Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[SpaceAnemone]

Okay, fine. Awaclus said that he didn't have a QT because he was town.

Imo, that's one of those throwaway "look, I'm being townie" statements that are trivial for scum to manufacture. I registered it, but I definitely wouldn't IC him over it.

I was under the impression you were a town player who tends to ask for QTs even when they're not automatically offered... so don't you have a QT either way?

[SpaceAnemone]

I have no idea what your deal with that Jake post is though. Has anybody here played with Jake before?

Jake and RR are IRL friends, and used to get into awful thread-saturating arguments with each other in-thread. They've been improving lately, which is to be encouraged!

Jake also has a tendency towards omgus and slightly tenuous arguments, but I think his ability to put a case together has gotten better with experience.

[SpaceAnemone]

Oops... 1am for me, so I'm off to bed. I have early meetings, but will catch up again around 9am forum time.

[Roadrunner7671]

I was under the impression you were a town player who tends to ask for QTs even when they're not automatically offered... so don't you have a QT either way?

I used to do that, but not so much anymore. I don't need a private chat if I have nothing to hide 

[Roadrunner7671]

This is not a bad argument, but Ashersky would have mentioned it somewhere if he had given townies QTs so that scum would know about it. Or Awaclus could have asked in private. Etc.

I assume that townies will get QTs, especially with Ashersky who has been around forever. In Squid Girl Mafia, for example, I was a VT and I didn't have a QT. I think this is because UoS wasn't around during the time when QTs for everyone became super popular.

Awaclus could've asked about it though, that's something I didn't consider. I'm not sure Ashersky would give him a straight answer though.

[gkrieg13]

Ash doesn't like QTs. He usually does stuff with PMs

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Yeah

First, Jake expresses agreement.

sorry

Then, he apologizes. That's called appealing to emotion.

I think

In the game where TWM, mcmc and I were scum, mcmc gave TWM some newbie scum advice: Always say 'I' and never say 'you,' because you'll sound less accusatory.

may

Not committing himself so he can still seem innocent/on the fence.

RR may be scum here.

Scum is going to agree with literally any wagon on any towny because we're at MyLo. If a newbie player is on/supporting of a wagon, it should be regarded with more suspicion than usual. And I'm not calling Jake a newbie to Mafia, I'm calling a newbie to an Ashersky setup.

I also

He says I again!

also

Expresses agreement again.

a numbers perspective he's been scum a lot recently (M94 etc) and I doubt that he can be scum so many games in a row.

This argument is invalid and I strongly suspect Jake knows that.

I doubt

He says I yet again.

(M94 etc)

Even with his invalid argument, he only gives one example of LaLight being scum 'so many games in a row.'


Conclusion: Jake is scum.

ppe LOTS

Ok hold up did RR just make a scum arugement against me because I use the word I a lot. This is ridiculous

[pacovf]

Ok let's get things moving again.

vote: WW

[Roadrunner7671]

Yeah this is spooky. I'm assuming everyone is making a 'good night' post when they go to sleep, but maybe that's not the case.

[Roadrunner7671]

Well I guess now's a good time to hit the hay.

[Witherweaver]

Yeah sorry but I think that RR may be scum here. I also dislike the idea of lynching LL because just by a numbers perspective he's been scum a lot recently (M94 etc) and I doubt that he can be scum so many games in a row.

This is bad and you should feel bad.

[Witherweaver]

Ok let's get things moving again.

vote: WW

Shtawp

[Witherweaver]

This is not a bad argument, but Ashersky would have mentioned it somewhere if he had given townies QTs so that scum would know about it. Or Awaclus could have asked in private. Etc.

I assume that townies will get QTs, especially with Ashersky who has been around forever. In Squid Girl Mafia, for example, I was a VT and I didn't have a QT. I think this is because UoS wasn't around during the time when QTs for everyone became super popular.

Awaclus could've asked about it though, that's something I didn't consider. I'm not sure Ashersky would give him a straight answer though.

What? You assume townies will get QTs?  Why would you be making an assumption here, if you are town?

[Witherweaver]

How could anyone possibly think I'm scum here?  It's like you guys have never played Mafia with me

[gkrieg13]

Also I'm now on Pacific time so I wake up even later

[pacovf]

How could anyone possibly think I'm scum here?  It's like you guys have never played Mafia with me

Precisely! You were scum in the last game we played together. And I was convinced you were town until you quickhammered for the win.

[LaLight]

Good morning!

[LaLight]

How could anyone possibly think I'm scum here?  It's like you guys have never played Mafia with me

Precisely! You were scum in the last game we played together. And I was convinced you were town until you quickhammered for the win.

Yeah, WW you look pretty darn townie as scum, look at RMM40. I was terrified back then

[LaLight]

but okay, for now I believe you. You play more carefully townie as scum.

Actually, if there is no quickhammer still, I would vote: Space. They look scummy from the first post.

[gkrieg13]

but okay, for now I believe you. You play more carefully townie as scum.

Actually, if there is no quickhammer still, I would vote: Space. They look scummy from the first post.

vote: LaLight

[LaLight]

but okay, for now I believe you. You play more carefully townie as scum.

Actually, if there is no quickhammer still, I would vote: Space. They look scummy from the first post.

vote: LaLight

Why?

[LaLight]

I actually think SA is the scummier one out of two. Also, now there can be a quickhammer, though in WW/SA situation there wasn't. Shouldn't that mean one of them is scum? Why vote for me at all?

[ashersky]

Vote Count 1.3:

LaLight (2): Awaclus, gkrieg13
SA (2): WW, LaLight
WW (1): Pacovf

Not Voting (3): Jake, RR, SA

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Day One ends on March 15 at 12:10 p.m.

[LaLight]

Oh, I thought I have 3 votes on me already.

[SpaceAnemone]

Morning all.

vote: WW
The no-hammer argument grew on me with time.