Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Awaclus]

I'm tentatively willing to hammer RR.

[Joseph2302]

With Joseph voting for RR and not going to be around at deadline, RR HAS to be the lynch.

There is no other choice that can result in a scum lynch without bussing.

Agreed

I'd rather no lynch.  That buys us another day.

Really?
We no lynch, I die, then what?

PPE:2

[mcmcsalot]

I think we should probably do no claiming unless someone has a result of some kind to share which would be valuable as we are in mylo.

You were the one who said someone with a result should claim. So I did one day later.

Except a one-shot cop claim is super super easily claimed by scum, and your result was town which is the safe result for scum to claim and it doesn't exactly qualify as "valuable" in fact you also if you are town basically said "hey scum dont worry I'm a vt now so I can't hurt you at night and I didn't catch anyone". It's a pretty unhelpful claim.

[mcmcsalot]

I'm tentatively willing to hammer RR.

Who do you think his partners would be?

[The_Wine_Merchant]

I think we should probably do no claiming unless someone has a result of some kind to share which would be valuable as we are in mylo.

You were the one who said someone with a result should claim. So I did one day later.

Except a one-shot cop claim is super super easily claimed by scum, and your result was town which is the safe result for scum to claim and it doesn't exactly qualify as "valuable" in fact you also if you are town basically said "hey scum dont worry I'm a vt now so I can't hurt you at night and I didn't catch anyone". It's a pretty unhelpful claim.

What other kind of result would there have been at this point in the game?

There aren't any other investigation roles out there. And anyone that would have caught scum would have obviously have claimed by that point.

So basically you are saying that you said you wanted people to give results, but didn't actually want those results to be out there?

[EFHW]

With Joseph voting for RR and not going to be around at deadline, RR HAS to be the lynch.

There is no other choice that can result in a scum lynch without bussing.

Agreed

I'd rather no lynch.  That buys us another day.

Really?
We no lynch, I die, then what?

PPE:2

Then we have more than 2 hours to figure this out. This isn't an "any lynch is better than no lynch" situation.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

I'm tentatively willing to hammer RR.

Who do you think his partners would be?

EFHW would be my first guess. The second one, I am not as sure about. But maybe you? Maybe Awaclus?

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Speaking of RR. Anyone notice that he is not here for deadline and once again doesn't have his vote anywhere?

[The_Wine_Merchant]

I'm tentatively willing to hammer RR.

Who do you think his partners would be?

EFHW would be my first guess. The second one, I am not as sure about. But maybe you? Maybe Awaclus?

Oops. I thought you were asking me this question, but my answer is still valid.

[EFHW]

You know what, for RR to definitely be scum for me, ashersky, Awaclus and TWM need to be town. And I do have townreads on each of them.  I didn't at the start of the day, but things have evolved. Hearing from the roleblocker would have made this much easier.  But I'll take the chance and hammer if needed. at 12.

[Awaclus]

I'm tentatively willing to hammer RR.

Who do you think his partners would be?

I don't see how it's beneficial for town if I answer that question.

[mcmcsalot]

You know what, for RR to definitely be scum for me, ashersky, Awaclus and TWM need to be town. And I do have townreads on each of them.  I didn't at the start of the day, but things have evolved. Hearing from the roleblocker would have made this much easier.  But I'll take the chance and hammer if needed. at 12.

So you think me/gkrieg/rr are scum? Even with twm's copping of gkrieg making that impossible?

[mcmcsalot]

I'm tentatively willing to hammer RR.

Who do you think his partners would be?

I don't see how it's beneficial for town if I answer that question.

Because unless you think it's me and EFHW why would one scum be bussing his partner? I think it's possible ash/gkrieg/twm is the scum team.

[Roadrunner7671]

Speaking of RR. Anyone notice that he is not here for deadline and once again doesn't have his vote anywhere?

I have school!

[Awaclus]

Because unless you think it's me and EFHW why would one scum be bussing his partner? I think it's possible ash/gkrieg/twm is the scum team.

For the town cred.

[Awaclus]

Speaking of RR. Anyone notice that he is not here for deadline and once again doesn't have his vote anywhere?

I have school!

I have school too, I just don't attend a lot.

[The_Wine_Merchant]

Speaking of RR. Anyone notice that he is not here for deadline and once again doesn't have his vote anywhere?

I have school!

That is fair, and I don't begrudge that you can't be here right now because of that. But did you have school last night when you could have put your vote someone? Or the day before? Or the day before that? Or over the weekend?

You get my drift?

[Roadrunner7671]

I am happy to vote for you or gkrieg. I've made that clear. Sorry for tryong to prevent a quick hammer uf you or gkieg are in fact town

Sorry for typos

[Joseph2302]

Speaking of RR. Anyone notice that he is not here for deadline and once again doesn't have his vote anywhere?

I have school!

That is fair, and I don't begrudge that you can't be here right now because of that. But did you have school last night when you could have put your vote someone? Or the day before? Or the day before that? Or over the weekend?

You get my drift?

Agreed. If RR is town, he's been an unhelpful town player.
If I'm honest, so have I, but I'm good.

I am happy to vote for you or gkrieg. I've made that clear. Sorry for tryong to prevent a quick hammer uf you or gkieg are in fact town

Sorry for typos

Just vote someone then....

[Roadrunner7671]

"But I'm good." What does that mean?

[mcmcsalot]

I am happy to vote for you or gkrieg. I've made that clear. Sorry for tryong to prevent a quick hammer uf you or gkieg are in fact town

Sorry for typos

Twm is the better choice of the two of those because of the claim. I would actually prefer vote: twm

[Joseph2302]

"But I'm good." What does that mean?

Means that no-one is going to vote me

[ashersky]

We don't have the numbers to switch to anyone, really.

RR never getting hammered and being town requires all there scum on his wagon already or really lazy/bad/absent scum.

I mean, if Awaclus was lying AND RR was town, he'd just hammer here.  There's plenty of cover for it and the chance of the Town RB being successful is not super high.  And even if the Town RB is successful, town's in bad shape.

I don't have the strongest scum read on RR (as compared to other players), but POE is Occam's razor here.

[ashersky]

I think scum likes a no lynch better than a partner lynch.  That makes EFHW and mcmc slightly scummier.

[Joseph2302]

Gotta go RR though