Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[J Reggie]

But why would watching scum ever give a good result?

That often target each other in RMM. Ash would be a prime target of another scum had a protective ability or something.

[ashersky]

You had to claim something to support the claim you used to escape your lynch on D1.  It not being real, you didn't think it through very well.  Also, dead player as only confirmation is the convenient choice.

[Eevee]

Reggie very much looks like scum to me.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Well ash is either lying or redirected, but at this point lying naked the most sense. I definitely watched him last night and received a result. I wish Faust were around to confirm it but whatever. I was going to try and watch a possible nk target, but I honestly had no idea who it could be, so I decided I'd try to watch scum instead. And I don't get why you guys are believing ash. Why would I target no one? That just doesn't make sense when I have two targeting abilities to choose from.

Vote: JR This is really fishy.

[J Reggie]

Man, this feels just like Heroes mafia.

[iguanaiguana]

Vote: J Reggie

[Eevee]

I think that's L-1.

[J Reggie]

Well you know who to lynch next.

[J Reggie]

I think that's L-1.

Do you want your item gone?

[J Reggie]

Not much reason not to vote: J Reggie now. You guys go and win this for me. You know what to do.

[Roadrunner7671]

gg ez

[gkrieg13]

Well now we just have to see who opposed the Reggie wagon.

[gkrieg13]

Sorry everybody, very busy weekend.  Ash, please don't go yuma on us!  You are very fun to play with and a great mod.  I'm only voting for you because I think you're most likely to be scum.  Although I could see myself switching to Eevee; I think he could pull this kind of stunt as scum.  I was hoping for a scummier response from Dylan after my bait post. 

But what about space?  I haven't seen much of them this game.

This is a fishy post.  This basically ICs ash.

[Roadrunner7671]

Sorry everybody, very busy weekend.  Ash, please don't go yuma on us!  You are very fun to play with and a great mod.  I'm only voting for you because I think you're most likely to be scum.  Although I could see myself switching to Eevee; I think he could pull this kind of stunt as scum.  I was hoping for a scummier response from Dylan after my bait post. 

But what about space?  I haven't seen much of them this game.

This is a fishy post.  This basically ICs ash.

How is that fishy? That's a good thing!

[gkrieg13]

J Reggie is a vote I can believe in.

Vote: J Reggie

Vote: J Reggie

townie votes on the Reggie wagon I think

[gkrieg13]

1. SpaceAnemone-Pretty null here, I don't really remember too much about SA
3. Dylan32-I still don't like that vote he put on ashersky, and I don't really like the reaction to his wagon. That being said, his wagon picked up fairly quickly, so that's in his favor slightly I guess.
4. IDon'tPlayThisGame-Don't really remember much from them either.
5. J Reggie-Seems scummy, which means J Reggie hasn't bee hacked by someone else and replaced. don't really want to vote here though.
6. Jake-I don't know. A little hedgy, but that's not really alignment inductive. Don't want to vote here.
8. faust-Taking a leadership role, I actually think this is sort of scummy. Why would you be trying to lead instead of encouraging the IC to do so?
9. silverspawn-Null.
10. iguanaiguana-Pretty null as well. Not a fan of his rapid changing of votes, but it's D1 and it's iguanaiguana.
11. Awaclus-Pretty null.
12. ashersky-Very ashersky like. I'm not actually towny on him, but I definitely don't want to lynch him because he's not scummy, and a tracker is an asset. ashersky as a player is an asset too.
PPE 2

Scummy position from RR

[gkrieg13]

RR what do you think of Eevee?

Looking at J Reggie. 15 posts, should be quick. The first notable thing:

Is it possible that LL would include mimes?  Otherwise I think there's a pretty good case on RR already.

I asked how this post makes sense and never got an answer. Because it really does not make a lot of sense. Plus, third party awareness is generally a bit more of a scum thing.

I felt like RR was being intentionally scummy in a way that made the most sense if he was trying to get quicklynched. It's probably a crazy idea but whatever.

Sure, but how did you reach the conclusion that scum!RR would be intentionally scummy?

Honestly I'm not sure what my logic was here.

Yeah, I think Dylan is slightly scummy for totally ignoring the wagon.

This is more of sheeping popular opinions. I liked him better when he did not understand why Dylan is scummy.

As I explained before, this post was kind of bait. I was hoping Dylan would come back on, see people saying this, and freak out. But that didn't happen so I'm not sure what to think.

How would that have been a desirable outcome?

It would have been clear to vote for him.

I really don't like how ash is so confrontational, especially of the IC. There's no reason to do that.

What does oyu not liking it have to do with ash's alignment?

I don't like it because there's no reason to do it as town, so that means ash is probably scum.

8. faust-Taking a leadership role, I actually think this is sort of scummy. Why would you be trying to lead instead of encouraging the IC to do so?

Err, hey, gkrieg is welcome to lead. Well, whatever lead means. I don't thiink the IC sharing their reads is very desirable. That is mostly what I am doing.

I don't think this would be a better game if every other post of mine was "Hey gkrieg, how about doing some leading?" instead of its actual content.

Yeah, Faust is just naturally kind of leader. At least in mafia games, I don't know about in real life. Him doing the leading is definitely not scummy, if not exactly a town tell.

Ppe

This makes Dylan townier.  Also I just realized that because LaLight is the mod, he is probably asleep, which means I have a lot more time to do this reread.

[gkrieg13]

Okay, J Reggie now:

Says there could be a pretty good case on Roadrunner very early in the game. Yeah, you guessed it, I don't like that. I think that's why I originally voted for him. His later posts however seem to indicate that he may just think differently about RR's jokes than I do. I'm more null on him now.

Sorry everybody, very busy weekend.  Ash, please don't go yuma on us!  You are very fun to play with and a great mod.  I'm only voting for you because I think you're most likely to be scum.  Although I could see myself switching to Eevee; I think he could pull this kind of stunt as scum.  I was hoping for a scummier response from Dylan after my bait post. 

But what about space?  I haven't seen much of them this game.

Mentioning a 'bait post' is a little towny maybe from someone who hasn't spent much effort on the game yet. Does disinterested scum think to lie about making bait posts? Well, maybe they still try to bait someone into saying something scummy. Slightly more likely from town I guess. Also possible he just stole the idea from Faust who mentioned a bait post before he did. Sorry for the insult if that's not true. 

Nothing else of note to me. J Reggie is super-null. Am I voting him? That seems bad

Vote: SpaceAnemone

Let's go with that for now.

This is scummy from iguana.  Takes his vote off with a bad reason, and deflates the wagon.

[gkrieg13]

Oh boy, time to read Faust.

Man, I'm not quoting all those statements.

Here's what I think about Faust. I think his play looks like town play. I've thought that before about him as scum. Way too big of a risk to lynch him today. So he's not on the table. So very much like Eevee, he's not really in my lynch pool today, but that doesn't mean I trust him or think he's necessarily town. And I'll be keeping my eye on him.

I do like his trying to bait people into voting Ash. I think it sucks how it resulted in Ash claiming at L-2, super duper bummer there.

His thing about Eevee playing too scummy to be scum seems likely to be right to me too. Well, unless that's scum!Faust protecting his partner. Ha.

And yeah, I don't like his vote on J Reggie any more after finishing my own reread of J Reggie.

More scummy from iguana.

[gkrieg13]

One more post.

To summarize Moderate Scum Slight Scum Null Slight Town Strong Town

SpaceAnemone
Dylan32
silverspawn
J Reggie
Jake
Eevee
Faust
Awaclus
Ashersky
Roadrunner
Gkrieg
Iguana

and I really don't like how both of my moderate scums are basically D1 lynchbait.

More scummy from iguana, especially considering we went for silver, his other person on the same level as J Reggie, and that he keeps J Reggie in his scummy list, but votes for someone else.  I guess that isn't super scummy itself...

[gkrieg13]

I don't think ii would post this much as scum. Jake piping up as soon as there's a post about him is kind of scummy.

I'd be happy to lynch ash, but could switch to Jake or space if needed.

Uh, I think iguana is scum guys...  Like lynch him tomorrow for me please.

[gkrieg13]

Well I guess I'm not the worst D1 mislynch, but if prefer to lunch someone who has a chance of being scum. And I'm feeling better about space being scum after their recent posts. So vote: space

This is slightly townier on Space.  The fact that J Reggie votes here when J Reggie is about to be lynched is telling.

[gkrieg13]

Why are you so nonchalant about being lynched?

This sort of sounds like a partner, possibly. 

[gkrieg13]

2.5 hours left, too.

Unvote for now at least.

More interactions.

[gkrieg13]

I don't think scum would act this resigned.

Like I'm reasonably sure the team is J Reggie/iguana/eevee.