum for crying out loud.

Too bad I don't really want to hammer.

What's wrong with hammering?

Pretty simple, if you're town you want a longer D1 and something more informative than a self-vote RVS to hang your hat. If you're scum you recognize the prior sentence and are hesitant to draw the suspicion on yourself for forcing the issue because you know you're going to get a town flip.

But carry on discussing the setup and acting as if this line of play is completely irrelevant.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Vote: PPS

You know that's L-1 right?

Too bad I can't hammer that guy, I mean, he claimed scum for crying out loud.

Too bad I don't really want to hammer.

What's wrong with hammering?

Pretty simple, if you're town you want a longer D1 and something more informative than a self-vote RVS to hang your hat. If you're scum you recognize the prior sentence and are hesitant to draw the suspicion on yourself for forcing the issue because you know you're going to get a town flip.

But carry on discussing the setup and acting as if this line of play is completely irrelevant.

I wasn't advocated hammering right this moment, I was asking Jake specifically why he didn't like hammering. I guess he meant he didn't want to hammer right now. Way to take everything literally Andrew.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Vote: PPS

You know that's L-1 right?

Too bad I can't hammer that guy, I mean, he claimed scum for crying out loud.

Too bad I don't really want to hammer.

What's wrong with hammering?

Pretty simple, if you're town you want a longer D1 and something more informative than a self-vote RVS to hang your hat. If you're scum you recognize the prior sentence and are hesitant to draw the suspicion on yourself for forcing the issue because you know you're going to get a town flip.

But carry on discussing the setup and acting as if this line of play is completely irrelevant.

I will hammer at 12:00 forum time. If anyone has any objections please state before then.

I'd usually prefer for more discussion but i dislike D1 so I will hammer.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Jake can you auto /in to every game I join please?

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Jake can you auto /in to every game I join please?

Maybe?!?!?!? Also I say there's a 45% that pps is a hidden jester

[SpaceAnemone]

I will hammer at 12:00 forum time. If anyone has any objections please state before then.

I'd usually prefer for more discussion but i dislike D1 so I will hammer.

I'd like to hear what answer Robz gives to the question you asked about whether he was aware it was L-1 already, so I'd prefer you didn't hammer before he responds. No need to let him off the hook too easily.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

I will hammer at 12:00 forum time. If anyone has any objections please state before then.

I'd usually prefer for more discussion but i dislike D1 so I will hammer.

I'd like to hear what answer Robz gives to the question you asked about whether he was aware it was L-1 already, so I'd prefer you didn't hammer before he responds. No need to let him off the hook too easily.

K

[Joseph2302]

Wouldn't mind a hammer, but it's probably a tad early for it

[pingpongsam]

Unvote