Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Robz888]

I also am thinking more about voting EFHW

Why? EFHW feels like one of the townier people around, in my opinion.

[Dylan32]

Why did Dylan not come to fruition yesterday?

Because I'm town. Also, because too many people left before the deadline to be able to move to anyone else after RR claimed.

Yeah so much for leaning town on Robz after the flip. Right now Robz is scummy, and (admittedly a bit of OMGUS) gkrieg feels slightly scummy to, in part because of the whole "that was the hammer right?" and then going offline through the end of the deadline at L-1. I know it is a mistake town could honestly make, but it is also perfect excuse to leave your vote on a wagon you know is town for scum.

Thinking I'm scummy, okay fine, everyone always thinks that, not surprising. Really weird for you to say you find gkrieg scummy after his possible townslip.

I'm going to vote LaLight, though, for reasons I previously stated.

Let's not let this game stall, guys.

Vote: LaLight

What possible townslip was there? I don't remember seeing one.

[2.71828.....]

Sorry, today was a busy day. Should have some more time tomorrow

[LaLight]

Yeah so much for leaning town on Robz after the flip. Right now Robz is scummy, and (admittedly a bit of OMGUS) gkrieg feels slightly scummy to, in part because of the whole "that was the hammer right?" and then going offline through the end of the deadline at L-1. I know it is a mistake town could honestly make, but it is also perfect excuse to leave your vote on a wagon you know is town for scum.

Thinking I'm scummy, okay fine, everyone always thinks that, not surprising. Really weird for you to say you find gkrieg scummy after his possible townslip.

I'm going to vote LaLight, though, for reasons I previously stated.

Let's not let this game stall, guys.

Vote: LaLight

What are thise reasons?

[LaLight]

Why did Dylan not come to fruition yesterday?

Because I'm town. Also, because too many people left before the deadline to be able to move to anyone else after RR claimed.

Yeah so much for leaning town on Robz after the flip. Right now Robz is scummy, and (admittedly a bit of OMGUS) gkrieg feels slightly scummy to, in part because of the whole "that was the hammer right?" and then going offline through the end of the deadline at L-1. I know it is a mistake town could honestly make, but it is also perfect excuse to leave your vote on a wagon you know is town for scum.

Thinking I'm scummy, okay fine, everyone always thinks that, not surprising. Really weird for you to say you find gkrieg scummy after his possible townslip.

I'm going to vote LaLight, though, for reasons I previously stated.

Let's not let this game stall, guys.

Vote: LaLight

What possible townslip was there? I don't remember seeing one.

Townslip was that gkrieg haven't seen RR caliming Jailkeeper and was genuinely surprised RR was killed which is impossible if he's scum.

The only question is if it was genuine actually.

[Robz888]

What possible townslip was there? I don't remember seeing one.

It just happened: gkrieg was confused about the kill because he didn't realize RR claimed JK.

[Robz888]

Yeah so much for leaning town on Robz after the flip. Right now Robz is scummy, and (admittedly a bit of OMGUS) gkrieg feels slightly scummy to, in part because of the whole "that was the hammer right?" and then going offline through the end of the deadline at L-1. I know it is a mistake town could honestly make, but it is also perfect excuse to leave your vote on a wagon you know is town for scum.

Thinking I'm scummy, okay fine, everyone always thinks that, not surprising. Really weird for you to say you find gkrieg scummy after his possible townslip.

I'm going to vote LaLight, though, for reasons I previously stated.

Let's not let this game stall, guys.

Vote: LaLight

What are thise reasons?

Yeah it is likely there's at least some scum on the wagon. I think LL's "all three" claim is dubious. In fact, that feels like something scum LL would say to divert our attention.

[LaLight]

Yeah so much for leaning town on Robz after the flip. Right now Robz is scummy, and (admittedly a bit of OMGUS) gkrieg feels slightly scummy to, in part because of the whole "that was the hammer right?" and then going offline through the end of the deadline at L-1. I know it is a mistake town could honestly make, but it is also perfect excuse to leave your vote on a wagon you know is town for scum.

Thinking I'm scummy, okay fine, everyone always thinks that, not surprising. Really weird for you to say you find gkrieg scummy after his possible townslip.

I'm going to vote LaLight, though, for reasons I previously stated.

Let's not let this game stall, guys.

Vote: LaLight

What are thise reasons?

Yeah it is likely there's at least some scum on the wagon. I think LL's "all three" claim is dubious. In fact, that feels like something scum LL would say to divert our attention.

ugh, well, no. It's my opinion that possibly having town wagon there might be all three scums.

[EFHW]

Eevee was a town wagon too.  Looking at the two wagons combined, I don't think we narrow down the odds of someone being scum based on who was on wagon.  We could maybe learn something looking at the people who didn't come back to check on the RR lynch, since maybe the reason they didn't come back was that they were fine with any lynchee that wasn't them.

[EFHW]

Let's not let this game stall, guys.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Sorry, my life is crazy right now.  Just posting to say I'll catch up and post later tonight, and also that tomorrow looks like I'll actually have time for the internet during the day when I usually do.

Sorry for contributing to stall.

[gkrieg13]

I'll put together a formal Dylan case

[Jimmmmm]

Checking in; still away.

[LaLight]

Vote: UoS

Why are you voting for UoS?

[Calamitas]

Going to reread today, this game is really stalling.

[Witherweaver]

I should have time for this now; the other game was a little demanding.

[Witherweaver]

Why did Dylan not come to fruition yesterday?

Because I'm town. Also, because too many people left before the deadline to be able to move to anyone else after RR claimed.

Wouldn't your alleged townhood make the wagon more likely to result in a lynch?

[Witherweaver]

Eevee was a town wagon too.  Looking at the two wagons combined, I don't think we narrow down the odds of someone being scum based on who was on wagon.  We could maybe learn something looking at the people who didn't come back to check on the RR lynch, since maybe the reason they didn't come back was that they were fine with any lynchee that wasn't them.

Well scum would surely have gotten on one of the wagons, right?

[Robz888]

To recap, I am waiting for gkrieg to explain his scum read on EFHW and for E to explain his vote for UoS.

I am voting LaLight for advancing the case that we had all three scum on wagon, which I doubt.

[Robz888]

Oh, we're also waiting on gkrieg's Dylan case.

[Witherweaver]

Well, I suppose RR + Eevee wagon combined is basically everyone:

Dylan32 (3): Witherweaver, LaLight, gkrieg13
Eevee (5): EFHW, Calamitas, Roadrunner7671, Dylan32, Robz888
Roadrunner7671 (4): Eevee, Jimmmmm, UmbrageOfSnow, 2.71828...

I don't believe scum is going to be pressing a PR mislynch more than an alternate mislynch, because they know it looks worse.  The people to back off RR immediately are probably among the most suspicious.

[Witherweaver]

Though I'm not sure LaLight is scummy for going down his line of thought.

[schadd]

Vote Count 2.2

Dylan32 (2): gkrieg13, LaLight
UmbrageOfSnow (1): 2.71828...
Jimmmmm (1): EFHW
LaLight (1): Robz888

Not voting (5): UmbrageOfSnow, Dylan32, Jimmmmm, Witherweaver, Calamitas

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day 2 ends Sunday, March 5th at 11pm forum time.

[Witherweaver]

Robz first to unvote:

Isnt lynching the JK extra bad because the mafia get a JK if we do that, or something?

Yep, setup says yes. Okay, this is worst case scenario. Unvote

Dylan next:

Part of me agrees. But say we don't lynch. Scum kills someone else for WIFOM and we lynch RR. Then they get another NK. That's 3 town dead before we actually vote for someone who has a chance to be scum... Just saying... unvote

And that was it, as deadline happened shortly after.  Dylan's immediate response:

So, are we going to follow through and lynch a claimed Jailkeeper, or at least I think that was what he was trying to do?

And there is also some surrounding discussion between Robz and Dylan. 

Given the lack of people on at this time and that this was all ~10 min before deadline, not sure there's a whole lot there.  Dylan still seems scummy to me.  Robz is maybez.

[Robz888]

Why is it scummy to unvote RR after he claims? I absolutely do not follow.