Let's see what comes out of a (10 page already) reread. The next part are mostly rambling notes, they are more for me than for other people, but you might find it interesting.
J Reggie comes out claiming non-tracker, silver (and I) votes for him because of it.
Eevee mentions that it's better not to make setup discussion (because town can PR-slip). Robz calls him out on it. Then mcmc votes for him
gkrieg mentions this is the first 9++ setup in which he isn't mafia, but apparently it's not true. (J Reggie calls him out, votes for him later)
ww "claims" PGO. Eevee and Robz believe him. Then ww says he was joking. Robz votes for him out of that (annoyed).
...J Reggie votes for Robz out of nowhere "because you're scum with Eevee." (no idea what to think of this)
mcmc: "Scum shaming just about everyone not voting witherweaver at this point." (he is not voting for ww). Eevee says that it's something that is unlikely to come from scum. Robz and mcmc still against ww, Calamitas points out (after Eevee had already done it) about the pre-game post to show that it was a joke. Teamlyle say it's clearly a joke, I push him about the problem with ww's actions and counterclaims. "that's fair enough I think"
Lalight: clearly a joke, but Robz is pushy, votes for Robz. Eevee sort of agrees. ww votes for Robz. Eevee thinks this isn't scum!Robz, but votes for mcmc. Teamlyle sheeps.
Eevee buddy-buddies, which makes JReggie slightly suspicious. Teamlyle adds another layer of suspicion "but I am not going to change my vote". I mention that ww has refused to clarify his claim, Teamlyle agrees it's bad.
gkrieg votes eevee, no explanation
silver defends eevee buddy-buddying and ww not clarifying
Robz sort of loses it over ww's reactions.
SA defends ww actions, but asks silver what would be scum indicative actions from ww (I think this is towny). silver declines to answer. Robz asks why. gkrieg sort of mysteriously says that ww is only difficult to detect D1
mcmc goes hard against ww, says he is wary of people defending him right out of the gate. when he sees ww clarifying he is not PGO, he votes for Eevee. Rails against silver a bit, then SA explains it away.
eevee thinks mcmc's behaviour is explained by him not reading the thread very closely. gkrieg asks, what does that mean. Probably town, he answers, but can't read mcmc very well.
mcmc makes a case against eevee (personally the only thing I see is eevee potentially trying to use the ww thing to lynch people voting for ww). eevee defends himself, silver votes mcmc over case, calamitas sides with eevee. mcmc says he was only trying to get ww to clarify, wasn't suspicious of him (is that really what happened...?)
J Reggie: "barking up a lot of the wrong trees" (ww and mcmc), wants to lynch Eevee or Robz, makes claim plan
Eevee keeps defending himself, ww and lalight (he's in this game?) vote for him. J Reggie thinks scumminess: Robz > Eevee > mcmc
Robz: mcmc is "winning" the argument, eevee is flailing. mcmc clearly town, eevee maybe scum? then votes J Reggie. // Lots of people saying J Reggie is trying to detract from the current conversation. Gkrieg disagrees scum!JR does that.
silver says eevee is being normal, mcmc is creating things where there is nothing. gkrieg says he is voting eevee because "gut". Lalight gives a uh confusing explanation
all of the sudden JReggie says he "hasn't caught [Robz] for the right reasons". ww votes him.
mcmc concerned about his wagon, asks people why they are voting for him (slightly scummy). Pushes SA, who unvotes
Teamlyle says pressure only on mcmc and eevee, probably both town while scum waits on the sidelines, unvotes (...towny?)
game slows down, eevee asks what's up, JReggie says he will sheep next vote, ww votes for him, so JReggie follows through. silver votes JReggie over self-vote (scummy)
Calamitas does not want to say anything, says he doesn't have enough info (dunno what to think of this). mcmc and eevee call him out on that. Calamitas completely unfazed by the pressure. Robz thinks it's towny.
eevee calls out silver for not trying to get an answer to his question about why people were voting for eevee. silver says he is lazy. votes for gkrieg, then goes back to JR. Calamitas says JR voting for himself is not scummy, it's JR-ish. mcmc disagrees, says JR is just bad at blending in
ww goes back to voting eevee. explains vote when asked. eevee explains himself.
Ok posting this already because computer crashed twice while writing this. Reads coming up.