I think scum is hiding behind teamlyle's claim, and they have their explanation ready for tomorrow. "I know he wasn't that scummy, but we just had to do that because of the claim". I don't think we should lynch him unless we think he is scum.
Calamitas, if he is never the most likely person to be scum at the end of the day, why do we have to lynch him ever? I think we have better shots!
To the people explaining "it could be a scum ploy created in advance".. sure! Anything is possible, but I think we should go for the most likely thing. What in teamlyle's play makes you guys think he is scum? I think the claim is more likely to come from town, how many times have we seen a newer player drawing an exciting role and being too eager to claim it? I posit that as scum, teamlyle would want to make sure to live as long as possible (because it's another cool role), I don't think he'd want to push himself to the forefront like this. Especially with a claim that makes makes the potential downside of lynching you smaller - you more likely to get lynched!
I'm really not seeing this.
Silverspawn being mafia and wanting to push this lynch because there is a built in excuse fits too, I like where my vote is at (more than I usually would day 1!).