So basically you are voting for Eevee because he OMGUSed silver, is what you are saying?
It's not borrowed OMGUS, but I think it's too early in the game (given yesterday's wash-out) for me to build much of a case. Let's start by explaining where my thinking came from, then I'll see whether I can gather things together into something case-shaped.
Relatively early in D1, I'd been town-reading Eevee: he's so nice, so it's hard not to! Then I re-read him in relation to the Eevee-mcmc clash. I still had an omgus vote on mcmc, though I'd developed a slight scum feeling on him as the game progressed a little. Over the course of that re-read, my town-read on Eevee dropped, my scum-read on mcmc diminished. The things mcmc had pointed out about Eevee's behaviour sensitized me a bit to a couple of things. So I was really second-guessing myself at the time on whether or not to find his "everyone agrees with me" attitude manipulative or just generally convivial. That part in particular came from mcmc's comments at #248.
There were several things I wasn't comfortable with in isolation, but during D1, and before the silver flip, it hadn't occurred to me to let them join up as a suspicion. There was the early suggestion of a blanket ban on theory. Now, I've never seen theory talk derail everything as much as it did here D1, so I can see why we don't want that to keep happening. But people being aware of the setup priors and mentioning possible roles/combinations doesn't seem anti-town at all. There's something about the tone of #197 doesn't feel quite right. Too quick to volunteer that he's town and build a big contrast, maybe?
There are a few places where he says or implies not-quite-true things, and then backs down when they're pointed out, like at #212/#220. Also at #249 where he asserts that this game is likely to have more PRs than in Covert Affairs (which is not true), which he backs down at #259 when challenged. There's a comment at #239 where gkrieg asks about the validity of the direction it was going in in the very next post. #253 is very self-aware, and awareness of scum meta is kind of scummy. #309 is quite defensive considering I hadn't voted him at all.
I mean, these are mostly all vague little things, and all from before the silver wagon, but I wasn't paying the right sort of attention at the time. So yeah, I think what I've got here is a suspicion rather than a case, but I'm happy voting for him at the moment.
...in my defense, this would be a lot easier in my native language.
I appreciate that you noticed it :-)