Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[schadd]

Faust, have YOU re-read? Your faith in schadd didn't waver?

yeah, he did, 755. did you, like, read the first time?

[Robz888]

Faust, have YOU re-read? Your faith in schadd didn't waver?

yeah, he did, 755. did you, like, read the first time?

Well I don't know if he re-read everything.

[SpaceAnemone]

I feel very towny about you based on the amount of effort you're putting in to keep things going, and on making the case. Can I suggest further homework? :-) What are your reads on Awaclus, Robz and Ichi? Do you feel like we have any clear partnerships in {Awaclus, Ichi, LL, Robz, RR}?

I think D2 is a bit too early for partner talk.

Hmm... I'd agree that second-order partner analysis makes for more work than first-order scum-hunts, but schadd has just demonstrated he's got enough time and concentration to put some quite comprehensive effort into this :-) With Eevee as an IC already, and with several others looking really townie, there are only actually 10 possible pairings between the people I suggested - fewer to consider if he's got a comfortable enough town read on any of them.

[SpaceAnemone]

Other explanations--the scum team is RR and Awaclus, basically--strike me as way too overly simple.

Given how much Awaclus seems to have it in for you, in what ways is that explanation too simple?

@Robz?

[schadd]

I feel very towny about you based on the amount of effort you're putting in to keep things going, and on making the case. Can I suggest further homework? :-) What are your reads on Awaclus, Robz and Ichi? Do you feel like we have any clear partnerships in {Awaclus, Ichi, LL, Robz, RR}?

I think D2 is a bit too early for partner talk.

Hmm... I'd agree that second-order partner analysis makes for more work than first-order scum-hunts, but schadd has just demonstrated he's got enough time and concentration to put some quite comprehensive effort into this :-) With Eevee as an IC already, and with several others looking really townie, there are only actually 10 possible pairings between the people I suggested - fewer to consider if he's got a comfortable enough town read on any of them.

there's another guy that i'd like to shoot some time and concentration at, if i have any of that left

[Robz888]

Other explanations--the scum team is RR and Awaclus, basically--strike me as way too overly simple.

Given how much Awaclus seems to have it in for you, in what ways is that explanation too simple?

@Robz?

It's a simple explanation because Awaclus and RR were like the only off-wagon people (I think?). I think it's too simple, though. Awaclus having it in for me doesn't really have anything to do with anything. I don't think finding me scummy is a scumtell, here or in general.

[faust]

Faust, have YOU re-read? Your faith in schadd didn't waver?

My townread on schadd is largely based upon my reread.

[faust]

I feel very towny about you based on the amount of effort you're putting in to keep things going, and on making the case. Can I suggest further homework? :-) What are your reads on Awaclus, Robz and Ichi? Do you feel like we have any clear partnerships in {Awaclus, Ichi, LL, Robz, RR}?

I think D2 is a bit too early for partner talk.

Hmm... I'd agree that second-order partner analysis makes for more work than first-order scum-hunts, but schadd has just demonstrated he's got enough time and concentration to put some quite comprehensive effort into this :-) With Eevee as an IC already, and with several others looking really townie, there are only actually 10 possible pairings between the people I suggested - fewer to consider if he's got a comfortable enough town read on any of them.

It's also dangerous because with this, people tend to forget that the "really townie" people are actually nowhere near cleared. This is basically how we won NM9.

[Eevee]

I'm behind, but I'll do some rereads for tomorrow. I feel it's good for us Robz is pushing for schnadd, I'll try to make my mind about that situation when I reread.

[schadd]

robz read is proving difficult. he's been town a time in recent memory, and unfortunately we killed him n2, after he had a weird d2 because he was a pr.


robz, what was your latest town game before your hiatus?

[Robz888]

robz read is proving difficult. he's been town a time in recent memory, and unfortunately we killed him n2, after he had a weird d2 because he was a pr.


robz, what was your latest town game before your hiatus?

If memory serves, I was town in the last game I played before my hiatus, which was Mafia 50.

[Robz888]

Yep, this one: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=11681.0

[schadd]

man, i should write a guide to winning town games by virtue of trying really hard: a self-help book by schadd

[Roadrunner7671]

I'm getting towny vibes off of schadd. I don't think his cases are overwhelmingly compelling, but they're something. Also, only faust makes a bunch of reads n' stuff as scum.

[schadd]

I don't think his cases are overwhelmingly compelling, but they're something.

if you lost your hedge trimmers, you can just borrow one of ours. we're good neighbors.

plus, that is something that two people sort of already said

[Roadrunner7671]

I don't think his cases are overwhelmingly compelling, but they're something.

if you lost your hedge trimmers, you can just borrow one of ours. we're good neighbors.

plus, that is something that two people sort of already said

If I don't have strong opinions, I don't have strong opinions. Your cases are okay. They're certainly not bad, but they're not enough to make me want to vote for Robz or LaLight.

[schadd]

If I don't have strong opinions, I don't have strong opinions.

oh muh gah. we lynched a traitor day 1, and scum knew who he was. you surely have to be able to find something to talk about. so far, you haven't even given me reason to believe that you read my case all the way

[2.71828.....]

Vote Count 2.4

Robz888 (2): Awaclus, faust
Roadrunner7671 (1): SpaceAnemone
schadd (1): Robz888
Awaclus (1): LaLight
LaLight (1): schadd

Not Voting (3): Eevee, Ichimaru Gin, Roadrunner7671

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch. Day 2 will last 10 days. The deadline for Day 2 will be Tuesday, 31 January,  at 1 AM forum time.

[Awaclus]

Just making sure I post enough.

[faust]

Also, only faust makes a bunch of reads n' stuff as scum.

...

[LaLight]

I am okay with vote: Robz now.

[Roadrunner7671]

Vote: Awaclus

[Awaclus]

Vote: Awaclus

Why not Robz?

[Robz888]

Just making sure I post enough.

This sort of thing over and over does not inspire confidence. Starting to feel like scum who has given up.

People don't like my schadd case, so I'll go Vote: Awaclus, since I seem to be the alternative.

[Robz888]

I am okay with vote: Robz now.

Nah, let me guilt you into going back to Awaclus!